Usually an excellent place for a pie, but mostly on Saturdays. Getting a pie like I did on a Friday. The pie was full of heavy bubbles, misshapen, and uneven and burnt crust. read more

very "unique" pizza. it's very good, but it is more traditional and has different sauce to cheese ratio. Love this place, but definitely would not bring it to a party. It's a nice, different, experience. their menu is relatively large, and all the options are solid. i've been here around 2 or 3 times and tried lots of there menu items. the atmosphere is cozy but a little dark. took maybe 10 minutes for my pizza to come out. read more

Got delivery once and pick up once and both times the tomato pizza was DELICIOSA! Being a vegan it was everything I hoped for. Better than the vegan pizza some places offer!ñ nearby! It was fresh and the dough was on point! For our delivery order the non vegans loved what they got too (Cheesesteak and cheese pizza). 5/5 hands down read more

Martellucci's Pizza - Vegan tomato pie - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

We have been going to Martellucci's for over 25 years. Their pizza in one of three best in the area, especially the Thin Crust Sicilian. The sauce is fresh and perfectly blended (not like many Italian restaurants that depend on sobbing their sauce with garlic so people think the food is good???). We would highly recommend Martellucci's for their Pizza and Italian dishes. The ambiance is very casual, not a place for fancy dinner. The service is very good and prices are reasonable. read more

Good pizza my kid likes it a couple times a month. Nice little place, the pizza is good

This is a family favorite. We have been going here for so many years. My siblings would have pizza here after baseball and softball games in the summer. The pizza is magnificent. It's unique. The crust is unmatched the sauce is so flavorful j love this pizza joint it's the best in town. read more

Martellucci's Pizza - Pretty decor - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

See all

As always food at Martellucci's was good. The delivery is what I had issue. The food was past estimate times. No show I ordered from another restaurant as I was walking out found my food at door no text of delivery . Food was cold I was lucky that the did not start order This the second time I have used Yelp or grubhub whatever it is. Some convenience I may not use the service but will continue to patronize Martellucci's read more

Our place to go when looking for square pizza,we love their thin cut square Sicilian pizza, friendly staff, and reasonably priced.

Thin crust Sicilian with fresh tomato and cheese is THE BEST. Salads are fresh and garlic knots are on point. Our favorite pizza place in the valley! read more

I will never order from Martelucci's again if they are going to sell a large pizza that is this small. This is like 12"-13" in diameter and a large pizza is typically at least 16" in diameter. Tastes good but if it can't feed my small family what is the point. Normally we have 2-3 slices left and today there's nothing left because my two year old was able to eat more than two slices since they're so tiny. read more

Martellucci's Pizza - Extremely small "large" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

Solid pizza, sandwiches and apps. Their pies with crushed tomatoes are a nice change of pace. Wish it was slightly cheaper or they had specials because then I could afford to eat there more often! read more

The pizza is just not the same. The thin crust isn't thin and the pizzas are soggy not anywhere near crispy. Loaded with toooo much cheese. No longer an Italian place. We miss the real Marteluccis read more

How disappointing! First off I ordered on door dash, and the pizzeria did not acknowledge the order for 40 minutes, and until after the driver arrived. Then the driver had to wait for the whole cooking time. It arrived piping hot thanks to the driver. The most institutional flavorless pizza followed. One step away from a cracker crust. Like it came from a stadium or school cafeteria. This is the 7th pizzeria I've tried since moving to Bethlehem. And no matter how many more I try, I'm certain this will remain at the bottom of the list! read more

One of my favorite casual places to eat in Bethlehem--great food and service and prices are excellent!

The best pizza in the City of Bethlehem! The pizza is perfectly consistent each and every time. Cheese blend is superior to other shops. The crust is thin, and executed well in the oven. Pizza is often pizza. This shop is a destination pizza. Family owned and operated. In a world where pizza is at your door in 30 minutes or less, I drive 30 minutes one way to get this pizza for take out. read more

See all

Local pizza shop with killer pizza. We've had their pizza and wings both of which are some of the best in this area. Inside is very casual and kid friendly. read more

One of the best pizza shops in the valley. Don't miss out on the thin crust Sicilian. Absolutely delicious.

