So we went a 1 hour and 10 minute drive to see the Ohio Bird Sanctuary. (loved it) I told my toddler we would go get Ice Cream and Pizza. I read the reviews of Warriors and decided to give it a try. I bought a baby ice cream cone which my three year old ate it all... Then I ordered a garlic cheese pizza and a pepperoni, green pepper, mushroom pizza. It was done in maybe 10 min. ( just enough time for my toddler to eat the last bite of his cone.) My review of this pizza is high. I have a few favorites around, and I am very picky when it comes to pizza. The sauce was great, the dough you could tell was homemade and it was very good. There is a garlic and Parmesan on the crust I believe. I ate more than planned and my toddler ate the hole garlic Parmesan pizza I ordered too... Give this a try you won't regret it read more

See all

The food is good. The service is exceptional. The ambiance is good for a small place. Never open

I would give more stars, but when you order a pizza with no tomato sauce and white sauce instead you should get what you ordered. My fiancé is deathly allergic to tomatoes and they knew that. read more

I'm an out of towner, but everyone was telling me to try this place. I got the pepperoni melt, it was soooooooo good!!!! Probably one of my top 10 pizzas of all time. Staff was super friendly, place was jam packed. Someone needs to order their lasagna pizza and post some pics. read more

Warrior Pizza & Ice Cream - Pepperoni Melt, sooooo good!!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ontario, Ohio

See all

I don't hate this place and like to visit when I'm home visiting family. There's a nice varied menu and everything is fairly good. It's a good place for kids and to maybe meet up with old friends. read more

This place has given me lots of mixed opinions, Let's start of with the food The food was made well, they have a robust menu with, a-lot of variety. I went her during the day and they were so busy, there was no one to direct people how it works. i went to sit down, and I did not even know, you had to stand in line, and then sit down and wait for the food to be brought to you, i saw so many teens running around doing multiple different task as if it look like a nascar race track, On person was handling men, then the same person put a pizza in the box, (with no glove) it was chaotic, it was strange that in a sit down restaurant, that then bathroom was out side in the back, as if it was like a gas station. I like the art work and the decor the owner is proud to show off his faith it get to send positive message to people, But I think one of the best ways to improve the restaurant from my perception is to not run it like a factory, that's at least what it felt like to me. It is true that the intentions are definitely their, this owner was very concerned about feedback, so that is definitely a positive thing, I hope to come again to see when it gets even better. read more

Warrior Pizza & Ice Cream - Chicken ranch pizza - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ontario, Ohio

Food is decent, pizza is good. The biggest drawback for this restaurant is the hours--closed weekends and Monday, it seems like every time you want to grab ice cream or a pizza, they aren't open. It's an Ontario staple. read more

My wife was in the mood for some sherbet and likes the quality of what Warrior offers... sign out front said closed Friday July 15... today is July 18 and still closed. This place is closed half the time we go for ice cream or sherbet (we don't go for the pizza). So we will bypass and not go out of our way as it's always a gamble whether or not this "open year round" place is open or closed read more

Absolutely the best subs in, Mansfield, Ashland, Wooster, or anywhere . I love the Roman sub and I add mild yellow banana peppers and mushrooms. It is killer, jammed full and overflowing with meats, cheeses, vegetables, and sauce. Nowhere else have I gotten such a filling sub for the amount of money. If you haven't ate here yet, you are really missing terrific food for a great price ! Alot of bang for the buck here. My favorite place for subs, pizza, etc, and they have much ,much more to choose from. You won't be disappointed ! read more

This is an award winning pizza place with a rotating sherbet flavor. You can come for the ice-cream, but you are here for the amazing pizza. Try the GPS (Green pepper, pepperoni, sausage) or the Pepperoni Melt with it's over the top amount of pepperoni. They have an awesome sauce on their pizzas that is just the right blend of herbaceous and sweet. The calzones are my go-to and I highly recommend them, but eat with a friend. Even the small is too much for one person. The Chicken Parm sub is outstanding, but if you get it, eat it there. It suffers from transportation and you won't get the right crispy chicken exterior and saucy unctuousness if you let it sit in a bag for the trip home. read more

