We have been going here for years to both sell things and buy. It's sort of self serve but there is always someone around to help you if you look. This is not a Goodwill or St Vincent store so don't expect that quality or price range. This is the good stuff with good value for what you get. The variety of things change fairly quickly so its worth a look every couple of weeks if you have something specific in mind. Do not drop in with a piece of furniture without calling first. The owners know what sells and what doesn't so call and send pictures before going. Small quality things are generally appreciated like table top stuff or good art. Masks are required of course. Give them a shot. It's never too crowded in there and it's a big space so you can keep your distance from others. read more

This place just needs to sell already to someone who will actually be open during posted business hours and care about their consigners and customers. What a waste. read more

I have never had such GREAT service as I had at Another Home consignment.I had only six days to shop for furniture have it delivered and set up before I had to leave for a cruise.And the wonderful girls at Another Home made it happen.Your the BEST. THANKS FOR ALL YOU DID FOR ME Jim Bossingham P.S.Can't wait to come back and shop again read more

If I could give no stars, I would. Overpriced. Period. Rude. No greeting. Zero tact with answers to questions. I've been in at least 4 times, or more. It's always the same. I never have returned. Not sure how they stay in business. read more

I am a huge fan of MCM furniture, so this place is one of the "must visit" sites when in Madison. So much beautiful furniture. However, pricing is frightfully high, like the bright-orange swivel chair for $6000. Yes, you heard me, $6000. Nothing in this store is even remotely reasonable. To decorate an entire living room would cost upwards of $15, 000. So, if you like MCM, Danish Modern, etc., this is definitely the place for you. But bring your checkbook. read more

See all

Was in the store Saturday afternoon and the woman working was very short and plain rude to us! I felt she was trying to ignore us. We just built a home in Middleton after relocating from out of state and we need EVERYTHING! The employee seemed very judgmental. I will go where my business is appreciated. We will never be returning again. Such a shame on small business Saturday too. read more

I stopped in yesterday for the first time and was very impressed with the quality of the furnishings they offer, the fairness of their pricing and also with the 3 sisters who are now operating this place like real pros I plan to bring in one of my Stickley pieces for resale in a great environment read more

I love this store. The sister's have always been wonderful to me and I did get a great price on a book case that is all wood. This is high end furniture at a fair price. Please remember that you can negotiate a price. The furniture is high quality and if you see something you like...make an offer. The ladies were always so nice. read more

I decided to browse at this place after finding it on Yelp. This is no thrift store; this store has many high-end furniture and decorator pieces, all in like new condition. I am guessing this is a popular place for wealthy people to send their gently used furniture when they decide to remodel. The store is not cheap, but if you are looking for high quality used furniture, this is a good place to stop. I didn't buy anything, so I can't review the customer service- I was not bothered by the employee when I was browsing. The only thing I didn't like is that there were a lot of unpriced pieces the day I was in. read more

I am not one to complain but after my experience that I just had I thought I better post on this shop. Just brought a what I call pretty nice purchase of approx $250.00 on some furniture. The furniture is in pretty good shape, its the staff that could have used some help. Here is why: 1) After my father who simply pointed and waived from across the store and said, "Can you help me please" . Got a yelling at from the employee on hand, saying how she shouldn't be pointed at. I thought that was uncalled for. Working retail I have dealt with much worse than someone pointing and waving and politely asking "can you help me?". 2) I am 8 months pregnant, not that I expected any sympathy but there was absolutely no help offered in loading heavy furniture. It was my Dad and myself. 3) If your going to take your child/grandchild or any child to work with you, either have them help or stay out of the way. 4) Don't lie to the client, saying you can't discount something if it hasn't been there a month, when in the breath just 5 minutes earlier you stated, " Yeah I should give a 25% percent discount because its been here so long." This was in reference to buying 3 pieces of the set verses 2. When I only got the 2 pieces it was stated it hasn't been here a month yet.... Kind of hard to believe that when you just stated its been here a while... read more

Wonderful and welcoming is how I would describe this store. Going there is beyond a shopping visit; it's a very enjoyable experience I would suggest to everyone. Sorry to hear a Mom felt unwelcome but I would expect that to be a rare response. I have always seen the employees as friendly and patient. Once while I was shopping, an unsupervised child knocked over a row of framed pictures, breaking a lot of glass. The shopkeeper (who lost some significant income with the broken items) was only concerned with the safety of the child and did not show frustration with the parent. I was greatly impressed. I highly recommend this shop! read more

I wish I could give this store 2.5 stars. They have nice items, but the prices are about 25% higher than they should be.

This is the nicest consignment store I've been in. The owner has obviously taken care to select only the nicest gently used merchandise. I thought the prices seem very fair. I have noticed that items seem to sell very quickly. On more than one occasion when I've gone back to get something, it's been sold. If you are looking for a nice piece of furniture and some new accessories that you would be proud to have in your home, then I think you would enjoy this store. read more

I love this shop!! The items are constantly changing. The variety is wide spread from contemporary to antique. The prices are very reasonable even if something seems a little high at first we always settle on a price we are both very happy with. I make it a habit to try and stop by at least once a week because I know things come in and go out quick. read more

Although I have not been to this store yet, I will NEVER go to this store. I recently read an account from a fellow mom who visited the store with her two young children. She detailed how rude and inconsiderate the salewoman was upon her visit. She was made to feel completely unwelcome, and was treated with no respect. It's amazing that a store would feel like they could treat their customers this way....I thought a retail store stayed in business BECAUSE of customers. You would think in this economy that the store would be looking to make money. Some people don't have the luxury to leave their kids at home when they go shopping, or run errands. It is sad to me that in a city that was once ranked the best place to live in America would have a business that was so family UNFRIENDLY. I will not be going to this store, and will be advising all of my friends-moms and non-moms to not go as well. read more