My fiancée any I ate there last night for the first time. We were really hungry for pizza and I…read morelooked online for something local and handmade. Boy did we choose right! I honestly can say it was the best pizza I have ever had. I got the Billy Jean and added more toppings, which at no additional cost for extra toppings, I was surprised I could do that. That pizza has ricotta cheese on it and it took it to a whole new level. I actually couldn't wait to get up and have an extra slice I brought home for breakfast! The chef came out to ask us how we liked it. you can tell he truly cares about his craft and is an actual artist with his creations. Our service was outstanding as well. They truly care about making your dining out experience enjoyable. I like the vibe. We felt like we were in a beach town enjoying an evening out at a local favorite spot. They even gave us a drink to go! We have now found our favorite pizza place and we will be back!

We really enjoyed our first time at dŌ, the pizza was perfectly cooked, the style is a…read morethinner/crispier crust, and the sauce has plenty of flavor. I highly recommend this pizza. The service was also outstanding and everyone was so nice here.

Absolutely the BEST Calzone I've ever had! Seriously!! Asked for a pretty specific order, and it…read morewas just Perfect!! I'm a regular of at least once a month, and it's always,always excellent!

Anyone know what's going on with Pizza Marsala in Irwin? There food used to be really good. Last…read morethree times we ordered pizza, it was burnt, hard and hardly any cheese. Two of the pizzas were red sauce one a white pizza. I find them a little pricey but it used to be worth it, no more. I don't know if they have new people cooking or what. We will be taking a break from them for awhile!

Mama Pepino's will be one of my new go-to spots for pizza. I can't believe it's taken me this long…read moreto give them a try. The pizza was good and even better reheated in the toaster oven. My kids don't normally eat pizza but they ate this one. The service was also great. I didn't have to wait long and the price was way more reasonably priced than some of the other local spots. I paid $13.50 for a large one topping pizza. That's what I pay for a small at Lucianos.

The food is excellent I highly recommend it good service, good people all around good place.read more

We love Order! Seems like most of business is takeout, but we enjoy the cozy atmosphere and BYO…read more It's our go to with friends because the food is fantastic and the prices are reasonable. Their crispy pepperoni pizza with honey chipotle glaze is perfection and I love their almond blue cheese salad. Dressings made in-house. Tanya has been pulling double duty as front of house and serving and is always warm and welcoming. Try it, you won't be sorry.

We order pizza all the time. So much to like. White pizza, pepperoni with chipotle honey, veggie…read morepizza. Hubby always enjoys the veggie wrap!! Friendly people too! Their eat in menu is different than take out so check the website! Don't forget the yummy buffalo cauliflower bites!!!

Stopped in for dinner around 4:30. Nice and quiet on a Thursday. We tried the appetizer pepperoni…read morerolls dipped in sauce and stuffed banana peppers. Both amazing. My son got the pepperoni pizza with extra cheese- great as usual! I got the Italian beef sandwich mini- it is a pretty big sandwich on a hoagie bun toasted perfectly with melty cheese and juicy Italian beef. My husband tried the steak sandwich mini-also served on that perfectly toasted cheesy roll. He said the meat was soft and tasted great. Our waitress was so sweet and happy to help. We will be back to try something else for sure.

Truly didn't disappoint. This was Baked on a whole love of italian bread, Plenty of meat in…read moredressing. Definitely worth the price!!!

Stopped in to the newest pizza joint in town to try a slice. The had a nice variety of slices in…read morethe case. We were waited on quickly and had our hot pizza in minutes. I tried the pizza with ricotta, meatballs and basil with traditional red sauce and my daughter tried the chicken bacon ranch. Both slices were great. Can't wait to try some of the other pies. They do have some seating in your like to dine in and there were a few people enjoying lunch inside.

They have been closed since before Christmas 2025 and rumors have been circulating that it could be…read morepermanent.

I have wanted to try their pizza for a long time and last night was the night…read more Wow, did they not disappoint, I only wish I lived closer to make this a regular stop. The food, atmosphere and staff were great. Do not compare this to your local pizza shop that's perfectly round and got even toppings. This had to be one of the best pizza experiences since I toured Italy & Sicily. Go hungry and you will still leave with leftovers

Wow! Simply some of the best pizza in the area. I love me some pizza, if we lived closer this would…read morebe the weekly answer of what's for dinner. First we ordered the garlic knots. So much to say. Actually should be called garlic loaves. They are delicious, with no shortage of garlic, butter and parm. Delicious. Second the pizza was better than it looks and it looked delicious. The pizza is not shrinking like most places and they believe in toppings. We got: 1. EBUT large 2. Spinach and Tomato large 3. BBQ Chicken large 4. Pepperoni large We could have feed 18 people. Honestly some of the best pizza I have ever had. I will be making the trip to try more on the menu. If you live near Shelly Pie GO! Heck if you are passing by and need dinner or lunch GO! Actually if you have to go out of the way GO!