Super friendly couple who makes delicious sandwiches! This is a hole in the wall shop that offers great food for great value. The super Italian sub was yummy and for the kids, we ordered the beef cheesesteak sandwich. Take your sandwiches to go and eat by the lake or at the picnic table outside! Would love to come back if we're in the area. read more

Great food when they're open,which could be hit or miss,and kinda pricey. Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx cxxcccc

I am so happy I can finally stop saying "wow I need to try that place" every time I drive by B J Sandwich Shop! It took me about 7 years to finally stop in, but was worth the wait. I popped in for lunch and ordered a turkey club (~$9) and oooh it was yummy! A massive pile of turkey layered with crispy bacon, fresh (no soggy edges here) tomatoes and lettuce, and hard boiled egg (I was skeptical but this was awesome). I got two lunches out of my sandwich -- huge portion! The owners were so nice & welcoming. I can't wait to come back and try some of the hot & cold sub options! read more

See all

We ordered two sandwiches and they were both amazing. The first sandwich was a Taylor ham, egg and cheese with salt, pepper and ketchup. The Taylor ham was sliced nice and thin and was cooked to perfection with a nice crisp on it adding a ton of flavor. Five stars for that!!! Ok the Sloppy Joe with corned beef and pastrami...blew my mind. Also, pastrami and corned beef was sliced thin and both had a lot of flavor. Truly a delicious sandwich. This was our last meal in NJ before we head back to California, so a special thank you to B J Sandwich shop for making our last meal absolutely amazing. read more

B J Sandwich Shop - Corned Beef and Pastrami Sloppy Joe - Delis Near Me - Budd Lake, New Jersey

the best deli ever!!! the fresest deli meats! everything made to order and homemade salads! the sweetest couple you could ever meet! if you havent tried it yet you need to! read more

Good sandwich shop. You need to stop them from cooking the eggs too much else their bacon egg and cheese is awesome.

On the way up to a hike up at the Delaware Water Gap, I got hungry (what else is new?). We went to Yelp and found this random sandwich shop. Walking in the place place was a bit grimy but exceptionally clean. This isn't an Italian deli, this is just some random sandwich spot. I decided to go simple and went with the #10: turkey, roasted red peppers and motz. The half sandwich and a diet coke came out to close to $10. What? I get legendary sandwiches in Hoboken twice the size for less. Whatever, hopefully it's delicious. The sandwich was fresh tasting but the motz had no flavor, the bread was chewy and a bit stale, but I'll give it up, the deli turkey definitely tasted fresh. Overall, the sandwich definitely was pretty tasteless and I didn't even finish it, I always finish it. I don't know the neighborhood, so I'm unaware of local sandwich competition, but for a turkey sandwich I'd keep on moving or make it at home, definitely not worth the moola. read more

See all

Best place hands down for sandwiches in Mount Olive. Real cold cuts sliced as you wait. Really good cheese steak and sloppy joes. Stop wasting your taste buds at those chains and get a real sandwich here. read more

Kim Convience meets a sandwich shop in NJ. Owned by a lovely korean coulple. Very simply a place to go to get a quick bite for breakfast or lunch. Plenty of fillings in their sandwich which makes it filling. I am not a fan of sandwiches but the amount they fill their sandwich is worth it. Couple of things they could to kick this place higher like switching to a less dense bread and I would even encourage putting a korean fusion sandwich on there. Given the times we live in where fusion is all the rage. My spot for a quick bite when I am in the area. read more

looking for sandwiches for a good value? Italian sub is the best. Tasty and lots of meat! This is our go-to deli for subs.

Got the turkey club and it was fantastic. Definitely will be coming back to try their other sandwiches. John is very friendly too!

Been meaning to stop by here for years but just never got the chance. And I regret not ever stopping by before! The food is absolutely amazing and the couple who own the shop are so nice! They have great portion sizes. My one mistake that hopefully people will see this and not make is that they only take cash! So remember to have enough when you go since it's such a hard spot to get out of! Will definitely go back for more when I'm in the area again! read more

Great little sandwich shop. Carryout is the main focus of business. Cute owners. Lots of meat on the sandwich. Definitely will return.

Your Greeted with a Warm Smile and a Hello and given what is One Incredible Sandwich! Huge Double Portion Size! This was my first time at this place and WOW what a Sandwich! I got the Triple Decker Pastrami and Corned Beef Sloppy Joe. A Sandwich that is Famous across NJ but seen on few menus. It came standard cold (Next time will ask for hot) with Russian and Coleslaw. The Boards Head meats were Phenomenal and stood out in their quality. Its really a Great Spot Run by Some honest Hard-Working Folks! Will be back for sure anytime im in the area. read more

B J Sandwich Shop - Pastrami and Corned Beef Sloppy Joe - Delis Near Me - Budd Lake, New Jersey

See all

Great little deli, easy to miss. Lovely couple running this old-fashioned joint! Cash-only, so be prepared, but you'll get a big 'old sandwich for your money! Called ahead for a group of 8 guys, and all of our orders were spot-on and excellent. read more

B J Sandwich Shop - Menu - Delis Near Me - Budd Lake, New Jersey

My first time won't be my last. The owner was extremely pleasant. And my sandwich, the Super Italian Sub was delicious. The prices were reasonable, too. Warning: cash only. read more

almost 2 years after my revised post and I have to say that the sandwich shop still holds up! The owners are fantastic and super sweet and the sandwiches are delicious. you can't go wrong coming here. And there's something about the feel of the location right across from the lake that's just awesome. They are no longer retiring anytime soon so stop in and get some breakfast lunch or an early dinner! And if you have any interest in buying this location please show up with cash and leave it as is! read more

B J Sandwich Shop - Turkey, Ham and Swiss. Slammed! - Delis Near Me - Budd Lake, New Jersey

