This is my go-to bakery for special occasion cakes, among other treats. My twins were celebrating their 17th birthday and I called Saturday morning to see if they had any cakes available. Generally you need to pre order and I forgot to do that. Lucky for me they were making an order and could make an extra one for me. Leslie was so kind and helpful and I was thankful for the accommodation. Do yourself and them a favor next time you need a cake--give them a few days notice and you'll guarantee getting a cake. My kids got the cake and their driving licenses! read more

502 Baking Company - Chocolate cake with chocolate filling -- delish!! - Bakeries Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

The very nice and accommodating staff helped me with a last minute bday dessert for my husband. It was in lieu of a traditional cake and it was the perfect decision. The fudge brownie with ganache topping hit the mark and it was truly delicious! Great choice if you want to do something a little different for a bday. Thank you again! read more

502 Baking Company - Bakeries Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

See all

6/2024: it's summer and back at the PP beach. Toni, the bakery owner, was so gracious and accommodating with us and replaced the strawberry pie from our Thanksgiving visit. She's hard working, and so sweet to offer us a key lime pie. Also, the crumbcake cheesecake (we discovered the delicious dessert at Atlantic Offshore FishRey & Restaurant over on Channel Dr., PP, NJ) and had to source the baker. A combination of cheesecake and crumb cake makes a truly tasty treat. So yummy. Thank you for rectifying the issue. It was nice to meet Olivia, store clerk, too. We'll be back to try the chicken pot pie in the Fall; read it's really good! read more

See all

It was ok. The food was ok. The prices were ok. The shop was small but ok. The service was ok in speed. The theme? It was just ok. ------ Update to business who replied: I am definitely talking about the one in Brick not in PA. I am in Ocean every weekend. Business owner replied saying "Can you help us out a bit? What food did you order? I didn't understand the "theme" comment....we're a bakery, not an amusement park..." I ordered the brownies and cookies. Your shop didn't have any price tags on them. They tasted fine. There was nothing bad and nothing great about them. The "theme" I referred to was how I referred to everything as just "ok" in the wording of my original post. Your first reply to my review was accusing me of addressing the wrong business and your second reply was misreading my review and attempting to take a dig at me with your amusement park comment. I will not be replying to you anymore. Your responses to my review reflect a defensiveness that is disturbing. read more

During our Thanksgiving visit to shore on Wednesday, we made an impromptu stop to check the available to-go items Inside the door was a table of $20 pies. The glass case was mostly empty due to the pre orders from days ago. I was initially interested in a Key lime pie but was told they were gone and so, the strawberry sounded good and as I was ready to pay, the clerk happened to discover ONE key lime pie nearby. Two pies, $20/$25 each. The strawberry pie crust was under baked (see photo) and the inside filling 90% gelatin/ filling with scant amount of actual strawberries. Disappointed at that price. On the other hand, the key lime was so good, true lime flavor, tad bitter like we like it with the graham crust. And we'll definitely re-visit for other specialty goods. Thanks for baking for us during the holidays! :) read more

See all

Thank you so much for going above and beyond by creating a coconut key lime pie for our son's girlfriend's birthday celebration! It was her heart's desire and you came through amazingly. Much appreciation for your time and talents. It was DELICIOUS! Can't wait to order another one!!! read more

502 Baking Company - A very special birthday pie from 502 Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

The owner here is really nice. The cheesecake crumb cake dessert is the best thing in this store. It is so creamy, so unique, and so delicious. The oatmeal raisin cookie or HUGE, soooo worth it!!!! Bang for your buck. It's also so moist and chewy. It is truly a perfect treat. I highly recommend this--it really might be the best oatmeal raisin cookie I've ever gotten anywhere!!!!!! I also wanted a carrot cake or carrot loaf, and I felt like his missed the mark for what I wanted. It was dry and didn't have the density or fillings I wanted (I expected to see big carrot shreds and raisins). But some lady walked in after me and said that's her favorite here!! read more

502 Baking Company - Pastry case - Bakeries Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

After tasting their Key Lime Pie at the Atlantic Offshore Fishery last month my wife was dreaming of the pie. What better way to treat my wife on Mother's Day than to travel south to Brick to visit the 502 Baking Company to pick up some treats? 502 Baking company has a small retail store in a nondescript shopping center along Brick Blvd. The famous Key Lime pie is sold as a Pie, mini pie and a bite size. I added a chocolate croissant, a piece of Apple Crumb cake and Tiramisu. I have to say the trip was well worth it, the treats did not disappoint. My wife and family were very happy. Everything was fresh and delicious as I expected, I might venture to say that their Tiramisu is the best I have had. I know they have a stand at the Brick Farmers Market, I hope they will consider coming to the Red Bank Farmers market as it will save me 20-30 minutes of drive time. In any case, if you are in the mood for treats, I recommend checking out the 502 Baking Company. read more