They make the pizza in a unique style the service is quick and the ice creams and shakes are soooo good, their is a good variety of foods for everyone's selection read more

Very good pizza, most of the time. Would have given 5 stars if they were more consistent. I actually prefer the calzones. Great subs, try the Sicilian. Great ice cream. read more

Stop to have a sub best one in miles, just like the pizza! Never disapppoints.i just might get a pizza to go read more

See all

Our favorite pizza and subs in town. The food is always consistent and tastes great. Definitely recommend trying the pepperoni melt pizza!

We ordered pizza tonight and the sauce tastes sickeningly sweet. They have overloaded it with sugar and have no other spice flavor in it. I am pretty easy-going with pizza and I found this to be nearly inedible. Their ice cream is awesome and service is great, just beware if you don't like mega mega sweet sauce because this won't be for you!! read more

I'm not sure what would bring you to little Ontario, Ohio but if you happen to be in the area, the Warrior is a great place to get pizza. We got a meat lovers pizza. It was not only super affordable, but also was absolutely loaded with delicious toppings. There were more toppings than most places put on pizzas, that's for sure. I was honestly surprised at how good it was. Next time, I'd like to try their subs as they look great as well. read more

The pizza and ice cream both met the hype. If I ever pass this area again I'll have to stop. Service and prices are both fair as well.

Have had nearly have the menu. It has something for everyone. The pizza is the best in town. Be prepared to wait, although generally having a lot of people behind the counter, it takes forever to get the food when driving through or sitting in. read more

I must be the only person this place absolutely always hands order dripping all over the place. The1st time, I was handed a chocolate soda with the lid not on completely. It was spilling out of the cup when they handed it to me and then, the lid came off completely spilling chocolate sofa into my Audi's perforated leather seats! That was a couple months ago. Last night I decided to give them another chance. I ordered a chocolate sundae. I heard one worker tell another one to just use hot fudge topping. I corrected the employee emphasizing I ordered a sundae with vanilla ice cream and regular chocolate syrup. They signaled they understood. Again I was handed a dripping product. It was so melted when I got to my home 10 minutes away, it was all over me and my car. The topping was thick hot fudge topping, not regular chocolate syrup. I am done with the way this place cares nothing about what they serve. Can't even put a lid on correctly. read more

Big thumbs up for Warrior Pizza located in the middle of nowhere in Ohio. I was taken here by some friends who moved to the area. We had a garlic pepperoni pizza - it was delicious, medium thickness crust, etc. This place is great: great hometown ambience, delicious pizzas (lots of unique varieties) and ice cream creations. For an electric oven pizza joint, this place is a gem. Check it out, I say! read more

The best shredded chicken sandwiches in town! The pizza is delicious too, especially if you let it cool off a few minutes so the square slices turn into a gelatinous brick of cheesy goodness. And of course, on those hot summer Ohio nights, get yourself some ice cream. The new owner has done a nice job retaining what made this place a success while keeping it clean. I do miss the old arcade games though. read more

We stopped for ice cream two days in a row! The apple dumpling sundae is amazing. The combo of hot and cold is really well done. Just order one and enjoy. It's a really generous portion, I couldn't finish the whole thing. They have a drive thru which moved quickly and they're very friendly. My only complaint was the lighting inside was so bright that it hurt my eyes. The ice cream is worth the lighting :-) read more

Excellent pizza! We have eaten many pizzas during our day. We stopped here for the first time today and found the employees so friendly, very informational and the pizza was so good. After ordering we took a seat and we watched as the food went by our table (being served to others) looked delicious! Warrior Pizza and Ice Cream has such a large selection of food on their menu and the food prices were very reasonable. Make this a place to stop this summer. There is something for everyone on this menu so, we will have to stop again and again, . We can't wait to stop again. This time we will save room for ice cream (it looked irresistible). You won't regret it. read more

