Out of the Past is a dear little antique shop with fun treasures and friendly locals. They also…read moreoffer free postcards that feature a sweet and vintage-style illustration of this cozy spot. Perfect for sending a note home while on vacation! My husband and I try to visit every summer. During our most recent drop-in, the owners took the time to show us their collection of Cape May beach tags--a colorful collection of miniature works of art that dated back to the 70's! I also purchased a nice item there last year, and it is a cherished piece. Just a perfect slice of summer Americana! Do try to stop by.

This shop is just lovely! Very organized with interesting things. It was a joy walking through…read moreand browsing. I did find a sweet butter pat dish to add to my long time collection.

Was able to stop in while in Cape May for the weekend in May. It really is such a great place…read more Filled with wonderful vendors that sell such great items. Everything from jewelry, clothing, vintage items, artwork, etc. So much to see! I think the prices are great and the staff is always so friendly!

My wife loves this place when in West Cape May and I admittedly like browsing here as well. Shop…read moreis made up of individual vendor booths - lots of cool gifts and awesome stuff to browse. Place also has a small coffee shop inside. Great place to find memorable gifts or holiday gifts. Great place to wander around in and browse on a rainy day.

Bottom Line: A unique exterior and equally unique interior filled with locally made gifts, decor,…read morefurniture and such. The dark exterior of Quirk & Co. caught my eye and quickly drew me in. Equally unique as the almost black sided exterior is the warm and rich wood tones of the interior. A lot of stores on the pedestrian-friendly Washington Street Mall blur together in my head but this shop was very memorable. Aside from the fabulous exterior and interior, I really liked the staff! They were welcoming and friendly, very laid back and conversational but not over-bearing or pushy. That is totally the way to do it. Kinda like you're just having conversation at a cocktail party. A lot of the merchandise sold at Quirk & Co is made by local artisans and other merchandise is proudly made in the USA. They have an awesome collection of candles, jewelry, scarves, tote bags, mugs, pillows and such. I also think I saw some cool vintage painted furniture. Animal lovers and those looking for some Cape May memorabilia will find some good stuff here too. Overall a great little shop with terrific staff!

One thing that the pedestrian friendly shopping mall of Washington Street has is an abundance of…read morequirky cute shops. PRO TIP - Try to not say "adorable" or "cute" all day while shopping here, and it is literally impossible. Especially because Quirk & Co. is full of adorable and cute things! I fell in love with the mermaid art made out of pieces of seashells. And the doggie pillows. And the beautifully candles that just smell so fresh. Decor inside is spare and not too crowded. In the back, I think there is an area where they showcase chalk paint furniture. Nice!

I have been going there for years. The owners are wonderful. I have bought beautiful jewelry from…read morethem for a long time. One of my favorite stores on the mall.

Really cute store! I loved the aesthetics and decorations! They had gorgeous dresses for prom or…read moreany other fancy event! They had some cute clothes but nothing that really caught my eye. I'd definitely recommend stopping by Victorious if you're in Cape May just to see the decor in the store, it's very girly and adorable, many sparkles! I actually googled "thrift store" in cape May and this came up, I wouldn't say it's a thrift store at all - I think the jewelry in antique though but everything else is brand new.

Wow, I haven't been racially profiled in a minute. Shame on the owner or employee who decided to…read moreuse me as an example of what a shoplifter acts like to her employees. She clearly gestured in my direction and said something along the lines of "like her" while I was the only shopper left in the store. It was also that she deliberately waited until the few other (need I say fully Caucasian) customers left to speak as if I wasn't RIGHT THERE that made me go, hmm, ok then. I was just casually browsing small gifts for my daughter and about to pick out a gorgeous wind chime afterwards. The fact that I had to physically turn around, look them in the eye and say hello *not cool* welp... I get shoplifting is tough on small businesses, but no excuse. Needless to say I spoke up for myself, purchased what items I had in hand and GTFO. 2 stars for selection only. 1/8/25 I did promptly reply to the business owner who messaged me under her private account, photo posted.

I was in Cape May and saw some cool items in the window so I had to stop in and I'm glad I did…read more I found some really cool lotions and my friend picked up incense. It's a small shop but nicely organized. There is paid street parking as this is off the Washington Street shopping strip. I'll be back

September 2023 This was my first time to Cape May Wicker in beautiful Cape May. I've been to other…read morelocations and it never disappoints! There is ample parking in the store lot which is a huge plus to me. The store had furniture, beach towels, home decor, gardening sculptures, signs, flags, and exterior art. I always enjoy visiting to peruse the goods. There are many! Things to see and enjoy and the price points are phenomenal. The staff is helpful and friendly, when I was there there was a good deal of fall, Halloween, Thanksgiving and Christmas items. I'll be back!!

Love love love this store! Many choices, different ideas as well as your typical seashore deco, but…read moreclassy. No junk! My favorite store in Cape May!

Great little shop, off the beaten path. I shop here every time I come down to Cape May. The…read moreowners and staff are friendly. The store is packed with unique finds for the home as well as jewelry and other small gifts. Some of their prices are a big steep, but they do carry some really unique items that are worth the splurge. They also have the most adorable dog that hangs out in the shop! I always enjoy my visit and shopping experience at Wanderlust!

The woman at the counter ( older woman owner maybe? Named Sherry?) was incredibly rude to my 5 year…read moreold son. Based on other reviews she is a rude person and has been rude to kids before. She screamed at my son while we were in the store and terrified him. In addition, when we waked in she gave a dirty look and did not say hello. Then after she yelled, we left and she gave a dirty look as we left. I think she needs help. Wouldn't recommend

First off, this is a very cute shop. However, it is also a very expensive shop. I know they must be…read morehit with fees for importing items but whew, a chocolate bar should not cost upwards of $10 just for being from another country. They have lots of seasonal home decor items plus jewelry and knicknacks. Overall I'd say it's worth a stop in case you find a gem. I didn't find anything I wanted, personally.