Very cool store with 100s of thousands of unique items very well presented aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaread more

IMPORTANT: this is no longer a multi-vendor shop. The store is on the smaller side and packed to…read morethe gills, but walkable. Prices are sky-high. Crazy high. There are some nice things, especially furniture, but I don't know who the target customer is here. Sadly, I can't recommend it unless you have money to burn.

My wife & I have visited Troyer Antiques twice & a year apart. The location is a huge former potato…read morestorage barn so lacks the amenities you may expect in a conventional commercial building. The selection is extensive & fairly well organized with a good balance between large & small items. I've not had an issue reading the price tags though my vision is not the best. The prices marked are high though the proprietor was willing to negotiate fairly. He even made the effort to retrieve & offer us an item which had not yet been inventoried because it was associated with our other purchases. For the collector looking for the out-of-the-ordinary, I feel it's definitely worth a stop. ______ Hey, fellow Yelpers! If you have read to this point, help keep me motivated by taking a moment to rate this review. Thank you!

Can't wait to get back here. 11/2017 next time. Place is amazing. Must see . Antiques are amazing…read morecollection.

CAME FROM OUT OF TOWN TO FIND IT CLOSED AND OUT OF BUSINESS. a sign on the door said opening soon…read morewith new owners, Wish I would have known that before I traveled 2 hrs

Be careful shopping at taylors. Ive been supporting local businesses as much as possible but…read moreunfortunately after making a purchase at taylors and being told buyer beware because they sell items that arent really vintage or even what they claim they are ill never shop there again. The items were marked and sold as vintage eye wash cups but in reality they are just small laboratory beakers. I do not collect eye wash cups or know much about the types or designs but paid $10 a piece for 3 of them for an elderly friend that collects them because the tag said they were eye wash cups. Taylors refuses to refund and do a return. #1 false advertising. #2 bad business decision. #3 not a business I will ever trust again and have gone there and spent quite a bit on items just for home decor not for antique value.

This place owned by one sister and Our Little Shop just a few miles up the road is owned by…read moreanother. They are both our favorite antique and unique gifts shops anywhere. The sisters and their guys are wonderful, their prices are great, and the inventory is always changing. I love going both of the places often.

Very eclectic place full of one of a kind vintage and historic items really fun to walk thru and…read moresee what speaks to you

Items from the shop were placed online. I reached out letting the owner know I was interested and…read moreasked if the items were still available, understanding that I might not be the first to comment. The lister then said that it WAS available - this was after the shop had already closed for the evening by the time we were communicating. I was working out with the owner when I could pick up based on her open hours - telling her my best convenience but ultimately letting her know that I'd rework my schedule with whatever works for her since it was something my daughter really needed. She said she'd get back to me in the morning with the time that would work. I didn't hear from her so I checked my messages to see that she marked the item as sold. I, of course, figured she had marked it sold for me (giving her the benefit of the doubt) and asked her if she had figured out when I could grab the items and she told me she had sold it. In hindsight, there was one red flag when we were communicating as she said "a ton of people want it". If that was the case, then I imagine it wasn't really available and/or we were being scammed. I was disappointed to say the least. If she had told me that I had to get it the second she opened, I would have called off work to grab it. She didn't. She simply said she'd get back to me with the time that worked for her. If it wasn't available, she should not have said it was. This is not how a shop with integrity works.

Not a bad store but didn't care for how I was treated. Walked around for about five minutes when…read morecollege kids came in. Suddenly everyone had to lock their "bags" in tiny lockers because we might "knock things over". Oh please! My husband was carrying a bag from another store and a big bag of kettle corn. Which was in MUCH MORE danger of knocking stuff over, and he wasn't asked to put THAT away. I had a slim leather bag. That wasn't going to knock ****over. I walked right out. The lady at the counter was rudely grandstanding to like cover up her distrust on young college kids, which is bad enough, but now you're going to get all up in my face to cover it up? Nope. There's a very nice antique store across the street. Thanks.

Just love this place. Clean, friendly people and always something fun to buy. Worth the tripread more

Kind of neat for what it is, a second hand shop that you wander around in. Their stuff is fairly…read moreorganized and it's easy to get around. They have lots of interesting knick knacks. They have lots of old books and cool historical items.

They are honest, pleasant and funny! I love shopping there and I donate a lot too! They have some…read morebeautiful items, f "Different" things and usually lots of vintage Tupperware! I recommend Finders Keepers to everyone looking for a delightful thrifting experience.

Easy to find, easy parking, no steps to get in and friendly people. No public restrooms - be…read moreprepared! Definitely more of a second-hand store than an antique store but it was well organized and clean. No musty smell that some places have. I was looking for a table cloth, and they had a few but not all of them had dimensions and I'm not good at eye-balling how big they are (I've bought a few that way and they were too small). Hubby bought a train set and a book. We would stop back when in the area.