I made a review on this place 9 years ago and came back to say they are still hands down THEEEEEE best seafood spot. Still consistent after all these years! I'm a seafood lover and I have yet to find a place better! read more

Great food! and great service! Everyone had a great attitude and was extremely helpful.

Stopped by here over the weekend to pick up some seafood (ordered 2 pounds shrimp, 1 pound of perch. broccoli, corn and potatoes) steamed medium spicy! Really good and healthy! Haven't been here in years! Always good service; however, ambiance always low key. Not too crowded for a Friday. Free parking in plaza. Will stop back by most definitely!! read more

The turkey necks were tough, old and season less... thats all I tried because the boudin they advertise they didn't have.

The food was okay the lady was rude as hell. I spent $70 on two plates of food and a few extras. I will never go back. It wasn't worth

Andy's has quality A1 seafood. They're clean and the food is delicious. Prices vary on what you want but I usually pay no more than $25. Forgot to mention they are very fulfilling. read more

See all

I love Andy's there crawfish are always good and fresh u like the other places and they have good fried shrimp

Best seafood on this side of town. Crab cakes are the best and the prices are reasonable. Every time I'm here visiting my sister I always stop by for either the crab cakes, whiting, or mussels. read more

Today was my first time here after another business failed to meet my expectations. The business was clean & it wasnt packed, which I was surprised about because it was a friday evening. I ordered the steamed shrimp & crab cluster combo and it was amazing!! I could have used more spice, but it was seasoned perfectly! I added .5lbs of shrimp & an extra crab cluster, but I would've been full with the regular order. I will be back ! read more

Andy's Seafood Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Lithonia, Georgia

This is our go to. Never disappointed. It is not a done in location but you will not regret going.

Saturday was my second time getting food from Andy's Seafood Market. My review of Andy's is it needs to be cleaner and neater, the place is very junky. Frozen food so unorganized. The food tasted better the first time I ate from there. I will follow-up to see if it's getting better. Thank you read more

I love Andy's! From the shrimp, crawfish, crab legs, fried fish, corn, potatoes & broccoli!! It's all very delicious! Always quick & easy & always yummy! read more

It was just ok. The perch was overcooked and hard. The shrimp was better but not enough for me to go back.

Fast, professional and friendly. Great food and service! I have been going for years and they never disappoint.

The wings were good in the past but recently the chicken wings were soaked in grease. The fish is OK but expensive.

Pretty good seafood . I've been coming here a long time . The crab legs and fried lobster tail is the bomb . A must try js the fried salmon you won't be disappointed. read more

Andy's Seafood Market - Lobster tail shrimp - Seafood Markets Near Me - Lithonia, Georgia

Nasty...Nasty....Mannnn..this was not the move at ALL..I ordered F2 Tilapia(soft,boring and bland), Shrimp was rubbery cardboard, and the fries were soaked in oil and seasoning salt...Had to pay for condiments that normally are complimentary. Don't waste your time!!!! read more

Andy's Seafood Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Lithonia, Georgia

See all

HORRRRRRIBLE! RUNNNNNNNNNNNNN! I came from Los Angeles and all I wanted was some crawfish. This was the WORST crawfish I have ever had on my life! It was so over cooked. When you chew it it tastes like sawdust. I had to add so much lemon to the seasoning. I can't imagine what I would have done if I hadn't had any lemon juice. I can't remember the last time I was so disappointed. ***ENTER AT YOUR OWN RISK!!!*** read more

Andy's Seafood Market - Overcooked crawfish. Well whatever does it mean when all your meat is dark grey and unable to chew - Seafood Markets Near Me - Lithonia, Georgia

Andy's is consistent and tasty. I am a pescatarian so I know my way around seafood. This place had never disappointed us. There food is made to order so it is always fresh and good. read more

His is hands down my favorite go to spot for seafood. I'm from Louisiana and Andy's is the first to get it right. I can eat here everyday and never get tired of it. Customer service is also great! I haven't had one problem with this place and I've been eating here for about 3 years Two years since I wrote this review and my feelings remains the same read more

I'm literally here every week! I can't stay away from their steamed broccoli and corn. It is the best flavored veggie plate I've ever had. Everything is good here all the way down to the hush puppies.. you won't be unsatisfied. read more

These mostly frozen seafood places seem to be growing in popularity on the east OTP. Many appear to be owned by Asians and have names like Bayou or New Orleans seafood. I'm from Louisiana and a bit turned off by this misuse of bayou state phrases to attract business. I'm at the point where I avoid these types of restaurants now. This is a barebones seafood shop that offers a small selection of fish fillets and frozen shellfish, with a few basic side dishes. They will steam or fry your food for $1 or $2 per pound. They charge $0.50 for any sauce or butter. There is one long table with 4 chairs for folks who dine in. I got fried perch and fries. The fish was decent. The fries were only fair with too much seasoned salt. read more

