I'm not sure why the other reviews aren't recommended, especially when they are the most real reviews. Be wary of fake reviews, when they sound too good to be realistic, it's almost always the case. Meanwhile, I would tell you to pay close attention to the negative reviews, becuase unlike positive reviews, no one pays to have bad reviews written about them, so you at least know that they're real. That being said, it's very rare that I've ever come across a person or business that I would go out of my way to tell people to stay away from, but this is one of them and the man who owns it has done some really terrible and disgusting things to both me and my family. Please do not trust this man. I did and it was a terrible mistake and I ended up losing money and valuable family items (furniture, coins, artwork) because of it. Ultimately, I ended up having to involve the local police due to some illegal activities that started to take place involving the holding my items unless I pay a certain amount extra to get them back, and even though the police usually wipe their hands clean of cases like this and just tell people to settle their disputes/claims in court, they actually made him return my items, but he didn't return all of them, because he said he "couldn't find them" at the time, so he said he would return the rest of them the next day. Well, the next day came, but he still didn't return them and now he said that he lost them, so this -explitive- got away with getting the better of both me and my family. So, please, don't make the same mistake I did and try to do business with this man/business, if you even want to call it business, more like robbery and that's honestly what it felt like, as if we just got robbed by a swindler. I should have read some of the other negative reviews ahead of time, but I didn't know, it was my first time working with a supposed "antique dealer". I have the police report as well as other evidence to prove, in detail, that all I've said is not only true, but it was actually worse than what I'm allowed to say in a review, so please feel free to contact me directly via email or pm, and I will be more than happy to share the details with you. read more

Dealing with Guy Ferraro was wonderful. I sold some gold jewelry, and some costume jewelry to him. He was very professional and explained in detail why he was pricing each item for the amount that he was. I have items such as early dishes , plates, and glasses that I wanted to sell as well. He said he couldn't buy them from me but suggested I put them on social media to sell and he spent time with me pricing the items. He wenDealing with Guy Ferraro was wonderful. I sold some gold jewelry, and some costume jewelry to him. He was very professional and explained in detail why he was pricing each item for the amount that he was. I have items such as early dishes , plates, and glasses that I wanted to sell as well. He said he couldn't buy them from me but suggested I put them on social media to sell and he spent time with me pricing the items. He went way above and beyond what I expected and I can't thank him enough for all his time. I highly recommend dealing with Guy if you are selling jewelry.t way above and beyond what I expected and I can't thank him enough for all his time. I highly recommend dealing with Guy if you are selling jewelry. read more

I was seriously pleased with Mr. Guy Ferraro and his business. My father and I went to his store with some items, wondering about their value, and right away, Mr. Ferraro proved to be knowledgeable, honest, patient, and very helpful. In fact, he helped us so much, he single-handedly improved my collecting and gave us advice we'll never forget. His international experience was obvious as well. Perhaps as important as anything, I learned to have real trust in him on that day and since then. I left his store understanding that I met a quality professional with a first-rate business. If you have any items you want to bring to him and learn about, Mr. Ferraro is your man, through and through. I wouldn't even waste valuable time going someplace else. You'll see exactly what I mean when you visit, and I wish the world had more true professionals like him--honesty and experience are a rare combination these days. Because of Mr. Ferraro, Atlantis Antiques is a top-shelf, classy operation. Go there and see for yourself! read more

I randomly reached out and first became acquainted with Guy early January 2021 involving elder family home contents removal and prep for real estate sale. A tremendous motivator and wealth of knowledge offering fair reasonable prices of valuable interest. He was a life saver. A man who no doubt has a sincere passion for what he does naturally becoming a large part of the equation making things happen. We met deadlines and achieved goals. A pleasure working together. I would recommend Guy to anyone struggling with a game plan. After a thorough assessment, the mission for results begins. A most honest genuine individual to assist those in need. A good friend. read more

Guy is super knowledgeable, super respectful and willingly to guide you even if you wish to sell something that is not for him. I have been to other dealers, and unfortunately others do not have his years of experience or credentials to compare to. He has never steered us wrong with knowing the actual value of something, which has nothing to do with what we paid retail years past. Regardless of value, you still need a buyer. He is a vetted appraiser for the government. He has 50 years experience as an appraiser and a restorer. He has so many unique items I have never seen anywhere else. Prices are reasonable as well as his vast selection. read more

I have nothing but wonderful things to say about Atlantis Antiques!! Guy is wonderful, warm, and incredibly knowledgeable. I was looking for a group of knickknacks and old photographs for decoration in my new apartment. He helped me put together a wonderful collection of the most incredible little antique pieces! Each one came with a little story that I could tell their many admirers. He has an incredible collection and an immense wealth of knowledge to share, along with a huge amount of expertise in craftmanship. I could NOT recommend Guy and his business highly enough!!! read more

This is by far, the best place to shop. Every time I visit, there is new merchandise. The store has a fantastic selection of antiques, rare finds, gorgeous art, exquisite furniture, and vintage treasures. The owner is so friendly and informative. As a repeat customer, it's so enjoyable to hear the history of these antiques, and shared enthusiasm. Guy, the owner is honest, trustworthy, and gives more than fair pricing. Way more than a 5 star review. A must visit! The BEST store around! read more

This company is amazing! I've been wanting to sell a piece of furniture that i purchased from the previous home owner and I had no idea if it was worth selling or if it should just be painted. The owner was so helpful with identifying the piece timeframe, type of wood, style and worth. I learned alot from him. I am ready to release it to another person that can truly appreciate it as I did for 20+. I cant thank him enough for his time and valuable information!! read more

Just had an awesome experience with the proprietor, Guy, who took the time to review and appraise some antique items which I had no idea about. I had reached put to a few other "experts" who wouldn't give me the time of day, but Atlantis was on time with our appointment, honest and transparent about the value of my antiques and was a complete professional on every way. Best of all, he was nice. Highly recommended. read more

I made an appointment with Guy to look at Antique Earrings for my daughter's upcoming wedding. He took the extra time to go through so many boxes of jewelry to help me find the perfect pair. He went above and beyond and was so nice to deal with. He had so many antiques I can't wait to go back and spend more time checking out everything else. Great service and experience at Atlantis Antiques. Tracy Brown read more

I had a truly excellent experience with Guy! He was knowledgeable, friendly, and an expert. His shop is filled with countless beautiful items that are all of great quality and great prices. I will definitely be going back and HIGHLY recommend him and his shop to any and everyone. read more

I called to speak about a beanie baby collection and spoke with the owner Guy who was super knowledgeable and beyond helpful. Instead of just trying to make off with money himself he took the time to give us all the information and guidance we needed! Such a sweet man! read more

The owner Guy Ferraro was very helpful and knowledgeable with a lot of the antique pieces in his store. Very reasonably priced. I bought a 1950s Libbey Gold Leaf glass piece set of 12. Will definitely will be going back in the future! -Amara read more

I want to share our wonderful experience with Mr Ferraro. He was extremely helpful and knowledgeable about appraising what we had. We will be back. We are happy with what he paid us. read more

Unbelievable customer service! Professional, goes out of his way to explain every detail, friendly, the real deal! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! read more

sweetest man ever who gave me a pin for free, will give you a great deal on some really beautiful stuff. 10/10 recommend!!!!

Found my new favorite jewelry pieces here. Beautiful and unique. A must see if your in the area.