Drove from Peoria, IL on 7/18/2025 to get a Made-Rite sandwich ( we live in Florida)…read more Checked on website before coming to Galesburg, said it was open, till 3pm , only to find it was closed for vacation.

Being a person of color...i felt discriminated against. I went there for lunch to go. I walked in…read morethe door before two couples and a single gentleman. They took my order first...all I order was two loose meat sandwiches and a drink. The 1st couple ordered 1 chili dog, chips, drinks and two sandwiches. The other couple ordered a salad and a couple sandwiches with drinks. The single man ordered 5 or 6 sandwiches to go. Remember I got in the door first and my order was taken first! The first couple got their order, the second couple got their order then the single gentleman got his order. My order just sat on the ready tray. Everyone was almost done eating before I got my order. The guy that ordered 6 sandwiches was long gone. I finally got my order. By the time I got back to work which was only about 5 minutes away my sandwiches were cold. Don't know if this was done on purpose or not...because of the color of my skin but I probably won't ever go back there again! If I could rate this establishment a -0 I would.

Complained when I placed my order at the kiosk. Family of 5 bringing you business, sorry for…read moreruining your slow night 2 hours before you close.

Always piping hot, friendly service, clean dining area. I love the Bacon Philly Sandwich.read more

This week's special was Firecracker Fries! They were absolutely delicious! There specials never…read moredisappoint although it is hard to steer away from the food on the menu! Midtown Burger is always a 10 out of 10

Always a great experience and great food! Family friendly…read moreand everything I've had (calzone, pizza, bacon cheeseburger) have always been yummy!

Calzones were ready on time. Mine was extra greasey. And sauce was cold. Size was small compared to…read morethe last time. I still like the their food . But this time it seemed rushed to make.

Their baked potatoes with toppings are delicious! I especially enjoy the one with sliced beef and…read morecheese sauce!

Don't waste your money. I was visiting the area and my wife went to get me a sandwich. She calls me…read moreand tells me a philly cheese steak is $8 for half and $16 for a whole. I was like, I'm not that hungry get me the half. My asked if the onions are cooked, and the didn't know. How can she not know? So my wife brings me the sandwich. This thing was so small. The bag was heavier than the sandwich. I open it up to find a steak-um on a grocery store roll, no cheese, that's it. What a joke! I was so mad I wanted to return it but the drive was too far. This place sucks really bad!!! KEEP AWAY

Make sure you only read reviews from 2017 on because they have a completely new facility and new…read moremenu and it's 100 times better!!! Everything we've tried is good. Think pub food. If you're looking for a Michelin star restaurant, this isn't it, but everything is good. They're dinner side salads could be improved with better lettuce. This is the only thing that hasn't changed from the old facility/menu IMO. Try the Ruben nuggets appetizer (may not be called that) is AWESOME if you like ruebens. They're Rueben makings inside egg roll wrappers. Think Reuben egg rolls! Yes, we recommend this restaurant.

Fiesta Thursday so asked for the "fiesta menu". He said no menu today but you know tacos,…read moreburritos, etc. I said fish tacos. He said they didn't have them. I would have preferred to see a menu. So I ordered a salad and jalapeño burger. After my salad I had to ask the waitress for my burger as the guy tending bar was counting his tips & other busy work and not coming over by me. When I asked the waitress for my burger is when he developed an attitude. Sandwich was a little dry, otherwise very good and by the time he came back by it was half gone.. he bought me extra sauce, I said thank you and he said yep. Not can I get you anything else.. just hoping for a good experience & it didn't happen.. I'll continue going to the "General Store" where I get great service from a friendly staff.

Food-5 Me and my friend asked our hotel receptionist what…read moreher favorite pizza place is in Galesburg. She said it's hands down The Pizza House. After she said that a hotel guest in the lobby also chimed in and said the same thing. I love a good thin crust pizza with some crispiness on the crust, but not burnt. This was definitely one of the best pizzas that I've had in years. The sauce was good, there was a good proportionate amount of cheese, and that crust was perfect. We also got the house sampler and there was not one appetizer included in that sampler that I didn't like. Everything was made fresh and came out hot. Service-5 The service here was exceptional. Our server was very attentive and always came back at the right time to refill my drink. The kitchen staff was on point, and the owner was very welcoming and polite. You could tell that they actually care about their place of business. Ambiance-5 I loved the feel of this restaurant. It felt very old school in the best way. They definitely keep up on the cleaning, and are able to create a friendly atmosphere. Overall-5 Would I go back to this pizza place? 100% yes! This is going to be my go to pizza place anytime I'm in Galesburg. Everything about The Pizza House was exceptional. If you have not tried this pizza spot you are missing out big time, especially if you are like me and love a good thin crispy pizza.

Just wanted to give another shout out to The Pizza House! This was my 3rd visit here, being from…read morethe about an hr away makes it more difficult to get here than I would like. This pizza is phenomenal. Maybe the thinnest and great tasting crust you can find. So so good. Great sauce, and cheese. They don't skimp on the toppings like a lot of other places! Service was great, and food came fast even for a very busy time that we were there. Cool building with an open kitchen where you can see them slinging the pizzas! A must if you are in Galesburg!

As a graduate of Knox College in the 90s, Alfano's was a staple. Flavorful and budget friendly…read moreofferings made this small, regional chain a success with locals and college students alike. That being said, when our next generation visited to explore continuing education, the large pie and Sicilian bread we consumed on the way out of town was celebrated by our teens. There's just something about Alfano's ingredients, sauce, and pizza that resonates with your palate. If you're new to the 'burg, the rundown, piecemeal venue Alfano's currently resides will come as a bit of a shock. The pictures inside and out may not do justice to the discerning first time visitor. Rest assured, the resulting meal will be delicious! I wildly disagree with Yelper, Yvonne T., who judged this venue on a late night, inebriated experience. While I identify with the bread and butter of Galesburg's branch, Alfano's fills the friendly, affordable pizza needs of the area and will always have my business.

Great food served up by a great family. I have never had a bad meal there. This is definitely a…read moreplace I take guests when they come to visit!