The seafood and veggies are always fresh!!! They even peal and de-vein the shrimp... They use red potatoes and we like the broccoli instead of the corn! read more

Andy's Seafood Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Lithonia, Georgia

See all

This place was recommended to me the last time I was in Atlanta so I tried and it was great but didn't write a review but after eating at it this weekend, I had too. It is a really small place with no website and you would need to prepare to take the food with you. There is one six foot community table if you just had to eat in. Well worth the price. Service is above average with friendly folks working. One of the best whole in the wall places every for seafood and the sad part is that I have passed this place for years. A well kept secret! read more

Love the fried dishes, especially the shrimp and salmon. But the steamed fish was uncomfortably full of bones and despite having a great flavor was too difficult to enjoy; I ended up just throwing it away. read more

Crawfish, crab legs, fish, shrimp,. broccoli... EVERYTHING is delicious! Must try place!

STAY AWAY FROM THIS PLACE! Don't eat here! I ate one piece of whiting and my young numb and I'm getting a headache. I eat organic so I'm free of a lot of chemicals which make me sensitive to chemicals and food that's not good. This food will make you sick! read more

Andy's Seafood Market - This whiting fish plate. I'll freeze it to have it tested - Seafood Markets Near Me - Lithonia, Georgia

The food quality and portions have changed. I've been going to this establishment for years but will not return moving forward. The " medium" shrimp are now salad sized pre- cooked slimy shrimp. I could not eat them...The crab legs were extra small. Lucky for them, my husband picked up our $90 to go order because I wouldn't have accepted the food. I understand restaurants are struggling due to the pandemic however this is unacceptable. I did call and was told they changed vendors. They need to change again. read more

I actually enjoy getting my seafood at Andy's. The price is very reasonable, a tad bit salty. But overall it's the best seafood joint I've hit & they love my son read more

I ordered four crab clusters, steamed shrimp, broccoli, and corn. It was really good. The crab came out effortlessly which confirms it was cooked to perfection. I enjoyed the garlic season sprinkled on top and the butter sauce. The cost was over 50 but it was well worth it. read more

This was my first time trying this location and I have to say I love how prompt they are in making your order. Delicious and affordable. I got scallops, potatoes, sausage, 2pounds of crab legs and the large shrimp. I recommend this place to any and everyone. read more

Food is great, but customer service is HORRIBLE. The lady that mainly takes orders barely speaks English and will slick say something rude trying to be "funny". If you call in to order, be prepared to be on hold for at least 20minutes because they're "busy". Apparently the phone is secondary. In store customers take priority (clearly no one there understands business). As long as you're okay with bad customer service, the food is fantastic and will make you want to go back for more frequently. read more

This is a great seafood spot that is reasonably priced and fresh. I come here only for their steamed fish and shrimp platter with spicy seasoning. It's good, fast and fresh seafood. The only gripe about this place is the parking lot. The parking can be cumbersome at times when it's busy and it's best to call ahead and pickup your food as the wait on weekends can be quite long. Also don't expect to eat in they have a small table (for waiting more so) otherwise check them out! read more

I love them. They are the best out of the other similar "competitors" in the area. I find that this restaurant is extremely clean & everything is always cooked accurately and fresh. The prices are reasonable & customer service is fair, especially considering how busy they always are . I usually order steamed snow crab and shrimp. read more

So good and fresh!! Very clean and the customer service is awesome. A friend referred them to me and I tried out for a Friday night... When back the next day because I couldn't get enough!! read more

This place is close to home amd im glad it is. I love their food. The prices are decent, depending of course on what you get. The seasoning is good. I recommend. read more

Best seafood I've ever had. Always consistently delicious!! I get the steamed tilapia with broccoli and corn and a lot of spicy seasoning. I'm addicted to pepper it's sooo yummy & the price makes it all the better !! read more

Crazy happy I found this place, I almost gave up on finding a new Friday night spot since Supreme Fish and J&J fell off. I can't stop coming here, I always get the fried tilapia and shrimp with hush puppies, vegetables and 2 remoullaide sauces. The prices are decent, the quantity is enough to last a couple days, and everything is fresh and made to order. I plan on switching things up soon, if their other food is as good as what I usually get, I'm not worried. read more

I have to say, I was really very surprised...In a good way!!! It's a little hole in the wall neighborhood seafood "deli" market. They let you use your EBT card to purchase the seafood, and charge a dollar per pound to cook it. It's so freakin' delicious!!!! Don't listen to these other folks that say that they are horrible. The only only thing horrible is those folk's taste for food! They must be trying to get something for free, because this place is off the chain...Trust ME!!! read more

Best damn seafood you can find in Decatur. Their always,so busy but they should be because their food is seasoned so well. I love their crablegs and corn and potatoes i get it everytime i go there. I love the fact that i can pick my own crab legs from the freezer read more