We had an amazing breakfast at Toby's. The donuts are fresh and there is a large assortment of delicious donuts. Our breakfast came out nice and quick and was delicious. I had two eggs over medium with a ham steak and it was delicious. My wife loved her eggs and sausage. The coffee is very good. Maria did a great job with Professional and friendly service. She actually looks like the famous Miley Cyrus... read more

See all

Toby's combines a classic breakfast diner where you can get some combination of eggs, meats, bread with a classic donut shop. The breakfast quality is good. The prices are reasonable. They have an extensive yeast and cake doughnut lineup. The restaurant is clean and streamlined. It's everything I want in a breakfast place. read more

Tobey's Donut Shop - Eggs, hashbrowns, sausage, and toast - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Watkins Glen, New York

Had THE best donuts at Tobey's Donut shop and the privilege of meeting the Fourth Generational Owner who was amazing!!!! This place is so cute and inviting. I am a sucker for pink and this place is a pink girl's heaven. You can smell the baked goodness before you even open the door. When you walk in it's donuts in your face and boy was I lovin it. We ordered the PB&J donut, an eclair, and a blueberry donut. We also ordered scrambled eggs and bacon. Of course we had to get the coffee. These were the lightest donuts I've ever tasted. Full of flavor and no greasy fingers. I will forever love PB&J. The scrambled eggs were flavorful and fluffy and the bacon was crispy just how we love it. Thank you Tobey's y'all were amazing. read more

See all

Excellent at everything they do. The breakfast is top notch. Eggs cooked perfectly, crispy Hashbrowns and delicious bacon. Donuts are incredible and probably the highlight of the establishment. Very unique flavors and baked perfectly. We had lemon, key lime, old fashioned, cinnamon, glazed, raspberry cream. Service was also exceptional. Very friendly wait staff and accommodating to our requests of a donut breakfast sandwich which also recieved high marks. Must stop when visiting Watkins Glen, try and have one breakfast here. read more

We weren't planning on going to Tobey's Donut Shop, but since the Thai restaurant wasn't open next door, we stopped by. Picked up some donuts and they were all good ($2.10 each): Key Lime - Key Lime filling sweet dough shell topped with bun icing and crushed graham crackers Lemon - Lemon Filled sweet dough shell coated with powdered sugar. Chocolate - Glazed Chocolate fry cake Raspberry Glazed - Original Glazed donut topped with Raspberry icing and sprinkles read more

Tobey's Donut Shop - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Watkins Glen, New York

Delightful quality doughnuts and great service. We tried a few different kinds including a cinnamon twist, sour cream glaze, powdered sugar, old fashioned with chocolate frosting and a French cream. Great local spot. read more

See all

Amazing selection of delicious, homemade donuts! A great treat while staying in Watkins Glen

Don't hesitate to stop here for breakfast and or just a donut. Great service and everyone super nice.

While my wife was running a 10k in Montour Falls, I snuck away and ran myself down to the donut shop (I think my idea was better haha). Food: I ended up getting three donuts for the long weekend: long john, apple cinnamon, and apple cider. All three were exceptional, but it was my first time having a long john donut and I was very impressed. Service: The young lady working the counter definitely didn't seem like she wanted to be there, but she was cordial and helped out. Aesthetic: a cool diner mix into a doughnut shop, definitely a style I did not expect. A huge volume of doughnuts too, so I assume they do a large amount of business. read more

See all

Great little donut shop that also serves breakfast! Staff are super friendly and helpful. Service is very quick after ordering which is helpful to get in and out. Our breakfast ordered were 2 eggs over easy with sausage and whole wheat toast. Also rye bread with omelet with sausage and swiss cheese. The food was excellent. The sausage wasn't overly salty like most sausages which helped. Tried one of their donuts afterwards but it looks so good, I forgot to take a picture lol. Very fresh though! read more

Tobey's Donut Shop - 2 eggs over easy with hash and whole wheat bread - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Watkins Glen, New York

See all

Best donuts on the planet. I ate almost a dozen myself!!!!The Long Johns are insane. They're sold out by 9 am.

