I was in the Rochester area and this place came up in Yelp so I went to check it out. It's not a…read morebig place but it was clean and everything was displayed well. I was especially excited because they had a couple of glass cabinets with Fenton pieces. I collect Fenton so I bought several pieces at reasonable prices. The owner "Rhonda" was there and she was very friendly. She also runs an online auction a couple of times a month at Rhondasauction.com. They are open 10-5 everyday. I will definitely go back when in the area.

I love the place, I even bought things. The women that…read moreworked there were fine, but there was a man that was just terrible and rude and obnoxious. Because of that, my friend and I will never ever step foot in there again, unfortunatly

The selection of items was incredibly. However, service was very dependent on who you spoke to, the…read moremanager on Sunday was a bit rude and escalated a simple question into a bit of a rude and not necessary aggressive conversation. Kayla was fabulous though.

Avoid shopping Sunday's at all costs - Manager Melissa…read more I'm a weekly customer and avid comic collector who loves the treasure hunt here. For context, I stopped shopping on Sundays months ago due to prior issues involving Melissa (weekend manager) and another employee. After six months away, I tried again--same result. I also observed smoking within a few feet of the public entrance when I arrived. On 10/19/2025, I brought two early '70s Batman issues to the 5-items-or-fewer line with Melissa, who was visibly agitated and had just called for additional front-end help. She allowed a one-item customer to go ahead--no issue. During my checkout, she began picking at the price stickers, bending the books, and left nail marks on a cover. I politely asked her not to remove stickers--a routine request I've made many times here because it can damage older paper. She paused for ~30 seconds, then rolled her eyes and replied, "Suuuuuure" in a sarcastic tone as if to imply I was crazy. I declined the purchase and stepped away. She called after me that she would personally buy the books so "no one would lose out," then grabbed the phone, threatened to call the police, ordered me to leave, and banned me--in front of three cashiers and roughly 6-8 customers. I was also accused of "threatening/harassing," which was unfounded and embarrassing. I value this store, but the conduct today was unprofessional and needlessly escalatory--especially from a manager. I hope ownership reviews the footage, clarifies handling of collectibles (including sticker removal), and addresses customer communication and de-escalation.

Sadly, they are no longer in business. This place was wonderful and my secret source for amazing…read moredeals! It was very small however. They closed this past Summer 2025. Yes I'm absolutely certain, I bought some display shelves right off their walls!

This shop is in a quiet neighborhood in the town of Chili. From the parking area, follow the brick…read morepath to a quaint house with a separate shed dedicated to Christmas. You will feel like you are entering a magical place and when you do finally enter, you sense that the owner has taken the time to create a special spot for each treasure to shine. This may sound corny, but you will understand what I mean as you peruse through all the displays. There are figurines of every kind, vintage games and housewares, bottles, buttons, miniature accessories for your assemblages or doll house projects . . . I've been visiting Rochester for 5 years and only today have I discovered this gem. It's worth checking out. And, even if you don't find something on your first visit, you will leave with a lighter gait in your feet.

Excellent staff and items! Highly recommend. This place has wonderful items and we purchased a…read morecoffee table, two end tables and another table to play games in. People are very friendly and all volunteer their time. A wonderful place for a wonderful cause!

Very friendly helpful staff. Reasonable prices. Limited selection but nice quality of furniture.read more

HUUUUUUUUUGE deceiving thrift shop with all kinds of vintage things, classics, collectibles, home…read moreitems, decor, clothing and anything you can imagine. The list goes on and on. Drove past here a few times and couldn't pass up going into a cute little thrift store. This place was everything but little with endless rooms and even a whole second floor. Things are pretty cheap considering other thrift stores sometimes can raise the price for things but this one was pretty reasonable. The ONLY downfall here is I was super turned off by a roach chilling in one of the clothes racks hanging on a shirt. I almost died. Either way, great store if you're in the area. Just wash everything - like really good. There's definitely something for everyone in here!

I went to Penny Lane on Saturday. I was impressed by the variety of the merchandis. There were…read moremany things that brought back memorie. I purchased a decent amount of random items including some Pokemon cards from a vendor upstairs, three packs at $5 each. Upon getting home and giving them to my son to open, we found they are counterfeit, and bad ones at that. One card was printed backwards and all of them look wonky. I realize it is a multi vendor store, but fake merchandise is unacceptable. It makes me question the other, probably honest vendor. If it wasn't an hour and a half away, I would have brought them back for an explanation, if not a refund. Very disappointin.