an antique shop that buys and sells antiques and curiosities. my first question was: how did you get all this stuff... Owner Susie Nerger told us - that they are going to houses that are moving and buy their stuff or people come and drop their stuff and they sell at suitable prices. You will find a treasure trove of high-quality antiques, collectibles, and curiosities that they procure daily! Dolls, toys, figurines, paintings, kitchen items, typewriters, hookahs, college stationery, old books, means you name it and you shall find it here - it is definitely fun while exploring the shop Definitely keep this place as a regular stop on the "hunting" trail. The owners are super friendly, welcoming, and knowledgeable. read more

See all

Pricing at their estate can be summed up as 'Antique store pricing on thrift store items'. $5 apiece for some basic vintage Christmas ornaments? Most antique stores will sell for $3, and this was at an estate sale Things that would sell at a normal estate sale for $1-$3 consistently marked $10. Avoid. read more

Ye Olde Antique & Curiosity Shop - Overpriced - Antiques Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

went to one of their estate sales. Prices were extremely high. Wanted 2 items. price was 3-4 times what it should have been for each item. Came back the end of sale, on Sunday, they advertise 50% off... same price and was told that was 50%.. So 50% off of what.. he says yesterday... well I was here yesterday and it was the same price. He tells me good bye. He probably doesn't want to sell items, he probably wants to put them in his store and sell them. So he keeps them high. My wife was standing by him waiting for me, and 2 women wanted to buy a vase he wanted $30.. they left it. she felt it was way to high and was thinking under $10. I think people are getting taken by signing up with this vendor. I think they can move more with fair pricing. There loss not mine.. I won't visit a sale with this vendor again. read more

I stopped into Ye Olde Antique for the first time (this is my hometown, how is that possible!?) and spent way too much time browsing and admiring the awesome collection. They have everything from jewelry to flower pots, dining sets, accessories, everything. I saw so many pieces I would have loved to bring home like glass candle sticks, a Stangle mug and a Haeger flower pot, but my budget made me be just a little responsible. I ended up leaving with just the cuteeeee pot and am so happy about it. I can't wait to make more trips here! It's such a fun shop to browse around find new gems. Maybe I'll return one day for those candle sticks and mug... read more

Great antique shop! It's huge with a large variety of old items ranging from toys to historical memorabilia to furniture and clothing. I specifically came here because I knew they had presidential memorabilia, and bought a bunch of old campaign pins. My friend had previously visited and found a porcelain plate with the presidents up to LBJ on it, and it's a piece I now love to display in my apartment. This is a great spot to just browse and especially if you have a hobby related to the past. read more

crammed. no prices on most things. waaay overpriced on what is priced. I sell antiques too and this person just wants a place to keep his collections. $500 on a transfer ware platter. I don't care if it's 1800s.. you will NEVER get that for it. Ive gotten those same platters for $50 or less. easy. We will never come back. I see the same inventory year after year because NO ONE is buying it. it's comical that they don't see their shop is not doing any business. I never see anyone buying anything. read more

A great "find the needle in the haystack " type of shop . The proprietors are super friendly and helpful . Their collections are varied but deep and everything is dusted , clean and presented in an organized way . This is the type of shop you can get lost in for hours . Surely , there is something for everyone here . read more

Ye Olde Antique & Curiosity Shop is not your ordinary estate sales service. If you want a full service business that handles everything seamlessly, then they are it. Like most people selling their home, I was completely stressed out when preparing to sell most of my elderly father's posessions. That all changed when I called Ken and Susie (the owners) for help. They immediately put me at ease, assuring me that they've been in the business for many years and have handled hundreds of sales successfully. The day of the estate sales went perfectly. Nearly all of the posessions were liquidated and those that remained were thoughtfully removed and donated by their company. Not once during the process was I concerned. Don't waste your time looking anywhere else, this company has earned my trust and respect for any future needs. Highly recommend! read more