This was an amazing surprize, great donuts, super sweet staff, delicious breakfast! Thanks for making our trip end on a sweet note leaving the finger lakes! We will bd back to your place read more

See all

Walked in to get a donut to go on a Friday morning. Loved the diner vibe. The cashier was super friendly and helpful in helping me choose a flavor. Though they didn't have a ton of donuts on display, there were plenty of the Bizmarks, which I wanted to try and the cashier highly recommended. So glad I got it! It was like a cinnamon roll, but with a more doughy and moist texture. I washed it down with a black coffee. Can't wait to come back to try more flavors! read more

Great service and good was amazing. Had a beehive omelette and took a donut to go. Highly recommend after hiking Watkins Glen. read more

Tobey's Donut Shop - Veggie omelet - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Watkins Glen, New York

Cute little diner full of hungry customers. Food looked and smelled delicious. Couldn't leave without a dozen donuts. Waaaaay better than Dunkin. Must try in Watkins Glen. read more

Tobey's Donut Shop - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Watkins Glen, New York

Extremely popular donut shop serving, tried and true coffee from a Bunn setup and delicious donuts. Lines to get in are understandable. I enjoyed my visit, you will too. read more

Loved the donuts, worth the indulgence. Go early as they sell out (yeah, I went twice to get the full selection). Friendly staff added an extra donut because they thought one was a bit "small." (They're huge) read more

See all

I can't imagine coming here during peak season. It was pretty busy for a dead week day. The breakfast sandwiches are pretty good and the donuts are delicious. I think everything is decently priced for a vacation town. It's a good spot for a quick breakfast. Bring cash! read more

Food was fabulous, service was amazing! Maria was on top of things, and didn't mind giving us a hard time about not wanting and then wanting donuts after breakfast. Beautiful young lady with a bright future ahead of her! She wanted us to clarify the she looks like the before meth Miley Cyrus! Thanks for a great breakfast!!! read more

Always a must do when in town. Great food and service. You get exactly what you see.

Excellent service! Great breakfast, awesome donuts. Cute diner. Definite stop and check it out read more

We were visiting from Larchmont on a family trip and stopped here on our way out. The moment we walked in, we were greeted and once we ordered, the food came out fast. Not only was it fast but the donuts were delicious and had a great crisp to them. They do not skimp on the glaze and/or filling either. Lastly, the ladies working the place were all in unison and offered a great positive vibe to the whole place. Thank you! read more

I am a donut snob and these were outstanding. Fresh tasty and all great flavors. Had the chocolate coconut, apple cider, vanilla sprinkle and some cream filled powdered long John style thing that is the best donut I've ever had. Light and airy and so great with a cup of coffee. So sad I'm not local but probably better for my belt and weight. Service was quick and polite. read more

A solid breakfast spot while in town. The breakfast Sammie is a good deal and the omelets are a good size but pricey by comparison. Make sure to get a donut before you leave. The PB&J was my favorite. Food: Good but basic, a little expensive Service: very good but needs more staff when busy Ambiance: local donut shop with tables read more

Great little donut shop. I enjoyed the coffee and sugar donut which wasn't too sweet. My husband loved his breakfast sandwich. The service was awesome read more

One of the best donuts I have ever had. So fresh! Great selection. The young lady serving us was very kind and helpful! Can not wait to return! read more

Excellent service. Delicious eggs - everything as we requested. Great donuts! Coffee was so-so but refills were plenty. Lots of good energy here! read more

we came back again after one year and i can say the breakfast is just like last year. Fantastic They are closed Tuesday read more

