Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Amity Coffee

    4.8 (128 reviews)
    Closed 7:00 am - 4:00 pm

    Amity Coffee Photos

    Business Info

    AMITY COFFEE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Good for groups
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    More like Amity Coffee

    Recommended Reviews - Amity Coffee

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Tomato and scallion danish
    Stephanie L.

    If you're looking for a solidly crafted coffee and a light breakfast, this is the place. I tried their cold brew and their caramel latte, both had amazing flavors and a good brew. I also had their pain au chocolate, and the tomato and scallion danish from the pastry counter. Definitely recommend!

    Laura R.

    I was sooo happy to find this place. I was having a hard time finding a coffee shop/cafe during my recent trip to the Finger Lakes, and finding this gem made this trip even more perfect. They have a nice selection of breakfast sandwiches, pastries, and coffee, and definitely satisfied this city girl! There was a good amount of seating in the restaurant as well! If I am ever in the area again, you can best be sure I will be back! There are not a ton like it around, and it's the perfect way to start the day!

    The coffee here is great! I also got the espresso croissant and it was probably the best croissant I've ever had. Breakfast sandwiches were also delicious.

    Bacon egg and cheese bagels and cappuccino.
    Saul G.

    Don't be put off by a long line. The place is well staffed, and they are pros. The line moved fast both days we went and the vibe is great. The baked goods would be very competitive even in New York City. I particularly enjoyed the pain au Chocolat, the monkey bread, and the chocolate almond croissant. The plain croissant was the underachiever. Don't sleep on the bacon egg and cheese sandwiches, which arrive on excellent small bagels. We tried the regular bec and the Sudsy, which adds hot sauce, fig jam, and avocado for a flavor bomb. Get it on a rosemary salt bagel. Finally, do try the basic coffee as well as the espresso drinks, it's surprisingly good.

    Cappuccino
    Michael B.

    Great little coffee joint. Pour overs were delish, cappuccino too! Saturday morning in late Sept had a line out the door. Still service was efficient and friendly.

    Alex T.

    Definitely worth the drive out! Food and drinks are both incredible. Great ambiance to do work. Service was quick and friendly.

    Simone T.

    It's so rare to see (good) coffee art where I live that I was pleasantly surprised to see it done so well in a small town like Penn Yan. Going on a Tuesday meant that there were less people around and quieter, but the baristas were still very businesslike. They are competent and respectful but not particularly friendly or outgoing. The sandwich that I had was good! And I like that they don't do added sugar to the matcha latte.

    Latte with honey and cinnamon

    Great little spot. Delicious looking bakery items, but i resisted the temptation Breakfast options are yummy. Lots of coffee and non-coffee beverage options. Prompt service

    Matcha and bagel
    Jackie M.

    Right next to the World's Largest Pancake pan, Amity Coffee is a short walking distance to grab coffee, tea and a few small bites. Pretty solid matcha whipped up. They have a small variety of pour overs as well. Delicious drinks and friendly service!

    Drip
    Jenny C.

    This place is a godsend in this area for coffee as there's literally no other place to get coffee. They serve light coffee which I was very excited about and on top of that found a new roaster I was excited to try (JUNTO). They don't serve single origin espresso and seem to excel in pour overs and their drip. The waitress doesn't seem to know any coffee lingo so I would hold off and just order a drink instead of asking for specific coffee questions if you are into that. In terms of what I got- I'm in love with the Colombian drip from JUNTO and I got a Rwandan pour over and usually it won't taste good at all if the wrong process is used / timing and pour / but they did it so good I was extremely happy with my coffee.

    Joy S.

