Had great pizza and mussels today at Domenico's, friendly staff and great service! Would definitely…read morereturn when I am back in the area :)

This is the type of place locals appreciate better. If you're passing thru, expect to pay higher…read morethan normal prices for mediocre food. How mediocre? The bread was the best thing about it. The worst thing? 2 Italian hot dogs, 1 cheesesteak and 3 sodas cost us $46.50. Out of town buyer, beware.

Good pizza. We got a mushroom & garlic pie. Quick Nice & friendly staff. Always a nice place.read more

A basic cheeseburger with lettuce tomato onion was to complicated. Food sat in the wind ready for…read more15 minutes. I was the only customer. The 87 year old guy was busy trying to fix a beer fridge. Food was cold dry cat food. The place is run down and dirty. Tables were sticky and smelled of piss.

Went for Father's Day. Met our daughter there. The girl who made our salad did a beautiful job. It…read morewas a piece of art! Whoever made our pizza (1/2 white and 1/2 meat lovers) did a superb job.

Very nice environment and atmosphere. The pizza was undesirable. The cheese did not taste like…read moremozzarella cheese. Not much tomato sauce. Very doughy pizza. I'll try something else on the menu next time.

Best pizza in the Poconos!!! The only downfall is that you need to find them at a festival, they do…read morenot have a shop.

From the owner: We are your pizza experts from Brooklyn, NYC – America’s best pizza city. With dough made from…read morescratch and premium ingredients, we serve you an arrangement of Unique hand crafted wood-fired pizzas like you’ve never had before! Enjoy

Pizza is just OK, nothing special. Cheaper, greasy cheese, not enough sauce. Crust needed a…read morelittle bit of a crunch. First time here, so maybe it wasn't their best day. Might try another place before coming back. Plenty of street parking. Place looked clean. Four tables inside and a few outside on the porch area.

Used to visit them at their original location in Hackettstown until they closed due to rent…read moreincrease. Heard about the new location and yeah found him. Got myself a favorite pizza spot again. Had a fresh pie made. Great crust thin, like a cross between NY style and cracker wafer thin, no flop, airy firm. The sauce is just as it was, not as acidic like others in the area which is what we like. Quality cheese. Price is better than others in the Hackettstown, Washington area too. Our old go-to is back closer again!

I will say I called and ordered for a pickup. Their timing was correct, the customer service was…read morecordial, and now onto the pizza. I ordered a plain cheese pizza. I paid cash which it is a bit cheaper. But the pizza was alright. I felt like I ordered from Dominoes and got a plain pizza. The difference was the stone stove taste. Which in my opinion they probably need to clean it. Because the pizza was burnt on the bottom. It could had been a one off night. We shall see. I'll try it again someday.

Hands down best pizza in the Poconos. Employees are on point. Typical comfortable feel at home type…read moreof pizza place I would go to as a kid in NY.

We have been frequenting Moonlight for years. Lived out here for 5, been coming that long, or…read morelonger as a visitor. As a NY'er- I have been around pizza. This is not your typical NYC thin stuff, it is rustic, and more akin to the old school stuff you get in Dyker Heights, but has that nice herb sauce you find more commonly in Queens. The crust, sourdough, is amongst the best I have ever had- the black char bubbles are a highlight. If you want wimpy and flavourless crust- go to one of the yokel spots- not even run by Italians - disgusting. The cheese to sauce ratio is perfect, and if you add toppings, they are well thought out. We have had most of the offerings, and I would place the Cheese & Greens varietals on top of my list. These pizzas command respect, and I also commend them for the way in which the business is run- it's quirky, and permits them a home-life. Support them during the slower Wednesday/Thursday. Deal with the phone calls! Get a salad- you won't be disappointed- they are always interesting and freshly made. Mrs Moonlight is in charge of those. I have never eaten in, but it is cozy appearing. Too much whinging about silly things on this website. 'Waaaaaa- I couldn't use social media to do something.' Come off of it. I would not change a thing with Moonlight- you guys are doing this incredibly well. Saluti from a longtime Loyal!

This placebhas the best pizza up here hands down. You have to get in early to get an appointment to…read moreget a pizza that day and spots fill up fast. It is a quiet small place, but they are a little slow. It is worth the wait though!

We were away on a trip and ordered from Guiseppe's. The food was delivered in a timely fashion. The…read morefood was delicious and enjoyed by all. We got a pizza, wings, and salad. I recommend trying them out if you're in the area

We were staying in the area for the weekend and did a take out order. The appearance of the place…read morewas lacking, gloomy and dark. We got a plain pizza which was decent. The wings of the other hand were very dry. The calamari tasted like onion rings, barely any flavor. My daughter enjoyed her fries, but those are hard to mess up. Soda was $6 for a 2L. We do not recommend this pizzeria, perhaps we are used to better quality in NY, I don't know. This place was not it.

Walking around the main street in Stroudsburg, we stopped in to this pizzeria for something quick…read morefor dinner. I ordered two slices, the pepperoni and the grandma. They were heated up quickly and brought out to us. I really liked the grandma slice - the sauce was great and it tasted fresh, and I liked the thicker Sicilian style crust. The pepperoni was alright, the cheese congealed a bit and it was a bit too oily than other slice.

The best Pizza in the Pocono's! Me and my dad been here multiple times because the food is that…read moregood, the service is wonderful as well, and it's one of the few places where they actually give you a pizza 'buy 10, get 1 free' coupon that you can through with repeat visits. Definitely a must visit if in the area just for the food and wonderful staff! PS. My favorite is a large meat lover's pie they make which is bigger than my countertop : )

This is a fukn disgrace..this is supposed to be a calzone..a calzone is 1 large pie dough folded in…read morehalf..not this fukn hot pocket i got..stay away..this and a large pie 40 buks..fuk this place..

Ordered from the slice app and picked the wrong location. That was my fault but oh well. Drove the…read moreextra 10 mins to pick up my order. Truly inedible. I don't know how but the wings we ordered were mushy. Like the meat was actual mush. Garlic knots are basically dinner rolls. Pizza was the best part of our order and that is not a compliment. The guys the work there are truly so sweet so I feel bad writing a bad review, but I just can't imagine ever going in there again. Beware.