** Tully Rinckey's response to my reviews is disingenuous. We already addressed this matter directly with the firm. The only options presented were to continue paying them to correct mistakes in their work--despite their already having the necessary information and documentation--or to close the matter and receive only the unused portion of the retainer. They had the opportunity to resolve this privately and chose not to. **
My 88 year old Mom and I retained Tully Rinckey after a year and a half of fighting dangerous snow/ice, blocked ADA access, egress aisles, repeated maintenance failures, and misleading "100% maintenance-free" representations in our 55+ senior community.
We hired the firm to advise us regarding breach of contract, fraud, discrimination, and landlord retaliation under New York Real Property Law § 223-b, and to prepare a strong demand letter.
Attorney Ashleigh Rousseau billed $1,815 to review our materials, research ownership, and draft the demand. Despite having the necessary information already directly in front of her, the draft was a complete failure. She addressed it to a former employee, mishandled basic ownership and recipient details, misstated our timeline, and omitted major facts and claims.
Instead of forcefully addressing the retaliatory non-renewals, rent increase, ADA and egress issues, misleading "100% maintenance-free" representations, and serious impact on our household, Rousseau's draft merely asked for clarification, future procedures, and meetings.
The demand read like an invite for tea and crumpets rather than the powerful legal demand we were promised.
The necessary information was not missing; Rousseau simply failed to accurately reflect the facts we paid her firm to review. Between her subpar work and the "supervising" attorney's billing, a majority of our $4,000 retainer was consumed producing a defective draft. When the firm expected us to continue paying to correct Ashleigh's errors, we refused. As a result, we lost the majority of our retainer and walked away with nothing.
I absolutely do not recommend Ashleigh Rousseau or Tully Rinckey.
Run. read more