Andersons is a small little deli in Pittsgrove. The sandwiches are fantastic. The service is excellent and I definitely recommend this place. read more

Truly the country store vibe. Can only use cash like it used to be. Been going there 60+ years. Unfortunately the cheesesteaks like everything else went up in price but the insides got smaller. Quick service with a smile is what you get! read more

Excellent cheesesteaks. Nice people. It's a country store in the middle of cornfields. That pretty much sums it up.

Grabbed sandwiches for some coworkers. Everyone loved their sandwich. The ladies were so nice when talking the order over the phone. Check out was quick and all workers are pleasant. Only thing that can make this place better is if they took cards for payment... however, they are worth making sure to have cash on hand. read more

Great food and service !!! And always consistent quality !! Best around !!! From cheese steaks to Rubin's or just a sub !!! read more

Great little country store tucked away in God's Country. I liked the store, the woman behind the counter, $10.44 after tax and most of the roll. But the more I think about this cheesesteak; 1. it needed more cheese. 2. The mushrooms needed more grill time. 3. mushrooms and onions needed to be mixed with the meat and cheese better. read more

See all

The food was comfort food and delicious. The staff was pleasant and always looking to create a good atmosphere.

I've had a couple friends tell me the cheesesteaks are the best here. And reading the reviews I was excited to try em. Going into the store itself was like stepping back in time. Love this store. Now the cheesesteak did not live up to expectations nothing special bout it at all. Only reason it's 4 stars is because of the store itself. The cheesesteak eh read more

This place's breakfast sandwiches, cheesesteaks, and everything else they make is so good. If it weren't cash only it'd be a perfect 5.

A true mom and pop shop often frequented by the locals. They have delicious sandwiches and are often generous with the fillings. Friendly and full of character, I recommend Andersons Deli for all your sandwiches. read more

One of the few places in this area with good food! Everything is always fresh and delicious. I've never received an order that wasn't absolutely correct. Service is fast. Orders are completed quickly. Everyone is so friendly. Cash only establishment. No fryer. read more

They have the best breakfast sandwiches on the east coast. Anything else I get is a disappointment. Seriously. I get steak/egg/cheese w/ 2 eggs on a round roll. I have had bacon, ham, just eggs. All good. Everyone I know swears by them. We drive 20 minutes at least once every 2 weeks for them. Open at 5AM for you hunters, fishermen, and farmers!! Cash only! read more

Nice, old time country convenience store. There are sodas, Tastykakes, fresh foods and tables to eat outside. The building is old and historic. Very cute! read more

Anderson's Country Store - a car parked in front of it - Delis Near Me - Elmer, New Jersey

See all

The sandwiches here are stellar. My family and I drive 25 mins each way just to get their cheesesteaks. I had a cheesesteak today with mayo, fried onions, and cooper sharp and it was out of this world. This place is a hidden gem in south jersey and well worth the drive. Only downside is that they don't take cards and also don't have an ATM on site, so def bring cash. read more

Best Cheese Steaks around, tasty breakfast sandwiches, nice little country store. Employees are very nice too.

Stopped by here on the way home from a day trip in Cumberland County yesterday. We were starving and Anderson's was the first store we encountered on way back to the shore. We ordered a grilled cheese sandwich and a Buffalo Chicken Sub from the deli counter. I'd be lying if I didn't acknowledge that I was a little bit apprehensive at first being that this was a general store in the middle of literally nowhere - but once we received our order and brought it back to car, I was in total heaven. My girlfriend loved her grilled cheese and my sub was phenomenal. If you are ever in the area and need a place to grab a quick bite or pick up basic provisions, Anderson is the place to go! read more

Everything is good. The Sandwich's are awesome especially on those delicious rolls . The service is amazing and all the girls that are there are always so friendly. Highly recommended read more

Food is always good. Fast service. Everyone is always very nice. Also have a big selection of chips, candy, drinks.

Great sandwiches and always friendly. Cute little local store that is well stocked. Five star

Best place in town! You can't go wrong with the breakfast sandwiches, and the cheese steaks are just as good! Friendly staff and a very cool old vibe to this place. read more

Best deli in South Jersey! Everything here is fresh! The cheesesteaks are to die for! Try the barbecue chicken cheesesteak too it's delicious! The only bummer is that it's cash only! read more

I was at a tennis tournament at Shalick High School and wanted to grab a little bite to eat. There are not a whole lot of options in this part of South Jersey, but I took a chance on Anderson's Country Store and I am glad that I did. Besides being convenient to Shalick, this spot is also convenient to Parvin State Park. Anderson's is not much to look at from the outside, but if it is anything it is authentic - this is truly a store out in the country. It is an old wooden building and was complete with 3 old guys drinking coffee on the porch. You walk in and are greeted with a main room full of pretty much anything that you might need - this is not just a convenience store, but a tiny little grocery store. In the back corner is a grill with the menu laid out on one of those old felt menu boards with the stick-in letters. I was greeted with a smile by three nice ladies and ordered a pork roll, egg, and cheese. My sandwich was made to order and served on a soft kaiser roll. As others have said, Anderson's does not take credit, debit, or checks. There is no ATM available on premises, but the Bank of Elmer has a branch about a mile up Centerton Road past Shalick High School. They charge $3 for an ATM charge if your are not a Bank of Elmer cardholder. You might think twice about stopping at Anderson's, but there is no need to do so - they will take good care of you. It is a lot quicker than driving 10 miles to Elmer or Route 55 to get what you need. read more

See all

For a little business on the edge of Pittsgrove, I really enjoy the selection they have here in the store and the food is excellent.

ridiculously good sandwiches. I personally prefer the buffalo chicken with bleu cheese, but they're all delicious. been eating here for years and every time it's fantastic. they also have various snack and drink items that you'd expect at a corner store. family owned and operated. cash only. read more

Love the sandwiches! Ham, egg white, cheese and jalapeño on a round roll is a personal favorite. A good price too

Andersons has ABSOLUTELY AMAZING subs and cheesesteaks.. I personally go out of my way to order here, because they are THAT GOOD! Lunchtime gets pretty busy, so order ahead to save time. Highly recommended. read more

Anderson's is a little country convenience store, and they've got the things that you'd expect. But where they really shine is their subs! They make a variety of hot and cold subs of all sorts, but my go to is their cheesesteak. It's my favorite one in South Jersey, and rivals the best I've had overall. Be sure to bring cash though, as they don't accept credit card. read more

The best Buffalo chicken cheesesteak!! Love stopping in here on the way home from Parvin State Park. Cash only but has atm. Little store has everything you could need! Definitely suggest trying it out read more

Andersons is the place that everyone from Pittsgrove and Upper Deerfield go to! Andersons is in an old building and still had the original flooring. So neat!! They have your basic one stop shop needs! Their food is absolutely amazing! My favorite are the cheesesteaks! The owners are just so sweet. They always treat my grandparents so special! Andersons has a ton of memories I'm sure for everyone. They do takeout only. I wish there was a little place to eat in the back but they never did that. Parking is great! This is on the corner so you will have to wait at the light for a little bit. read more

Great little spot for a quick sandwich and snack. It's like a flashback to 50 years ago, love it.

Nice small deli in the country side. Subs are delicious they have the freshest ingredients. Always stop here on my way thru. I enjoy giving small businesses my business. They have lottery, food, drinks, and other essentials. Old time setting gives it a warm essence inside most of the shelves and the floor is aged well. read more