I'm proud to say, without hesitation that the Buccaneer is home to the best ice cream on the Jersey…read moreShore! So many unique and extremely delicious flavors. The service is quick, even when the line is really long. The staff is always incredibly polite and friendly. And the best part: the scoops they give you are generous and large. One place where you are guaranteed to get your money's worth. Bonus: the plastic cups are shaped like little boats! So precious. I can't recommend the Buccaneer enough, and it's a highlight of my trip every time I come down.

Ice cream is absurdly expensive, staff are very avoidant, portions are unreasonably huge. The…read moreatmosphere is nice but not enough "cash only" signs, as we had no idea that they didn't take any other form of payment and my boyfriend had to run back to our house and grab cash. Miserable experience

good place to eat ice cream. and sit down and relax there…read moreis a lot of history in springers . ask the new owners about springers . i sure they will love to tell you about springers home made ice cream lance

I'd wait in a line that went all the way out to the beach if it meant I got to eat Blue One ice…read morecream and scrape my blue-dyed tongue and feel completely sick! It's a canon experience and an important part of all my Stone Harbor visits. I love cookie dough and this ice cream is my cookie dream. Gobs of oreos and cookie dough and blue ass ice cream. I got a small cone and it was just SO much ice cream. They load you up and send you on your way. Don't be misled by the line. It moves very fast and they have like 10 folks scooping at any given time, on top of an ice cream hostess that answers questions before you approach the counter. Great process for this SH staple. Can't wait until I return next summer for more treats and blue food. Thanks Springers!

Great ice cream Peanut butter ice cream was delicious…read more Mint chocolate chip also good Cute little place with lots of choices service was fast and staff was very friendly

I tipped the woman a generous amount. With a generous tip I excepted a good amount of topping and…read morefudge. She gave me very little. Not pleased. Will b reporting to corporate. Truly unacceptable. Very dissapointed.

Waited 20 minutes for my ice cream. Disgusting, Icy, and not creamy at all. Don't go here unless…read moreyou wanna wait outside for worst ice cream ever. Line outside was so long and it was crowded, it was chilly outside and we couldn't even go inside. Never coming here again.

maybe it is worthwhile to wait 20 minutes for an ice cream cone, but for one iced tea? I recently…read morestopped by after using the public restroom to 'grab' an iced tea. first it was $4.00, but I had waited a few minutes to get to the window, so I was invested. next I was given a number and directed to wait on the side of the building and my order would come out of the window. I waited while the specialty coffees were crafted, the waffle was made from scratch, and various frozen treats were scooped and handed out before the worker went to an urn, poured iced tea into a cup and handed it to me. ridiculous. one and done.

A must when you visit the beach! We love a twist custard with rainbow sprinkles! Great location and…read moreservice!

It's just the most amazing ice cream I've ever had and I've tried ice cream in Japan, Europe, and…read morethe Caribbean. Service is peak and the ambience of a nice ice cream shop is amazing. Please go here.

This is a unique twist to the various fruit bowl places. It's fun and refreshing on a hot day. This…read moreplace is pineapple themed with dole whip in some form in most of its menu choices. We got the pineapple float which is pineapples mixed in with dole whip and pineapple juice. I'd love to try the 5 mile cake next time. It looks like there are 5 layers of pineapple treats. There's also açaí bowls which sound good. The service is fine, albeit a little slow.

This location is new to Stone Harbor, and occupies the space previously held by a mini donut shop…read more Pretty much everything looks exactly as it did as a donut shop, except now the pictures and displays are of fruit concoctions and whips. I chose the small cone with watermelon whip and a small cone with mango whip. This looks just like soft serve icecream but it isn't. It is frozen fruit like an icy smoothie. It is all natural so it isnt all that sweet. Its basically pureed frozen fruit. A small cone or dish of just whip is $6. You can select protein extras and other health conscious add ins for extra cost. There are also combinations of all kinds. I basically thought of Tropical Smoothie in a cone or dish. It was very refreshing with a bit of brain freeze thrown in for good measure. Not sure how well it will do in this location with soft serve a few storefronts down, and water ice at the other end, but business seemed steady and best of all, the one employee seemed able to get everyone served without long lines. Will definately stop in again for that refreshing something different on a hot day.

CASH ONLY! The line is long but plenty of bench seating along the line. The workers are quick to…read moreget your order.

Outrageously Expensive!! And sneaky about it too. You'll notice upon browsing their menu that they…read moredon't have any prices listed. That is on purpose...If they did everyone could plainly see how ridiculous they are and that would turn many away. Instead they want you to step out of line and scan a QR code with your phone to see the prices, which I doubt many people do under the pressure of choosing what to order, keeping the line moving, watching/ helping your children, etc, it's not a good time to be fiddling with your phone and they know it. They don't show their prices on their website either (not a coincidence). So by the time you find out what you're paying, you and your kids have already waited in line, gone through the decision process and placed your order before being sucker slapped in the face/ wallet with an outrageous total $. Now are you really going to tell your kids "No" at that point as they're being handed their ice cream and after going through the whole process because it's way overpriced? Probably not, and that's what they're banking on. Pretty slimy way to do business, and to top it off the portions are pretty small when you receive them. Ice cream is decent, but certainly nothing special or out of the ordinary. You will absolutely feel violated when receiving your order - I guarantee it! I wish I could say to have a look at the prices for yourself, but they're not gonna let that happen until you're there to scan a QR code in person which is pretty deceptive if you ask me. Thankfully I only had one child with me but I will definitely not be returning with any more family members. But Just to give others an idea... 1 regular size cup of soft serve with peanut butter 1 waffle cone with 2 scoops of ice cream - no sprinkles, no extras... $19.00!!! ...for 2 of the most basic no frills items you could order. I still feel violated the next morning which is why I'm here lol. If I had gone with the family of 5 it would have easily been $100 order which seems criminal for something as cheap and plentiful as Ice Cream. Absolute Rip-Off. Will never return.

This place is pretty unassuming from the outside and I'm not sure it would occur to me to go in…read moreover some of the flashier places if I didn't already know about it. They have this stuff I'm kind of obsessed with called Banana Whip. It's frozen bananas pulverized to an ice creamy texture. Only it's better than ice cream because it tastes like bananas and it's actually healthy. If you don't want to be tooooo healthy you can get it with hot fudge and whipped cream. Best ever. Good treat for dogs too when it's hot out (minus the hot fudge and whipped cream). They also have great coffee and espresso which is hard to come by at the jersey shore (yep, I'm a spoiled New Yorker). The owners, Bill and Cookie are great. Go git some Banana Whip.

This place has such a wide variety of ice cream selections. I LOVED my Sundae!! The owners are…read moregreat...such nice people. The coffee is the best on the island!!