502 Baking Company - a display case of pies - Bakeries Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

See all

Most amazing experience! This bakery scores the top rating of all local bakeries! Unmatched premium made from scratch top quality cakes that proverbially blow the competitors cakes out of the water! And the customer service? Off the chart! Please don't just take my word...I invite you the read what others are also saying about this incredible establishment. My parents' 60th Wedding Anniversary blowout party was a casualty of COVID. A small party of 20 guests could not be accommodated by the restaurant of their choice. My parents understood the situation but though they tried, they couldn't hide their disappointment that the party would need to be postponed a year. Backup plan? Go virtual... key component-- one of a kind cake delivered to the house by 502! Safe, secure, achievable! Placed the order by phone 3 weeks before the event. The lady who took my order was magnificent! Gracious and kind, she helped me select (based solely on the happy couples tastes) a lemon cake with dark-dark chocolate frosting. Because of the small gathering I selected a small round cake that serves 4-6... this was an excellent choice as I'd find out later... I relayed the address and informed her that my sister was sworn-in as "secret agent" in this regard so delivery should be made directly to her, for purposes of surprise preservation. The ordering process to include payment was fast and flawless. Day before delivery, the baker called me back and asked for some last minute clarifications! How cool is that?! I felt I was included in the entire process as they walked me through the baking and how they'd handle the delivery! What an amazing mission partner! The day before the virtual party, the cake was delivered exactly on time. My dad answered the door but the delivery agent refused to turn the cake over to anyone except my sister! Talk about "chain of custody"! The end result: a decadently rich, dense and explosively lemony cake that was not overly sweet but just perfect! No mix or supermarket or high production bakery garners this level of quality! Parents were so surprised and impressed.... oh yes and a final word on the size... because of the dense-ness, richness, and luxurious nature of the cake there was scarcely a dent made even after 4 hungry people went back for seconds (see photo). The 4-6 people that the cake was supposed to serve was an understatement... well maybe 4-6 football players... but this size can easily service 8-10 normal appetites. Service, quality, satisfaction... 5-stars! The hands down only choice if you're in the market for a one-of-a kind cake to celebrate a special event. And require delivery. Mahalo nui loa 502, and mahalo to you all for reading my review. read more

502 Baking Company - Showing the inside and how dense and rich it was.... - Bakeries Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

See all

Cannot resist stopping by every time I go to the area, The pastries are amazing, love their key lime bites. Today, for the 1st time I got the Italian bread...crisp outside & soft inside, still warm in a paper bag, it was fantastic! read more

502 Baking Company - Key Lime Bites - Bakeries Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

Love this establishment! Saw an Instagram posting about their FABULOUS Sourdough bread and DM'd them about any loaves left that I could pick up. They responded in a timely manner to say "yes" and what time I could swing by. Truly enjoy all the products that we have sampled from this great shop and it's always great to have a personal connection!!! Thanks 502 Baking Company. And to think this all started with their Key Lime Pie that we had at Atlantic Offshore Fishery in Point Pleasant!!! read more

Service was fantastic! Went in the day of for an emergency order. They accommodated me very well, and went out of their way to make sure I was happy. Will definitely return read more

My wonderful friend got Toni Marie and Les at the fabulous 502 Baking Company to make me a MANGO PIE!!!! And now it's on the regular menu!!!! It was absolutely incredible, as were all the goodies we brought home, including fabulous gluten-free almond raspberry cookies and carrot cake. Thank you all so much!!!! read more

502 Baking Company - Bakeries Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

We love this local bakery as everything that we get or order from them is terrific. Our latest "find" was their take on the Brooklyn Blackout Cake. Fabulous, tasty, and chocolately!! Couldn't have been easier with a quick message via Instagram to order. Had to add their awesome Sourdough bread as we went their regular version but also check out their Jalapeño Cheddar version! And finally their Bacon Cheddar Maple scones (my fav!!!). We've ordered many things from 502 and have never been disappointed. Did I mention their sublime Coconut Cake (my wife's special)? Go check them out and follow them on Instagram as they post delicious selections read more

Love Love Love this hometown bakery! Authentic and everything home made from scratch! The real deal! No artificial ingredients, gluten free options and just plain delicious! Treat yourself! Staff and owners friendly and welcoming! read more

