Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Athena's Magical Treats

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed 9:00 am - 7:00 pm

    Athena's Magical Treats Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Athena's Magical Treats

    Recommended Reviews - Athena's Magical Treats

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Raven F.

    Raven F.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Athena's Magical Treats

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Custom Cakes 818 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Missy's Cupcake Creations

    Missy's Cupcake Creations

    4.0
    (240 reviews)
    2.2 km
    $

    I've heard so many good things about Missy's that I had to stop in. The lady behind the counter was…read morevery pleasant and had a beautiful smile. Everything looked so delicious and smelled heavenly that I wanted it all. I bought a jelly donut, chocolate cake donut with nuts and a cronut. I love jelly donuts and this one was so soft and the jelly was perfect. The chocolate cake reminds of what my mom used to make for me and it was perfection. I'm saving the cronut for later but it smells so good. The cupcakes look so yummy and she mentioned that they cakes as well. I will be ordering a cake from here when it's my birthday. Do yourself a favor and stop by and pickup some donuts you won't be disappointed. Can't wait to try her cakes.

    I stopped in here on Valentine's day and by 2pm their selection was a little slim, but since…read morethey're only open until 3pm that was not surprising. I saw on their menu board they have Gluten Free options, but the woman behind the counter confirmed it's custom order only. Still, it's good that it's an option if you order ahead. And their macrons are GF so I got some of those. They had 11 different flavors, though I only saw tags for some of those flavors so the rest will be a surprise! I also got 4 cupcakes and I had committed myself to buying 4 but wasn't sure I loved 4 flavors of what was left. I ended up with (in order of interest): apple pie, black forest, snickerdoodle and mint chocolate. I should have read my review from 12 years ago because the mint chocolate still tastes like toothpaste to me, but it's a very mild mint so that's good. I wasn't sure I'd like the snickerdoodle but it was amazing! The black forest cupcake had a maraschino cherry inside, which was an awesome surprise! I ate the apple pie one last and it had a little actual apple pie filling inside of it! LOVE THAT!! It feels sacrilegious of me to say, but I think the cupcakes have just a little too much frosting. It's also fair to say these are not cheap cupcakes. You can taste the quality of the ingredients, and they look beautiful, and you pay a premium for all that. Overall, I highly recommend these cupcakes and will definitely stop here again.

    Photos
    Assortment of non-vegan options
    Assortment of non-vegan options
    Exterior
    Exterior
    Mini cupcakes

    See all

    Mini cupcakes
    Sugar Lab Bake Shop

    Sugar Lab Bake Shop

    4.5
    (332 reviews)
    6.0 km
    $$

    Ali at Sugar Lab Bake Shop was such a wonderful part of my daughter's wedding yesterday. From the…read morevery beginning, she was warm, kind, and genuinely lovely to work with -- exactly the kind of person you hope to have around during such an important event. She created the most beautiful three-tier cake for us with delicate pearl details and softly textured rustic tiers that fit the wedding perfectly. It looked stunning, but what everyone kept talking about was how good it tasted. We chose different flavor combinations for each tier, and every single one was incredibly moist, flavorful, and delicious. For anyone debating between a cake and a dessert table, Ali does both beautifully -- but there's something so special about having a gorgeous cake as part of the celebration. Ours became such a focal point of the reception, and the cake cutting ended up being one of the sweetest, most heartfelt moments of the evening. I'm so glad we chose to include one. Ali also handled delivery and placement flawlessly, which made the whole process feel easy and stress-free. We couldn't have been happier with our choice and are so grateful for the care and talent she brought to the day.

    From the tasting of cakes to the end of the night, Sugar Lab Bake Shop provided top tier service,…read moreflavor, and texture. Their wedding cake tasting package yielded a fun and tasty date night and gave us confidence in our choice to rely on them. Our guests adored the lemon bars and brownies and loved the variety we had in our three tier cake: top tier was red velvet cake with vanilla cream cheese filling, middle tier was a champagne cake with strawberry buttercream filling, and our favorite, the bottom tier, was a banana cake with banana brown sugar filling. They were communicative and clear with pricing and I couldn't be happier with their timeliness and the love they put into their goods. My husband and I highly recommend Sugar Lab Bake Shop and dream of their desserts. We can't wait for our anniversary cake!

    Photos
    Christmas cookies
    Christmas cookies
    Cute cake!
    Cute cake!
    Cookies for Lovewell

    See all

    Cookies for Lovewell

    Athena's Magical Treats - customcakes - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...