Just had the best pizza of my life! Tomato, mushroom and chicken, with the amazing warrior sauce and homemade crust. PERFECT. Plus they have great subs and ice cream. Give it a try. You won't regret it. read more

This is my favorite pizza in town. They have great sub sandwiches too. Get there early so you can find a place to sit, or you'll be out of luck. The food is always fresh and delicious. They also have wonderful ice cream, including awesome sherbet flavors, the best turtle sundae around, root beer floats and old fashion hard dip ice cream. We order out, eat in, stop by after school...we just love The Warrior! Look up their many reviews on Google too! read more

Over-rated. Don't get me wrong it's good pizza but I won't make the drive to get to it when there's better options closer.

Warrior is hands down one of my favorite places to eat. Actually ordered pizza from them for my wedding. It was a huge hit. Always have something different always delicious. The staff is helpful and make sure you have everything you need. I literally can't say anything bad about them! read more

Well if your hungry for pizza and subs come here just plain good. But they have a full menu ! And don't forget to leave room for desert! read more

See all

Best place for pizza and ice cream family friendly atmosphere. If you come during busy hours you will have a wait as to be expected making fresh foods. Great owner who really cares about what he does. The pizza has more of a sweet sauce so if you are looking for more of a tart or really cheap pizza this is not really the place to go. You pay for what you get and here you pay for great pizza! read more

Good family restaurant. Dad and daughters run this place and they do it very well!! Try the pizza - excellent!!

Always great pizza! Their subs are very good too...and they have a HUGE selection of desserts! There's something for everyone here. Our out of town family always want to visit the Warrior before leaving to go back home. read more

I'll never get pizza anywhere else. Amazing! I've had pizza all over the country only to find pizza heaven 15 minutes away. Eat it while it's hot. The outer crust is like eating breadsticks. The sauce is slightly sweet. Man is it good. read more

The place is small but very nicely decorated. The food was good nothing amazing, especially for the time it takes to get it. I will say that the staff is very young or at least seems that way. They make no eye contact, a few of them kept touching their faces and one preceeded to pick at her chin then without hesitation picked up a pizza box and got an order together. I also witnessed multiple people handling money and then going to the back and prepare pizzas. They used their shirts to wipe their hands, the girls hair, while under a hat, draped across their faces and hovered over the food being prepared. There just seems to be no supervision or concern for hand washing. I gave 2 stars because the ice cream was good but I won't be back based on how the preparation and unkept look overall in the kitchen. Basic customer service and food handling training would make this place at least 4 stars. read more

Great pizza and fun atmosphere. Good food in classic small town pizza shop. Ice cream is good as well.

The Apple dumplings are to die for and everything is very reasonably priced. The complaint I have is the wait can sometimes be rather long during the summer. read more

Recently picked up a couple of large cheese pizzas that I ordered online through their website. Crust and sauce are made fresh daily and it really shows. I definitely prefer the Papa's Gondola cheese pizza, but this is VERY good as well. Will definitely come back of try more of their offerings - I'm looking forward to it :) read more

We come here quite often the pizza melt is amazing as well as the ice cream! Family-owned little pizza joint friendly environment and we love the outside seating. We drive a little further away and pass a couple other ice cream shops on the way but this is hands-down the best one! read more

Warriors, is seriously one of my favorite pizza places ever! Always polite service, always delicious food, and always a smile on everyone's faces! read more

This is what I compare all other Pizza places to. Subs are also outstanding. The staff goes out of their way to satisfy the customer. Don't see something on the menu, they will gladly make what you were craving. Highly recommended!! read more

This is a great place! They have the best veggie subs and I also love the garlic cheese bread pizza. If you havent been here, you should go!