We read that they were selected top ten crumb cakes in NJ. We tried 3 kinds of crumb cake... plain, raspberry and cheese filled crumb. We were very excited and very disappointed after trying the crumb. The cheese filled was the better of the three but I still wouldn't say it was good or even crumb cake. The plain and raspberry were both hard and dry on the edges, slightly more moist on the inside when cut but still dry. It is a bummer. The scone was a maple cheddar bacon, We warmed that up in the microwave and it was very good and the reason for three stars. I went for crumb though and the crumb was a let down. Maybe you'll have better luck but I won't be going back. read more

502 Baking Company - Creme filled crumb cake, raspberry crumb, plain crumb and the maple cheddar bacon scone. - Bakeries Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

Great service, very fresh doughnuts even though I stopped by right before closing. Will go back

The gluten free peanut butter pie was so good and we've had lots of gluten free pies. I have to say the crumb cake and the pie was the best of our Thanksgiving dinner. Can't wait to order for Christmas and tell Alexa to order more this year. read more

The smell when walking through the door is intoxicating! Purchased the peanut butter pie and loved it. The cheese crumb cake was also delicious. read more

We heard the Keylime pie was excellent so five of us went in to check out the bakery the cheese crumb cake is outstanding. The gluten-free almond cookies were wonderful. The cranberry orange scone was excellent. We didn't care for the blueberry, lemon scone. It wasn't lemony enough for us then we tried a maple bacon scone, which was excellent. We purchased a chicken pot pie, which will cook for dinner and try also highly recommend this bakery. read more

So happy we found this Amazing Bakery!! The Key lime pie is incredible!! The coffee cakes are plain, cream cheese filling or raspberry filling delicious!!! I highly recommend this bakery!!! The owner is such a sweet lady! read more

first time visiting got a GF brownie, GF crumb cake and a cheese crumb cake ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE, glad we didn't wait to get home to taste. can't wait to return for more read more

Best bakery I have been in In a long time! The key lime pie will make the Florida Keys jealous! Gotta get there early closes at 4 And the good stuff (everything) goes quickly read more

Raspberry Crumb cake , Lemon bars , brownies, cheese cake ,and of course the Key Lime Pie, are hands down the best in the area ! Toni and Les are the best , and great people to do business with ! read more

Really not much to purchase. I had the gluten free morning glory muffin at the Farmers Market and it was great. I guess you have order ahead of time. read more

Came here for the gluten free baked goodies! First of all, the staff is very friendly and knowledgeable! I called ahead and they were able to list everything they had gluten free. The big hits for us were the cookies!!! Just delicious. Peanut butter cookies or with the Hershey drop just fantastic! The vanilla cake slice was good by the carrot cake really hit the spot. It was not dry. And cream cheese frosting was not sickening sweet! I would have given a 5 star rating but the scone was disappointing. I know gf scones are not easy to come by but this one was like a dry brick! The only thing that tasted ok was the actual blueberries! Overall, would come back again. They also said they can bake anything to order after the holidays GF except bread!! That is something I may take them up on! Hubby who is not GF had the Cheese Crumb cake and raved about it! read more

My Mother in law was turning 81 during a pandemic. We searched for a bakery near her to deliver a cake. In all of Tom's River we couldn't find one to deliver. Then I found 502 Baking in Brick. They were 15 miles away...but did offer delivery, so I sent them an email. I knew it was a long shot since they were so far away. Well, even though their delivery radius was 5 miles, Les (one of the owners) agreed to deliver a cake to her on her birthday. They took payment over the phone and even included a beautiful candle with the cake. Not only was the customer service of this bakery 5 stars...but the cake looked gorgeous. And according to my Mother in law, absolutely delicious. The delivery made her day! Les delivered it himself and even chatted with my Mother in law when he did....which also made her day. :) Thanks guys for helping us give her a nice birthday! We celebrated via zoom and were all jealous watching her eat her cake. read more

See all

Recently moved to the area and needed a cake for our daughters bday. Our request seemed simple but we struck out at 3 other area bakeries before calling 502. They were super easy to work with and pricing was extremely reasonable. We emailed them a picture of what we had in mind and they knocked it out of the park. We even got a half dozen matching cupcakes. Can't wait to order from them again. read more

502 Baking Company - Rose cale - Bakeries Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

See all

I just bought Vegan cookies and croissants-what a delight! Fresh, tasty and no one would know that they were Vegan! Have gone there before and was always delighted with my selections but the addition of their Vegan specialties was amazing! Highly recommend. read more

Went in on A Saturday around noon- No key lime pie available ... unpleasantly I was told I could come back in 30 minutes I settled for a mini key lime ... to see if it was that good, and the apple pie which looked delicious! Total disappoint- I never tasted such a bland apple pie in my life, and the key lime was too sweet - and for the price.... no way worth it read more

Freshest key lime pie ever! Tried for the first time Labor Day when I brought to a friends party. Delish!