    Nice little coffee shop and what I believe is the only coffee shop right in town. Ample seating indoors and a few tables outside. It was pretty busy but we didn't have a problem finding a table, even with social distancing. They also had a nice variation of seating styles from standard tables and chairs to large padded high back chairs (our choice) to couches and finally a long padded bench across from where you order and receive your drinks. The decor was simple, but nice. Standard espresso menu and pastries. We didn't even look at the pastries as we went in while waiting for our table for breakfast. They also had a small board with some daily specials. We ordered an espresso and because I saw it on the specials menu, a blackberry espresso fizz. That was definitely not my best choice. I had them explain what it was and I ordered it because I had never heard of something like that. There's a very good reason for that. An espresso fizz is basically sparkling coffee and it's every bit as weird as it sounds. It wasn't terrible but I also didn't really enjoy it and will never try something like that again. I don't fault Amity for that, my husbands cappuccino was good, I fault myself for trying something so strange. It's definitely a good place to get espresso based drinks and we would recommend it. Just don't get fizzy espresso!

    Chipotle bowl. Delicious.
    Michelle G.

    Amity Coffee has become a staple when we go down to Keuka lake. The coffee is amazing and their food is so fresh and delicious. We highly recommend you stop in every time you're on Keuka Lake. See picture for our delicious lunch

    Outside
    Kate B.

    Nice location, chill coffee shop with decent seating. I had a honey cinnamon latte. Nice presentation but tasted a little on the burnt side.

    See all

    8 years ago

    Cute little coffee shop in Penn Yan. We got the pour overs, which were delicious! Friendly service, clean atmosphere, good prices!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of E S.
    0
    24
    0

    9 years ago

    Awesome coffee, great service. Finally a good cafe in Penn Yan. Lance was very knowledgeable and personable.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of C M.
    0
    1
    0

    8 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Lyndsi S.

    Lyndsi S.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Excellent drinks, especially the iced lattes. Big city vibe in the village. Service is top notch!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - Amity Coffee

    You might also consider

    Outlet 111

    Outlet 111

    4.1
    (9 reviews)
    0.2 mi

    This review is regarding our 2nd stop at Outlet 111. We were here sometime late 2025 or maybe even…read moreearly 2026 and it was cold out so we were inside. We each had a drink and I believe we split steamed dumplings and all was good on that trip. In fact, we were elated to find the place because it had a good vibe and seemed nice and we decided we would return in nicer weather. We returned the last weekend of May and stayed inside this visit also. The place was empty when we arrived. We sat against the glass wall facing the water. My wife noticed that a bunch of tables were dirty as were the windows. They are very large windows to enjoy the waterway but when mixed with the dirty tables, it causes one to wonder. We ordered drinks and food. The drinks were excellent. I ordered the pork dumplings and empenadas and my wife got the special which was a smoked turkey hoagey. The dumplings were excellent once again. The empenadas were tasty but seriously light on filling. And her turkey sandwich was terrible. She asked for it deconstructed because she didnt want the hoagy roll. She ate most of the insides of it but couldnt get through the turkey. I generally serve as her garbage disposal and if she doesnt finish something, she pawns it off on me. I can eat just about anything but this was not chewable. I am not sure what to call it. It tasted delicious, as smoked turkey does, but the gristle/ fat or whatever it was, couldnt get chewed enough to even try to swallow it. It had to be a 1 to 1.5 oz clump of unchewable stuff (for lack of a proper term). So needless to say, we wont be back. Bottom line, drinks were excellent, some food was good, some borderline worth the cost and some terrible. To us, it was a waste of $100+ with tip

    In the heart of Penn Yan. An exciting addition to this Finger Lakes region. Great spaces for…read morerelaxed dining, or gathering with friends, family, or business. In the canal, docking and waterside dining and relaxing. Light pub fare, charcuterie and flatbread choices. Local wines and crafted cocktails and mocktails. Locally sourced sustainable ingredients. This former cold storage warehouse from the early 1800's has been transformed into a one of Penn Yans most exciting gathering and entertaining spots. Amazing architectural transformation. Casual atmosphere. Order at the bar, pick a table on the patio or deck, a seat at the bar or the loft area and relax. Service is great, food outstanding and the beverages are unique. Enjoy!

    Photos
    Outlet 111
    Outlet 111
    Inviting. Bar!

    See all

    Inviting. Bar!

    Amity Coffee - coffee - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...