We have been a Gionino's family for years and never really considered trying Uncle Spikes until my son had friends over and they requested it. I must admit, their pizza is really good! We all loved it! Big picture.. The prices are pretty reasonable and they have a great variety of options on the menu. Ordering is easy and straight forward. But, most importantly the pizza is great with a crust on the thicker side and a healthy portion of cheese (ok, it's not exactly "healthy"). If you want authentic NY style pizza try Pizza DiLauro, if you want filling, delicious Ohio pizza...try Uncle Spikes! read more

I purchased a $30 discount certificate for Uncle Spike's Pizzeria so I ordered a large cheese pizza and a small thin crust cheese pizza for takeout; ordering is easy and efficient. The menu is pretty straightforward, plenty of pizza options, calzones, a single salad and a couple of beverages. Uncle Spikes is half of a small building just East of the center of Aurora, the shop is takeout only, a simple counter, one cooler and the kitchen behind a wall in back. My pizzas were ready and nicely cooked; the presentation is simple the pizza boxes are just plain, no logos or writing which is fine. The pizzas are very good, the crust is excellent, the cheese near perfect, and the cooking was the way I prefer it a bit well done. The only problem I had was that there was almost no sauce on my pizzas; with a good sauce these could be some of the best pizzas in the area. I did enjoy the pizza over the next couple days, especially since I could add some toppings including chopped and sun dried tomatoes; the reheated pizza is excellent. The large pizza with the regular crust is big enough that 1/4 of the pie makes a good meal; the small thin crust is also very good since this makes for an even cheesier taste. Uncle Spike's does a really good pizza, the portion size is generous, the quality is excellent, the only issue for me was the lack of sauce, I don't know if this is their usual approach or if it was just a mistake. I do appreciate the nice and simple approach, no frills, no hype just good take out pizza. read more

See all

Good service. Great prices. Good smell of food in the location. One of the ones in the city . Worth stopping in read more

Uncle Spike’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Ohio

This is a takeout or delivery establishment. No dining room. I ordered their basic cheese and a rustic pizzas. Both were delicious. Very good crust and toppings. Friendly stuff and pizza was ready at quoted time. read more

Very good pizza! Very friendly staff. Will definitely be back! The large is HUGE!!!

Great Pizza And Wings . Locally owned and operated .A very good value for the money

Heard about the awesome reviews. So thought I'd give them a try. Got the New Yorker with pepperoni and sausage. It was steaming hot when I picked it up. Just out of the oven. The box is huge. So best idea is if picking up have room to get the box in your car to lay flat. Seriously. The pizza lives up to the hype of how big it is. The pieces are huge. $25 later it is probably worth it. It's huge. Toppings are delicious. Wish there was a bit more. I think that was a bit skimpy. Still good. I am a 2-3 piece pizza person normally. I struggled to eat the whole piece. It's good. Not spectacular but good. Dough is ok, sauce is ok, toppings good quality just not enough. I like the toppings to go to the edges and this didn't. Doughy at the end of the pieces. I'll go back try something else. Advice is to call early they seem to get busy. Picked up the pizza at 5:30 and the calls coming in were not going to be out till 7:20. Wow! read more

Uncle Spike’s Pizzeria - New Yorker piece with pep and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Ohio

Deep Dish 5+ pound monster pie...Chicago style has nothing on this pie...30 minutes outside of Cleveland & worth the drive to get one read more

See all

This place is amazing! We ordered a medium rustic pizza, and my wife and I will have leftovers for the rest of the week! The pie was fresh, the fresh dough was spectacular, and the owner was beyond amazing! Mike has been jamming pizzas out if this location since 2019, and he has such a passion for delivering great pizza with even better service. If you live nearby Aurora, you have to check this place out! read more

Uncle Spike’s Pizzeria - Rustic pizza with sausage, peppers, artichoke hearts - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Ohio

This has to be the best Pizza in Aurora!! I froze the leftovers and ate them about a month later and it was still delicious!!!!

We have tried Uncle Spike's pizza two different times. The first time we got the chicken bacon ranch pizza, which is a white sauce pizza and the next time we tried the rustic pizza, which is a red sauce pizza. Both were really tasty and good choices. We are still experimenting to find our perfect pizza, so we will try many more. read more

Seriously the largest pizza I've ever seen east of NYC! Delicious, cheesy, - crispy crust and excellent sauce. Everyone was wowed by the size of the New York style pie - worth the price. It's very impressive! The owner and staff are very friendly and helpful. So happy we discovered this little gem tucked away off 306 in Aurora. read more

Excellent pizza! Tried the New Yorker last night and it was delicious. Each slice is a foot long! Delivery was fast and easy. read more

Uncle Spike’s Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Ohio

Great pizza! Calzone is huge a regular can really feed 2. Just a heads up if you have picky eaters who like to pick toppings off, the bake their toppings under the cheese. read more

Giant, delicious pizza and the owner waited 10 minutes after closing for us to pick it up.