We stopped here for breakfast on a Sunday morning. Get there before 11 am, as it turns into take out only after that. I ordered a Mexican spicy omelet -- when I saw it had chorizo in it, I was sold! Breakfast came with toast of your choice. I did think the price was pretty steep for $18 though. Service was attentive. I didn't try the donuts (this time) but heard they are fantastic. read more

We enjoyed the great service and selection of omelets. They are friendly and come by often to fill up your coffee. They have plenty of tables so it seems like you can often get one even when there is a lineup for donuts. read more

Breakfast super quick. Home fries, eggs, bacon and toast. Filling! A bit too much paprika on the potatoes, but still yummy. Worth the stop here especially after your hike of the Glen. Make sure to get a donut to go. read more

Tobey's Donut Shop - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Watkins Glen, New York

See all

We had breakfast here on a Friday morning. The place was busy people coming and going. We sat down and had bacon eggs home fries and toast. We asked for eggs over hard and got undercooked eggs. I'm ok with it but the wife. The home fries were cooked crispy and had a lot of crunch. It was a little bit oily but we liked it. We got a couple of donuts for the road and they were very very good! Food was a little pricey but we will be back again. read more

See all

What can I say?... The donuts are AMAZING!! Bagels, good, coffee.. just regular. 5 stars for the donuts. Will come back and recommend to everyone ;) read more

Doughnuts were amazing. Breakfast sandwich was the perfect, greasy, cheap Sandwhich of your dreams. Worth the wait if there's a line read more

Tobey's Donut Shop - 1/2 doughnut selection - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Watkins Glen, New York

my wife and I got there a little later in the morning and unfortunately they were out of quite a few donuts we would try but decided to stay. The breakfast sandwiches were AMAZING. Sausage, egg and cheese on a bagel and boy did the bagel have butter on it!!! We went back two days in a row because the first day was so good! Very friendly service, good food for a good price! A nice little food spot just off the main strip of Watkins Glen! read more

Tobey's Donuts are the REAL deal! Screw DD, they've always been garbage. Their Sour Cream Old Fashioneds are literally the Food of the Gods! read more

Corn beef hash was delicious, good breakfast sandwiches, not to mention the donuts and coffee. Thank you for your service

My parents and I were dropping by the Watksin Glenn for the lakeside views, dropped by Tobeys Donuts for breakfast and we were pleasantly blown away! Walking into the diner you will immediately feel a humble and warm atmosphere with the red leather lined booth seats and two vivacious waitresses that seated us at a booth with menus and explained the donut selection for the day. We were here on a weekday morning and 3/4 of the booths were full with what seemed to be a mix of locals and visitors, which speaks to the quality and fame of the establishment. Their donut selection was broad and delicious. Boasting of their homemade recipes, the waitress told me her favourite was the "Bismark"-labeled cinnamon roll. They were happy to warm it up for me and every bite was soft, laced with the perfect level of cinnamon and frosting, heavenly! Would highly recommend! Their breakfast offerings were classic and simple with variations of eggs, seasoned home fries, your choice of sausage/bacon/ham and/or omlettes. I had the #3 with 2x over easy eggs, 3x sausage links and complementary buttered sourdough toast. Everything was clearly freshly made on the grill and perfectly hit the spot. Our coffees came with refills that the waitress, although busy tending to other tables, attended to promptly. Other brunch spots tend to provide way too many options that the customer is often burdened with decision fatigue. This family run diner with top notch classics, attentive waiting staff and an authentic donut recipe is a rare and valued breath of fresh air! read more

See all

I could write odes to your cider and sour cream donuts. Both are the best I've ever had. The cider donuts are now the gold standard, with a great mixture of cinnamon and fresh nutMeg(?) I'm so glad we got there early to get variety and grateful for your going back to find a new tray of cider donuts! A fan for life. read more

We went here after reading the reviews and were not disappointed. The donuts are excellent Not greasy, flakes, not too sweet. Such a pleasure to go to a local business and be delighted. We also had breakfast but the donuts were the highlight read more