Excellent, would come again, and tell others!! We had the yellow cake with pink and white frosting - Yummy!

Cute shop with a small specialty selection. Service was not very welcoming which might have changed the experience--could use some warmth and more than one word answers for those interested in learning more about the shop and products. The caramel peanut butter cupcakes had a good flavor, not too sweet and not a combination I have seen before. Slightly on the dry side. Chocolate cake pop was perfectly moist and rich. Good stop for the prices and flavors, not the ambiance that would draw me back for more though. read more

Baby Cakes - Tiramisu Cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Willoughby, Ohio

See all

We wanted two cakes - a very special birthday cake and smash cake - for our grandson's first birthday party. Baby Cakes did not disappoint! Not only were these cakes absolutely adorable, they were also delicious. Thank you, Baby Cakes, for making this day perfect! read more

Baby Cakes - a mickey mouse themed cake - Bakeries Near Me - Willoughby, Ohio

See all

This place is super cute, staffed well and always friendly. Their cakes taste great and they have a bazillion flavors you can order from but I will never understand why they use basic whipped cream frosting - it really takes away from the taste and presentation of their cakes/cupcakes. When we ordered ahead we always ask for buttercream (which is an up charge of 0.50 or $1 depending on cupcakes - and PER cupcake) but honestly without the tastier icing I would not look forward to the cupcake without it. The baby shower we had there for my work peeps was great - remember ordered ahead for the buttercream - but only one flavor had been given the requested icing...the other was whipped cream - that one we had a bunch of left overs on - the blue champagne ZERO leftovers...icing speaks volumes! for me the taste of a cake of cup is all about the icing - it starts and finishes your taste experience. read more

Baby Cakes - Cupcake display - blue champagne (perfection) and bananas foster (cake great, icing whipped ) - Bakeries Near Me - Willoughby, Ohio

The three star rating is quite fair as service is very sweet and warm, and cupcakes are okay/good. Having gone to a few famed cupcake establishments at the prime of the great cupcake craze, if i must be honest, I'll have to say that baby cake's selection today was rather limited and uninspired. Where were the pretty little cupcakes pictured in previous yelp posts? Where's the whimsy? I picked out a red velvet today which was moist and good, not bad, but not all that special in cake or icing. For two dollars a pop, the icing could have used a bit more effort in piping. Looking forward to give them another try if other reviews show that this was just a weird day. read more

Baby Cakes - It was like this when I got it.. I'm sure they wouldn't let this happen for a catered occasion. - Bakeries Near Me - Willoughby, Ohio

Not sure about the previous reviews, but each to his/her own. Today, being Valentine's Day, I wanted to get my wife a small flavorful gift is not the ordinary type gift. So since I was in and around the area of Downtown Willoughby, Baby Cakes came immediately to mind. As I parked, I saw a few people already walking out with boxes of cupcakes! (They opened at 11 and I was there at 11:30!) I'm wondering, "Late again John?" Well, fortunately I was not. I exactly what I had in mind. Red Velvet Cupcakes, my wife's "to die for" treat. AND a deep chocolate cupcake, w/chocolate icing, topped with a chocolate dipped strawberry! Was thinking about getting one for lunch, but thought better of it. Made my selections; had them perfectly boxed; and completed step one of this Valentine's Day journey! Looking for that unique bakery treat? Be sure to check out Baby Cakes! IMO you won't be disappointed! read more

This was the most horrible tasting cupcake I am here like what in the world the frosting tastes like Crisco Grease with sugar and the cupcake is self had like a gritty almost cornmeal taste .We bought two of the supposed gourmet flavors. It was a waste of five dollars... I'm not sure what these are made out of but they were awful!!l I make cupcakes and I was in a pinch and wanted to get something for my husband's birthday I left him with a really bad taste in his mouth never again Babycakes more like what's in the baby's diaper! read more

This place rocked my world and my wedding and my belly! I walked in, showed them what I wanted, had tons of delicious flavors to choose from, and had the most delicious wedding cake ever! All I had to do was sign a paper and everything was taken care of! They were courteous and professional! I came in twice because I completely forgot what flavors I chose, but really it was an excuse to eat more yummy cupcakes! My cake and sheet cake were both vegan and my guests had no idea because it was so delicious! Everyone was ranting and raving about the yummy cake at my wedding! Thank you guys so so much! read more

Baby Cakes - a three tiered cake with the word mr and mrs on top - Bakeries Near Me - Willoughby, Ohio

See all

Delicious cupcakes. Ordered strawberry champagne cupcakes a few days ahead. They were waiting for me when I arrived. The cupcakes were so wonderful, they were the highlight of the evening. Thank you for such wonderful treats.. read more

Recently I spent $45 on a dozen and half cupcakes. Yikes, for not much more than a little cake and some frosting on it, nothing special. Six of them were supposed to be lemon raspberry, but tasted like just yellow cake. They were hard as rock by the next day. I can do better with a box mix. Six of them were gluten free and very dry--they used to be better. read more

Babycakes has thee best cupcakes with a wide variety to choose from. My favorite is the chocolate cover pretzel cupcake. Prices range from $1.95 and up. read more

I showed them the cake I wanted and also sent it through email and was told it Can be done. They made a completely different cake. Also my cake should have been vanilla frosting with a creme cheese filling, my cake wasnt even 2 layers so there was NO creme cheese filling, also the cake was for a 6 year old birthday party the top of the cake WAS NOT EDIBLE and they did not tell me anything about it. The entire picture that covered the cake you had to peel it off I had little kids & ederly people CHOKING from trying to eat the cake! This was a waste of $50 , disappointed wasn't even the word for how I felt and I wouldn't recommend not a damn person. I could of went to giant eagle got the same size cake $20 with the exact picture I wanted. Not to mention my cake from baby cakes Willoughby tasted store bought and not home made read more

So where do I start, three years ago when I graduated from Highschool I had a big graduation party. I remember I really wanted a big three tiered cake, because I just love cake ! So my friends and I went around to different places and tried their cupcakes to see which one would taste the best for the right pricing. So we picked this place. What a God awful mistake that was. I said I wanted edible bones and edible pictures of x-rays on the cake since I was going to school for radiography. It was a total mess, one of the most disappointing experiences of my life. We paid over 150$ to have literally pieces of paper that were printed off the computer be put onto my cake ! And the fondant bones looked like a third grader molded them. It was absolutely heart breaking. Especially considering how well the girl made it seem like she understood. I have voices my complaints and told them exactly what this cake came out to be and they never even said sorry. I like supporting local businesses but this place is a sham. Worst experience ever. Don't go here unless you want to be super disappointed. I wish I had a picture to show you how awful it was. read more

The store is very cute but the customer service is lacking. First- I was horrified that the girl put our selected cupcakes into the box without gloves!!!! I also thought it was strange that her long hair was not secured or pulled back. Second- this girl was unfriendly and inattentive. Although the cupcakes are decently priced ($2.00 to $2.50) there was no deal for purchasing a dozen, which I thought was strange. The variety of cupcakes was lacking so preordering is probably the best option. The cupcakes tasted okay, some of them were dried out, and other flavors were better than others. Not worth the price in our opinion. read more