Their NY Style pizza is something to go out of your way for and reminded me of the pizzas we enjoyed in Seaside on the NJ coast. This NY style pizza is so big you will surely have plenty left over; remember, the mark of a great pizza is that it tastes great cold the next morning with black coffee, enjoy! read more

First time trying Uncle Spike's. The pizza rated as "Terrific pizza". Service rated as "Great service!" We will try chicken wings next time!! read more

Easily one of the best pizza spots around. Our go to spot on fridays!! Definitely recommend the New Yorker but make sure to call early on the weekends!!! They get busy. read more

Uncle Spike’s Pizzeria - Pepperoni New Yorker pizza - foot long slices! - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Ohio

Tried out this place after hearing good things. I had a cheese calzone (the menu says for 1-2 people) and it was indeed massive! I will definitely get it again and probably check out their pizza next time. read more

New York style pizza is number one in the area you have to get it with sausage and pepperoni There's no way you'll finish it and it still good the next Day read more

Very good pizza. We have been here nearly ten times in the past year and have never been disappointed. Be warned: the New Yorker is GIGANTIC as in it barely fit in my car. I absolutely recommend Spikes for their pizza. read more

Seriously good pizza! I ordered a large rustic and WOW, was it Large! Hot, fresh and tasty - we munched on it for 2 more meals. I'm going back. read more

The New Yorker is the closest thing to real New York pizza I have had since moving to Ohio.

I LOVE THE GREEN MAN PIZZA OMG. Honestly a lot of "homeowned" pizza shops are okay but let me tell you Uncle Spikes are above and beyond. I highly recommend the super gyro and the loaded tots! If you're disappointed by this place then you need to see a doctor and get your taste buds checked out read more

If you like New York-style pizza, this place has the best stuff around! The box is as large as my stove top... it is insane. My husband loved the wings (I did not try them). This is our favorite pizza that we have found so far in Ohio! read more

The three stars here doesn't mean I disliked the pizza. It was just pretty middle of the road. Pluses: Thoroughly cooked. Generous amount of cheese. Even topping distribution. Minuses: Very little sauce. Way too much cheese (I've never said this before). Between the scant sauce and the pile of cheese, the flavor of the toppings were just overpowered by dough and cheese. Again, not bad. Just not my thing. read more

One of the best places the New York style pizza service had been wonderful they've helped me out the door or brought the massive pizza to my car for me. The counter area is always clean and clear, not much waiting space inside. read more

One of my favorite places to grab a weekly pizza from, and great people working there.

Sooo. I liked the za. It wasn't bad but not as good as the hype. I was really excited for the new Yorker having been a resident of Brooklyn for a minute... it's not new York style sadly. Just a gigantic Midwest style with a medium thick crust. Lacked sauce but good cheese blend. Topping proportions were good and delivery time was on point. Just not what we were hoping for. Also my salad was wilted and brown like it had been sitting out for days... :( all together decent pizza if you feel like changing it up here and there with your normal mom and pop pie place, but not going to be my new rebuy spot by any means. read more

The pizza lacks flavor. Tried the deep dish, it was literally a messy pile of slop. Sorry but its just not worth it, salads are pretty not exciting too. Only good thing I have had there is the smores pockets. read more

Have not answered phone last 2 weekends. I can only assume they are closed for business.

Uncle Spikes is THE BEST! Not just good pizza but OUTSTANDING people as well! My family and I went to eat sushi (right next to Uncle Spike's), my son ended up getting sick while walking back to the car. The owners came out with a sprite and a water to help with my son! These guys will have a fan for life! Can't express enough of my gratitude for the small gesture they exhibited to my family!! I will ALWAYS go to Uncle Spike's whenever we can! They are the salt of the earth and the cream of the crop! read more

Pizza was good, reminds me of the old guy's pizza. Appear to still be working out kinks with new staff but that's to be expected since they just opened. read more

Best pizza around. I have been seaeching for a good NY style pizza for years and this is it! Call early on weekends but worth the wait! Soooo good!!! read more

Tried Uncle Spike's for a second time recently. Their traditional pizza is a thin crust on the base and thick on the edges. Sauce is decent and they're a little skimpy on the toppings but heavy on the cheese. We also had an order of wings and a salad and I'd rank those about the same as the pizza. It's pretty middle of the road stuff and the prices are about in line with what the other pizza places are charging these days. As of this writing, they've been open around two months or so, and I'd think they've worked out most start up issues. I'd really like to see the place succeed. We need a decent pizza place in Aurora and so far, I don't believe anyone has this game figured out very well. read more

I'm a pretty picky pizza eater, but this place has something for everyone. The New York style pizza really has slices that are about a foot long. The deep dish pizza takes a little extra time to cook, I've heard it's good but we haven't tried that one yet. The regular pizzas have good topping choices, the sauce is good. The crust could've been a little crunchier so the next time I will ask for that. The garlic Parmesan wings were meaty and yummy. read more

Tried to order Uncle Spike's this past weekend, but phone rang and rang with no answer. Either they weren't answering or they were unexpectedly closed when website, Yelp and FB said they were open. COVID-19 is a boon to pizza places not an excuse for poor service. We'll give them one more shot to see if they can improve their poor reliability. read more

Ordered from here 5-6 times, very consistent and delicious. Great food at a fair price and they are nice!

This pizza is the best pizza I've had in northeast Ohio. I'm from NY and the pizza in northeast Ohio is highly disappointing, but not Uncle Spike's. We usually order pepperoni and do pick up and have never had any issues. read more

I grew up in South Jersey so I cut my teeth on seafood straight from the ocean, white corn, the original Philly cheesesteak and really, really good pizza. I can tell you that Uncle Spike's is the real deal! read more