We just go into the door at Doug's Seafood Market as it was closing…read more We were excited that we got in just in time due to the market closing,m for the day. When you walk in, you can immediately tell the quality of seafood that's available which was very good! We got a pound of shrimp and enjoyed it later. We felt the prices were fair and the service was great! I'd definitely return for more next time I'm in Ocean Isle Beach!!!

Solid local spot with a ton of fresh seafood. They had all sorts of fish, shrimp, oysters, crab…read morecakes, scallops, and more! They also carry a bunch of sauces and seasonings for all your seafood prep needs. The people working there are super nice and helpful, five stars!

Love Sheffields, convenient, friendly, well stocked with quick pick up items. Fishing, groceries,…read moregas, boat gas, drinks, seafood. Many trips to OIB each year. Try to always stop in Sheffields. Just a fun place to check out.

On my many trips into Ocean Isle Beach, I have made Sheffield's a stop on many occasions. It is the…read morequick or emergency "go-to" place (convenience/gas) on the island, just at the end of the Odell Williamson Bridge as you come in from the mainland over the Intercostal Waterway. If you are looking to make big grocery store trips to get a big bunch of food or supplies for the week, you probably are going to head to the Lowes Foods right back over the bridge or the Food Lions near Sunset Beach or Shallotte. But for quick things, a few food items or convenience store things, beer, etc. then Sheffield's fits the bill. A huge walk in beer cooler, always nice especially when it is so hot outside! There is a small seafood shop in the back as well. Quick ice stop here is probably the main reason we see it so much. Very nice people working, great location, and handy items make Sheffield's one place you will probably visit many times if you make it out to OIB anytime for a vacation.

We really enjoyed it here, the food and service was amazing , hopefully we can go down to the beach…read moreand here again!

Excellent fresh seafood and wonderful key lime pies. Very friendly service. Close to Ocean Isle…read moreBeach.

The seafood boils are amazing. Best scallops I have ever had! Everything was cooked to perfection…read more Highly recommended!

This is a really nice local fish market in sunset beach. Friendly staff and really fresh fish…read more They also have really delicious key lime pie. They have so many different types of seafood. They have some pre sliced and all ready to go. Very convenient and fresh. They also have items for sale and really nice stuff. I recommend the salmon but if your a seafood lover check it out and also don't forget the pie. Key lime is my absolute favorite and it was super good and definitely didn't disappoint only regret was getting a slice and not a whole pie lol.

When I used to live in Holden Beach I would stop buy to get some fresh fish for dinner and I've…read morelearned that there is all different kinds of seafood available to try and over ten years of experience with them I've never had any problems with them I highly recommend them Thanks John

BEST fresh seafood around. Mr Larry is the nicest person you could ever meet. We only buy here…read more NEVER disappointed !!!! 5 stars hands down.

My husband and I went to Ocean Isle beach yesterday (31 May 2026) to visit the Museum of Coastal…read moreCarolina. Afterwards, we had lunch at Ocean Isle Fish Company. We sat outside and it was chilly from the winds. We didn't want to sit inside, we wanted to enjoy the views around us. I had ahi tuna and Tony had a fried Mahi Sammich. Everything was delicious and the food came out fast. Friendly service by the wait staff.

Oh good gracious!!! Seafood and a view, yes please. We love eating at this place. It is always on…read morepoint. I didn't get any pictures of anyone's food on this trip. Having too much fun with the Grands and the Kids. We highly recommend the fried shrimp, fried clams and fried scallops. They were all completely amazing. My 3 year old grandsons even ate them and they always want chicken. The service is always on point as well. Super sweet servers and great staff. We had a party of 12 every single night of our trip.

great place honest good guys !! fresh seafood !! I will definitely go there, especially with me…read morebeing an island girl. It's hard to find seafood, good quality and not get ripped off from the price. He's fair price fresh seafood.

I have used them numerous times fresh seafood, always I have always been pleased and pricing decent…read moreto

Visit this area about once year. Always get at least one take-and-bake from Feast. Always more…read morethan adequate portions well prepared and easy to fix with quality ingredients. Easy to order online and ready as requested.

First experience with this restaurant was enough to make me NEVER go back. Lied to before we ever…read morewalked in the door about wait times over the phone. We left a diff restaurant with an hr+ wait bc this place supposedly only had a 20-30 min wait. We arrived, checked in and were told when one specific table leaves that we could have their table. There were other open tables but told they didn't have the staff to serve them. So we waited 30 min. and that table did leave on time. However, during that time at least 2 or 3 other parties came to the restaurant and were sat in those empty tables. We were told they had prior reservations AND that apparently they had someone already coming to fill the table we were originally promised. We could wait another 30-45 min for someone else to leave OR sit our 6 adults and 1 child separately at two high back booths with no contact. If it had been my decision I would have walked out immediately. No customer service by host or manager who came to hear it out. The rest of my party was too hungry to wait or go somewhere else so they sat separate and ate. I refused to give them my business and never will. VERY POORLY MANAGED and it obviously starts at the front of the house. My wife had the apricot salmon ($28) its was extremely bland. My 5 yr old son had shrimp and fries ($14!!) which were extremely mediocre at best. I've had better at Culver's. Restaurant looks poorly organized. Needs a renovation, and OBVIOUSLY some new staff who know how to provide customer service in a service industry. Ambiance was like a dive bar trying to serve food to survive. They won't be around long.