This used to be my go to stop because of its selection and location but it has unfortunately deteriorated with time. On two separate occasions now I have found expired seltzers in their refrigerated section. The first time I didn't realize (because I assume things are not expired if they are being sold) only to open the box to crushed cans (a clear sign of being bad). The box had expired in 2023! The second time I brought it to the attention of the staff who unfortunately did not believe me. I can't keep risking spending money on alcohol that isn't drinkable so I will have to go to one of the many other liquor stores in the area next time. read more

Very Nice Folks & Great Selection as well as good Location Only Setback is No Website.

Witty's used to be the "Go To" place for hard to find liquors when I lived in East Brunswick, particularly premium rums that I would send to my family in Scandinavia. Time has not been kind to Witty's and now it's just another dark, dank liquor store featuring more of the same. Bottom shelf wines and liquors,domestic beers and a scattering of those insipid flavored sparkling waters with cheap malt alcohol that seem to be the tipple of choice recently. Visit if you're in the market for that gallon jug of Gallo so popular in South River on weekends. read more

Great prices, excellent selections and friendly personnel:-) I really appreciated their personal approach!

Wittys has the best prices and all the liquor it has 3 other locations Metro liquors down the street in linden and another location in Woodbridge next to shoprite. read more

I live in California, used Wine-Searcher to find my favorite bottle of Cabernet Sauvignon. A 2010 Staglin Estate. Found two magnums of it through Whitty's discount liquor offered for $299.99 a bottle. I purchased online on the 20th of February. Today is April 20th, 8 weeks later. I have called a dozen times to find out where my order is. Finally, I cancelled my order by phone 3 weeks ago for non delivery and requested my credit card be credited. To this day, I have not seen a credit. As a note, one of the employees did tell me that they do not ship to California. So why did they charge my card? I am working with my credit card company now to get a refund. Do not buy from Whitty's! read more

Staff is always friendly , attentive and knowledgeable. Decent prices, and bottles are never dusty. A pleasure to shop in this store.

about half the space in this Gujarati business is occupied by an utterly amazing selection of Portuguese wines , ports, liqueurs, and other forms if hard liquor. some interesting Russian stuff also. good place to find unusual alcoholic beverages to give as a gift. they have a decent selection of tequila, vodkas, rum, and so forth; but the real standout here is the Portuguese selection, along with a decent amount of Spanish stuff. read more

Lame...this place is overprice in my opinion...I can go numerous other places and get my boxwine hella cheap.

This place has an amazing selection of craft beers and they also have a huge selection of Portuguese wines. The prices have gone down since the new owner took over, so that's a plus. overall this is my go-to liquor store. read more