I have been a loyal customer since The Wine Authority opened. Not only do they have great…read moreadvertised prices (when I can stock up for holidays or parties), but the regular prices are competitive so I don't feel like I am paying too much when I want to just grab a bottle of wine to enjoy or bring as a gift. As a local Realtor, I take advantage of their bottle engraving service. In addition, they create the most magnificent gift baskets that I use as closing gifts. I provide them with some extra "goodies" for the baskets and they do the rest. All of the recipients of these gorgeous baskets are pleased. They get to toast to their new home, and keep the beautiful bottle as a keepsake. I am always treated kindly by their attentive staff. When I first started ordering the engraved bottles, Brandie helped me come up with the perfect design. She worked with me to get the look "just right". All staff members are knowledgeable about wines and will make a recommendation if you need it. The store itself has a clean, well-lit appearance. It is a great addition to Mt. Sinai and vicinity. You will not be disappointed!

The woman behind the counter couldn't take a minute to look up to help…read more Many choices in liquor stores, they need to have a nice person behind the register! My suggestion find another store to patronize!!!!

awesome selection. They have beers you won't find anywhere else. I never knew there was so many…read moresmall independent breweries on Long Island

I have been coming here since 2009 and the place keeps getting better. It starts with low pressure…read morehonest service and ends with fair prices and solid selection. Let's do a price check. Another local beer distributor charges $11 for southern tier unearthly IPA. Here it is $7 and change. What about selection. At least 5 choices from Knee Deep brewery and 4 from evil twin brewery. Also they have new releases including the 4 Bean from six point. My complaints would be it's on a busy intersection by the railroad and 112 and also that I don't make enough money to come here regularly. The growler station was very exciting but I got so distracted I didn't take a photo of the most recent selection! Must focus! Five stars because this is the best local beer distributor I know about !

Absolutely love this local, family-owned liquor store! Besides the adorable country store feel,…read morethere is a welcoming neighborhood vibe that's hard to find these days. They're helpful, knowledgeable, and happy to make recommendations, which makes every visit feel personal. Great selection, fair prices, and a staff truly cares about their customers. Always happy to support a local family business--highly recommend!

Excellent selection, knowledgeable staff to assist you find exactly what you need. Needed a…read morespecial order, looked at 20 different stores and nothing, not even an offer to special order. NC Wine & Spirits looked it up, gave me a price and 2 days later I had a special order of what I needed. Thanks!

Very narrow selection (honestly there is nothing there but basic vine and liquor)…read more Will not recommend this place to no one

What a nice surprise!…read more I shopped at Pindar yesterday (it's time for Winter White!) and I was looking for a bottle of Prosecco. No, we don't carry any Long Island Prosecco but the liquor store does. Wait, what? Where?? Yes, right by Tiger Lily. Huh??? Sure enough, I walk in with my dog and there is a new, pretty nice looking liquor store in the village of Port Jefferson. I asked about Processo that's not too dry. The helpful counterperson starts explaining to me the different Processo brands for sale. I grab a nice bottle and the see some tasting bottles on the coutner??? Yes, this is a Rum made in Long Island, Sag Harbor Rum. Outstanding! I also notice on the wall, smaller liquor bottles. If there is one thing I love is small bottles. Why? A good example would be St Germain. You can't keep it on the shelf for a long time. And I don't drink a lot of it, I like to mix it every once in a while. Hence, the need for a smaller size bottle. I see the different wine selections as well as liquor. If you're having a party and need a bottle? Port Jeff Liquors is now in the village and open until 10pm

Excellent selection of wines and liquours at reasonable prices. The only issue I had with them is…read moretheir policy that they will match competitor's advertised prices. That didn't occur last week when I shopped here. According to the clerk, they cannot adjust an item that they have on sale in their system even if their sale price is greater than the advertised price of of competitor. What can I say, you either match your competitors price or you don't. Simple right? A simple "override" accomplishes the price match.

First, let me say that the map that yelp brings up isn't correct right now, but the address is…read more This store is on Nesconset in the same shopping center as Kohls. Now that that is out of the way, I'm definitely a fan of this place. They have an okay selection of booze, and their prices are pretty good. They also seem to have random sales where you can find a good deal, I got a liter of Kahlua not too long ago for only $13. Also every time i've been there, they've had 3 for $10 deals on some of the wines, which is hard to pass up. Be sure to check their website as well if you want to find some coupons.

Very nice people there ... knowledgeable about the wines and liquors very competitive prices…read more. will always shop here

Be careful with this store. They price gouge and mark up all their inventor way over MSRP. I placed…read morean order on door dash for two bottles that they had forgotten to price gouge on. They cancelled my order and then increased the price immediately. Please see photos as proof. I called the store and they admitted to cancelling order because they refused to sell at original price listed There is no reason a customer had to loose out here because of the businesses oversight. After looking at other reviews on here. It looks like they often play games with pricing to lure customers in.

Super friendly staff, they actually make you feel welcome here. Large selection of spirits…read more(including my favorite, Gray Whale gin), decent amount of wines, some variety of pre-made cocktail mixes and chilled cocktail cans. Well lit and in a busy area. My go-to store in the area if I don't want to feel like my business is bothering the staff. Located between ShopRite and TJMaxx.

Overpriced by $12 - I went in to get a 1.75 Liter bottle of Baily's, paid and left. I get back…read morehome and my father says "where did you get that?" and I told him Siliato's - and he said "you definately overpaid". I double check their price vs several others in the area, and yes, they are $10-13 more expensive than anyone else - and according to my father and now several other people I spoke to, this price disparity is across the board. The nice old man who used to run the place for decades passed away at some point in the past few year, and that is sad - sadder still is ruining the formerly trusted and respected name for some nickel and diming - behaving like some large soulless corporation. I will never step foot in their again! Imagine a local mom and pop making Amazon look normal by comparison! I hope that $12 is worth the loss of thousands over the next few years!

this used to be my go to. I used the app and accumulated points, the Dad was a lovely man. He…read morepassed and greed took over. prices were raised but I still continued to go. The last time I was there, they had the audacity to charge me a fee for using my debit card. I thought enough, I pass 2 other stores to go to them. So now i stick with North Country, its closer and they dont try to rob me