As another reviewer said, the used car purchase experience was fine. However, the after-sales was ...well ... mediocre at best.
The sales visit (Anthony/Dale) was pretty much like any other respectable car sales lot visit. The only small issues were that the salesperson sat in the back seat during our test drive instead of letting us go off on our own for 10-15 minutes. The car also had its "fuel nearly empty" idiot light on, so we spent some of the test drive putting another gallon of gas in the car. This meant we really couldn't put the car through the full "hard turns" and hard acceleration tests for fear of running out of gas. Not a deal breaker, but not great. They were willing to let us take the car to our mechanic for an independent set of eyes to look over the car, so I got to do the testing I wanted during that excursion anyway. They did honor their no-haggle price - although I had to explicitly point out a decrease in price on their web site that had happened between our initial test drive, taking the car to our mechanic the next day, and closing a deal after returning from my mechanic's inspection.
Our mechanic found the car to be in pretty good mechanical shape, so we were pleased with the car as a whole. The mechanic did note that the front grille was cracked and the headlights were very foggy. The mechanic's official report noted that both items needed attention. The headlight issue is not unusual on used cars and is easily fixed in a an hour or two with a $30 (retail) headlight kit. The grille and its trim pieces, on the other hand, needed replacing (entire grille including trim pieces can be found on e-bay for $100-$200.) To my surprise, AutoNation agreed to do both at no additional charge. They then procured financing for me (not really a challenge, I have an 820+ credit rating), allowing me to do some work/reading while they busied themselves with the financing details.
Overall, I'd rate the sales experience just shy of a 5 star experience - most of the usual shady used (or new) car experiences were not present, but there were things that just weren't perfect. So, SALES: 4.5/5
Unfortunately, post sales was not nearly as good. The headlights were washed and that's about it. Net effect - no change in the foggy status. I did the work myself (again ~$30 and 1-2 hours of inexperienced labor) a few days later and they were fine afterward. The grille part arrived at AutoNation about a week afterward and we made an appointment to get that done the very next day. I talked with the service department person (Abbey) to make sure that it was the entire grille being replaced and not just the chrome parts (or vice versa.) I was assured that, yes, it was the entire grille. Well, it was just the chrome parts only, and they knew. Instead of replacing the grille they just pushed in some epoxy to hold together the cracked parts of the grille. I figured I'll just take my losses and walk away - if they can't be up front about not having the proper part, then I'm not going to trust them to put it in right even if they did follow up with the actual part (and they didn't follow up even though they promised to do so.) So, SERVICE: 2/5.
And then, getting the title. Yikes. This was literally a one owner, no accident or title issue situation. Why their title person (Melissa) couldn't have given me the title on day one, I'll likely never know. But she literally overnight "Fed-Exed" it to me so it would arrive in my hands the very last day I could register the car without paying a late penalty. Probably not coincidentally, the title arrived in my hands on the very last day (i.e. 30 days after sale) that Missouri law allows such to happen without potentially voiding the sale. Lucky for me, Fed-Ex delivered the title late morning, so I could waste a sunny afternoon blowing a vacation day in the local DMV. Thankfully, the title was clean and all the prior paperwork (inspections, bill of sale, etc...) was also in order. I suppose they met the minimum needed to be passable, but just barely. So, ADMINISTRATIVE: 3/5
I really want to be able to say this was a 4 or 5 star experience. It certainly had that potential on the day of the sale, but the post-sales experience does not justify such. Will I shop here again? Yes, but I'll be a little more careful about any items that need service work and I won't close a deal until I have been shown the physical title. OVERALL: 3/5 read more