I visited today for the first time, after driving by for too many years to count. We got an Italian sub, chicken cheese steak and tuna sandwich. Everything was great. I will be returning. read more

B J Sandwich Shop - Italian sub - Delis Near Me - Budd Lake, New Jersey

This place i gotta say, love them turkey sandwiches. flavor is amazing, even the craftsmanship of the sandwich is amazing. great effort, and they both are very kind. Personally i think they have the best sandwiches in town. read more

I don't really like the owners, always rude to me and If you show up a few minutes passed 11AM for a breakfast sandwich they look at you like you have 3 heads. Still the quality of the sandwiches have always been solid. They make a better Taylor ham egg and cheese than anybody on 46 around here. Italian sub is my go to for lunch. read more

Was out looking for a car near there and popped in. Not only was I met with a very nice owner who was so gracious but great food! I literally went off the reviews when I was looking for a place to grab a bite to eat fast. I ordered a spicy bacon egg and cheese sandwich and it was delicious! Will definitely be back OH, AND THEY HAVE TATOR TOTS!! YEAH BABY!! read more

Amazing, I passed this little place for 17 years not knowing if it was open. I went there today. Delicious sandwiches, top grade Cold Cuts Like Boar's Head.... generous portions. They've got a location that's good and bad .... they're right on Budd Lake offering a great view of the lake .... the bed thing..... if you're traveling west on Route 46..... is that you might drive right by them, for years, like I did. They close at 3 p.m. At noon time.... lunch time... the local workers trucks Pull in ... they found this gem where the good food is a long time ago and where to get a good hero. Stop by. You'll be pleasantly surprised read more

See all

Literally the best sandwiches locally!! Love everything I've gotten from them. My favorites are the Taylor ham, egg and cheese and a hot pastrami sandwich. Amazing! read more

Great subs for its prices all around simple and great. Run by a mom and pop. They definitely fill up the subs, favorite place to run by and grab a quick sandwhich read more

Service is so great here! They are so friendly. The food is also awesome and you can tell they know what they are doing. Always delicious.

This is a great little sandwich shop located right across tt 46 from Budd lake. The best taylor ham egg and cheese in the world. They only use boars head deli meats and the couple that runs the place are always happy to see you. Great quality, friendly service, good value. I love this place. I try to stop in every time I am in town. read more

Stopped here for a sandwich and some chips before visiting a local brewery. Got the Italian and it was great. Bread was very fresh. Staff behind the counter was super nice! read more

The Owners are super friendly. We love the sandwiches here. Breakfast and lunch are always outstanding. The food is delicious and made with care. Nothing beats fresh sliced deli meat to order! My go to is Turkey, Bacon, Swiss sandwich. CASH ONLY Establishment. read more

This is a lovely quiet little place right by Budd lake. I've had their sandwich for a long time now and never have once did it fail me! Sloppy Joe is top notch (i live in manhattan and haven't had a better sandwich) and italian sub is my absolute favorite. If you are looking for a quiet relaxing afternoon on weekends (or weekdays) with a good sandwich in your hands (if it fits in your hands) by the lake, this little deli is a must try! read more

See all

Outstanding sandwiches,I had the #5 sloppy Joe, corn beef and pastrami. I couldn't only eat half. Best that i can remember read more

B J Sandwich Shop - Delis Near Me - Budd Lake, New Jersey

FYI- CASH ONLY! Absolutely loved this place!! Delicious food and fast, friendly service. I would have bought 2 sandwiches but i only had enough cash for one!! But, it was wonderful and i will definately be back. read more

This is my favorite sub shop in the area. Great prices , awesome subs and friendly service, all with a view of the lake ! However their hours are limited That's why I'm not giving them 5 stars read more

Friendly owners...great food, especially the hot turkey w/ gravy and cheese Expensive...especially for the size of the subs read more

This is a very unassuming sub shop that has very tasty sandwiches. I got a ham and provolone sub and it was exactly what I needed. The owners were very cheery and made a quick lunch. Highly recommend for simple and filling food. read more

Extremely friendly owner! The hot turkey, gravy, and American cheese sub i recently got was awesome!

Best tuna, hands done! They use top quality ingredients and their sub rolls are delicious!!!

I live in a town outside of Atlantic City called Galloway. There is a deli there called Pitney Italian Market. To say the least, I'm spoiled. Homemade everything and made fresh almost everyday because if you come in too late, you're liable to not get what you want. You can get a variety of subs (about 30% larger than BJ's) with a soda for $4.50. At BJ's, my sausage was prepared in a microwave and I payed $9.25 for a sub and soda. I'm giving BJ's a rating of three stars because despite it not being as fresh as I'm used to the sandwich was good. The sausage had good flavor and the sauce was savory and sweet. Also the owner was very friendly and enthusiastic about serving me. I will say, I feel sorry for the people of Budd Lake if BJ's is their standard for a quality deli. A spot like this should be sitting at three stars at best. If any of you are ever visiting Atlantic City, take 20 min and head to Galloway and visit Pitney Italian Market, you won't be sorry. read more

I really like this place. You feel welcome when ordering and they have great sandwiches at decent prices. They are always very kind and appreciate your patronage. The sandwiches are always made to order and huge. I'd be giving them 5 stars - but the place is a bit grimy and dirty. I'm sure all food is prepared in a sanitary manner - but the place seriously needs a good scrubbing. read more

Their Italian sub is absolutely delicious! Nice portion size--they are so generous with their fresh ingredients. Definitely the best in the neighborhood. I just had one today and I'm craving another one already! read more

B J Sandwich Shop - Italian sub - Delis Near Me - Budd Lake, New Jersey

See all

Best sandwich shop in the area. The owner is super nice. We order sandwiches about every other weekend. Nice portions.