The pizza was really good. We tried some new menu items and were pleased. The restaurant was clean…read moreand the people there were very friendly and courteous.

Everything was delicious even a salad yes a salad was fresh and let me tell you was closing time ,…read morewhen we went there and they took our order and that It meant a lot to us because we had a very rough day, and the pizza mmm delicious fresh omg the taste of the brick oven was amazing. I chat with the owner, she is very sweet kind and if the girl and the boy were her kids !! They are the same. Thank you for your kind words, I hope everyone is well.

We came here for lunch on our weekend getaway. We were immediately greeted my Cash. He was very…read morefriendly and polite. He gave us the option to sit wherever we wanted. Once sat he came over and told us what the have and old us about the pizzas. The ambience is fun and a lot for the kids to see and do, including arcades and a chalk wall. Take a look around. It will bring a smile to your face. I like how they all come in the 14" size and you can mix and match. We had half supreme and half buffalo. This pizza was amazing. Hot, flavorful and perfect. The excellent friendly service was throughout the elite meal. Cash even brought out a new frosty mug for my wife's beer they only come in cans and bottles). Next time we are in town, we will be back.

Super funky interior decor! So much fun. We shared a pepperoni pizza with basil for our family…read moreservice was great and they always kept our drinks filled. The only complaint is that it was pouring rain and the handicap parking spot which they have was obviously put in place sometime ago. They have multiple. Metal sculptures, and obstacles in the way so you can't walk on the sidewalk from the handicap parking spot all the way to the front door they should really consider moving the handicap spot to one that's closer to the door as they've blocked off the doorway, which is right next to the handicap parking space

This place is AMAZING! I have eaten and numerous restaurants that serve trout....and this place is…read morethe beyond others! We ordered several dishes, entrees and appetizers. All of the were more than we expected in taste, size and flavor! The service was exceptional and the staff were courteous, professional and sincere. Our tip reflected this service. The atmosphere was authentic and other patrons were also enjoying the essence this establishment offered. It was obvious that those who attend this fine eatery have been there before! We could instantly realize that the owner was on site and took exceptional pride in the atmosphere you experience. He even came to our table and made sure that we were 100% Happy with everything. Definitely a stand-out amongst others. 10 of 10! Than you!

We had three pizzas that were all delicious but the black goat was the highlight! The only reason I…read moretook a star away is for the space. Very awkward, tight walk to the bathroom and you have to walk through the kitchen to get there. The whole restaurant is tiny so when you walk in with a big party there's no place to stand and wait without it being very awkward. However, the pizzas more than made up for the inconvenience and this will be our first stop on our next trip back to Ellijay!

My wife said let's have pizza tonight, I went to get the mail and there was a Pappy's Pizza mailer…read more We haven't lived here long and only have tried one other pizzeria here. So we looked over the ad and made our choice, called in the order.A very friendly person took the order and help me with the the extras and 17 minutes later I was picking up dinner. Well when I walked in I was greeted warmly and genuinely. And as I was being rung up we have a friendly chat about the place and their pizza. I paid cash saving 3.5% credit card fee, and also received a veterans discount. The pizza was great, tasty crust with crispy edges. So much topping on the Nanny's meat lovers pizza. The sauce was perfect and we got a side order of the red sauce for dipping. Overall a wonderful experience and a great meal. I love to shop local when the owner takes care of you and has skin in the game . BTW bonus, the pizza was delicious cold for breakfast the next morning.

I was excited to try NY style pizza in Adairsville, GA. What was I thinking? I was very…read moredisappointed with the bland taste of the pizza. It's like they went out of their way to not season anything in the pizza, including the sauce. The service was slow. Neither of the two waitresses on duty acknowledged me when I entered the restaurant. Given they were busy, it takes no energy to at least acknowledge a patron as they enter. I waited about ten minutes before I was welcomed and my order was taken immediately. It was 45 minutes before my pizza arrived. I was extremely patient thinking I was going to experience a product that was tasty. Did I expect it to be exactly like real NY pizza? Heck no, I'm a realist. But never in my wildest dreams expect something so tasteless. The reasons that saved this establishment from receiving one star? The cheesecake was phenomenal and the place had the ambiance of Cheers without the warm greeting. If the food were better, I'd give them another try. Since I can get a decent product at a much lower price, I'll go to Papa John's when I want pizza.