Stopped in for a pastry and coffee. There wasn't much of a selection of pastries at the time I was there. I asked for coffee and it was a self serve option. The lady at the counter explained to me why there wasn't a lot of selection due to the time of the day, which I'll understand. I settled for the croissant, but it wasn't warm. I appreciate the lady at the counter (didn't get her name :( ) for trying to accommodate me with pastry options. Based on the other great reviews left, I will try this place again. Maybe their pies everyone keeps talking about ! read more

This bakery has been open about 4 months. This is a small bakery but cute. Today they had cookies, cakes? Cupcakes, brownies, rolls and breads, and other pasteries. Everything looked really nice. They also have a separate case of gluten free baked goods. The gluten free items are baked elsewhere and are in sealed containers to ensure they are not contaminated by the bakery gluten. I tried two items - a huge chocolate chip cookie and a macaroon dipped in chocolate. Both items were very good and fresh. Both also looked really appetizing. The staff was very friendly. the prices were good (both items together were only $3! I definitely will be going back to try some other items. read more

See all

We tried 502 bakery for the first time a few weeks ago. We have already been back a second time. The key lime pie is the BEST we have ever had. My fiancée has also declared the boston cream donut the best he has had. Couldn't recommend this place more. If you want a cake for a special occasion, call ahead. Otherwise, go in and check out a few things they have available that day.. you won't be disappointed! read more

Lived all over the country, but was born and raised here in Brick, NJ. Good food isnt hard to find, but GREAT food is. Look no further than 502 Baking company. They did my sisters cake for her wedding, along with many others delicious sweets (macaroons, cupcakes, butter cookies etc) and each one i tried made my trip here from Minnesota worth it. Their hard rolls are the best I have had in a long time. I took some on the plane back so I could enjoy an old fashioned Jersey shore breakfast of a butter roll and coffee, for the next week or two. I will shamelessly admit to eating, or sampling almost every type of pastry or cake they had to offer during my short visit here. Again, great food isn't easy to come by, so enjoy when you can. They had a great variety of treats that made me want to try them all....so I did! If you're driving by, give them a try. You'll be grdeted by some pretty amazing gals and guys behind the counter, who are attentive, very sweet and truly love the work they do. You can see how much pride they put into their work. From the cleanliness of the store, the smell of the artisan rolls and bread baking in the back, and the sweetest cookies, cakes an pies I've had in a long while, 502 Baking Company made my vacation home a real treat! Definitely recommend! Let them know Kevin sent you! read more

502 Baking Company - 502 Baking company! Big counter and shelves full of some of the best baked goods I have had in a very long time. - Bakeries Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

All I can say is WOW!! These guys knocked it out of the park with a crazy 9 year old mind. He wanted all strawberry cake. From the cake to the inside and icing. By far one of the best cakes I have ever eaten. Thank you guys. read more

I stopped in for the first time today and I was warmly greeted as soon as I entered. The gentleman was very friendly and nice. I bought an oatmeal Cookie and a blueberry muffin. The oatmeal cookie was not fresh and so hard you could hardly take a bite. The blueberry muffin tasted fresh and had nice blueberries baked in, but not too much flavor. If you are a new upcoming bakery you have to take a loss at the beginning and throw old products away! I hope they read this and review their baked goods daily, and only serve the freshest products or they won't survive. read more

My husband and I stopped in, just to see what they have. I wanted to know what they had that is Gluten Free. To my surprise, they had the best variety and I wanted to try it all. The staff was so easy to chat with. Thank you guys so much for the variety of goodies I will get to enjoy. My gluten free journey started last August. It took 3 drs, 10 years to no tell me what was wrong. It took one new Dr to tell me that I am gluten intolerant. WELL WORTH STOPPING IN. read more

Went for the first time on Thursday. Service was great and the desserts were so good. I ordered the mini key lime and it was delicious! I can't wait to go back for more. Good price's also read more

I picked up a key lime pie as well as a Coconut Custard pie for my wife and OMG the Best Key lime pie EVER!!!!!! I will be making a weekly trips for that pie. read more