As a new owner of a home in the area, this is my new favorite Italian restaurant. All I had this…read moretime was a meatball Parmigian sub to-go. I ordered it in advance, it was coming out of the oven when I got there, and it was delicious. Not the biggest meatball sub that I've ever had. But it wasn't expensive, either. The people are VERY friendly here. I can't wait to go back on my next trip to Murphy in a few weeks. I'll have to try their pizza and update my review. But if first impressions are any indication, it's going to be another 5-star experience.

Something has changed, pizza very dry not as good as before…read more Also, phone order is never ready when promised, have to wait over 15 minutes

First time eating here and we had it to go. A large cheese and a custom pizza with pepperoni,…read moreonions, olives, and jalapeños. When we got it home and ate the pizzas...so good! We really enjoyed the pizzas! Will definitely be back!

I have been here in the past but it had been about a year since my last visit. When I went this…read morepast Saturday I was super impressed. I immediately thought this must be new ownership because Wow what a difference. We were greeted at the door by a super friendly hostess who showed us to a table. Our waitress was attentive and friendly. The atmosphere was wonderful. We ordered a supreme pizza and it was delicious! It was cooked perfectly! I ordered the cheesecake for dessert which I was told they have shipped in from Brooklyn and oh my it was so yummy. Best pizza and best service!

I always like to go to locally owned places. It's better to keep your dollars running around your…read moreneighborhood than off buying somebody a yacht. That being said, we called in order in my phone. Very friendly over the phone service. Explained the deals they had because this was the first time you'd ever ordered from here. Drove down to pick it up 20 minutes later. Okay as instructed and boom pizza's done in the box. Hot and fresh ready to go. Took them home for the four of us. Bottom line is they were perfect. We got a meat lovers and a supreme crust was crispy. Not overdone. Lots of toppings. End-to-end great flavors. We enjoyed our dinner. Now. Tomorrow morning I've got two pieces for cold pizza for breakfast. We will definitely be coming back.

If you like bland pizza, this is the place to go. If you like slow service, this is the place to…read morego. If you want overpriced pizza, this is the place to go. If you want to be waited on by the hard working owner, this is the place to go. If you want a warm, inviting place to dine-in, this is not the place to go, it's strictly takeout. Why the two stars? Because, despite the poor food quality, it's clear to me the guy that owns this place is trying. I'll give him more opportunities to increase his stars. At least until I see no improvement.

Crust is PERFECT idk what else to say. Service is nice and spacious inside and outside…read more Yum yum yum.

Great pizza. My favorite pizza in Blue ridge Friendly staff and…read more Consistently good.

Delicious pizza and Greek salad. Very clean restaurant with Great atmosphere Would highly…read morerecommend!

Excellent gluten free pizza and Italian salad. Friendly servers. Reasonably priced…read moreClose to our campsite. Not much ambiance

They're vegetarian pizza with pepperoni is outstanding! Always cooked to perfection with a generous…read moreamount of toppings. The woman who runs the pill is very friendly and has made some great suggestions. This is a great place when you're wanting to have a lazy evening and not cook. You can either eat there or get it to take home.

Everything you think of when you are craving good pizza, with all the additional amazingness that…read morecomes with wood fire style done to perfection. Don't go in expecting a thin wood fire pizza that won't fill you. We ordered like we usually would for this style and took an entire pizza home. Tiffany makes a mean pie, and is sweeter than a Georgia peach to boot. If you are in the Ellijay area or anywhere close, stop in and leave satisfied!