I'm not a regular here as I've only had two experiences with their food, but each was sort of noteworthy so here goes. The first time, friends of ours who swear by this place insisted that we order take out from here as they do at least once a week and overall I could see why. We got various sandwiches along with a pepperoni & onion pizza and overall everything was really great. It was a weeknight and the person who made the call was told 30-35 minutes but in reality everything wasn't ready until closer to 45-50 minutes which he said is actually par for the course here. The next time maybe a month later on a Friday night I made the call and was told 45 minutes except this time the food took closer to an hour until it was ready. It's also worth noting that if you come here to pick food up and if it's not ready there really is no good place to hang out as you're right by the register/pizza making area, it's hot as hell along with being a very high traffic area. Again the food was perfectly fine but the wait was ridiculous as the time given bore no resemblance to the actual time it took for the food to be ready. I mean for me, we live on the other side of town from this place and there are a literal ton of similar places between here and there all peddling the exact same stuff. Would I go out of my way for their stuff? Maybe if they delivered but since they don't I can't see myself ordering from here often as while the food is good it's a heck of a wait until it's ready. read more

I have ordered three times now, their food is good. My problem is, they can't follow simple instructions. All three times, I asked for the sauce on the side, all three times it was put on the sandwich. . read more

Pizza has stayed consistent since the ownership transfer. Still a big fan of this place and will continue to support them through the transition. I had 1-2 issues picking up orders but they've always been very friendly about it and made it right without my asking for anything. read more

I want the old owner back right now. Pepperoni is not under the cheese. Way too flabby. Way too greasy. They never used minced garlic but now they do, seems cheap. Barely any crust read more

Just had a first and last experience..wanted to try them for the first time. After trying to call 8 times...no one answered. One rang so long the call disconnected. I really wanted to give them a try. So we tried one more time an hour later..only to be spoken to rudely..and dropped presumably on the counter top after being asked to hold a minute. Meanwhile I hear this women being just as rude to customers picking up orders and paying. Complaining about all the things she still had to do. More rudeness to customers and I think fellow employees as well. Arguing with a customer who asked for specific instructions on a pick up... Yes foolishly I waited this long because I really wanted to try their menu items. What's next...well..they rudely hung up the phone on me! Meanwhile..it was also a 10 minute opportunity to not answer any more order calls. Steer clear...if you really want to give them the benefit of the doubt.. and they don't answer the phone when you call..hang up and move on. Not kidding..these people clearly do not want or need the business. read more

Martellucci's is a small, clean, friendly neighborhood pizza place. With that said, I am from outside the area and was looking for a place to get pizza before heading to the Liberty HS stadium. Pizza was very good, service was fast and friendly, and price was right. Forget the Dominoes and Pizza Hut around the corner if you want better pizza, service and price. read more

" Best Italian pizza" in the state! Homemade taste , everything fresh and just "delicious"! Enjoy and take one home to enjoy tomorrow ! Amare!!! read more

Had the pizza and cheesesteak both were excellent. The entire office liked the pizza, its different but the SAUCE is great.

To preface, I really wanted to like the Sicilian pizza at Martellucci Pizza, especially given all the 5 star reviews. I'm new to the Lehigh Valley, and haven't yet found a decent pizza. Unfortunately Martellucci's is not an exception. My review is limited to the thin crust Sicilian pizza, which I tried on 3 separate occasions (2 take-out; 1 eat-in). Reviewers say: "Delicious pizza!", "... real star ...", "... perfect." , " ... just awesome." , " ... magical." I say: You must be joking. Try this little test: can you hold the pizza slice horizontal by its crust? Absolutely not. It flops down and tears like damp cardboard, and the meager toppings tumble right off. There is no real flavor to either the crust or ingredients. And how insulting that they used frozen vegetables as topping on a vegetarian pizza. This contributes, I believe, to the dampness, glueyness of the crust. The pizza chef seems like a nice enough guy, but clearly he doesn't know good pizza either since he continues to make a really sub-par pizza. 3 strikes -- you're out. I shall never return here. Reviewers, should some of you ever try pizza in practically any average pizza parlor in New York City (or many other cities), you've got a real treat coming. Until then, my sympathies that Martellucci Pizza earns your 5 star reviews. read more

From reading the reviews I was excited to eat here and knew that on a Friday night we should call and make reservations. So we called and were told that they had a table available right away. We told them we'd be there in 15 minutes and when we arrived (in 14 minutes) the place was packed, there were already 2 parties waiting for tables and they didn't save us a table. We mentioned we had reservations and they didn't bother to apologize or acknowledge us in any way and from the way the staff barked at each other it was obvious that we were going to wait for who knows how long. After waiting for another 10 minutes we left. No loss. I would give zero stars if possible. The parking lot is TINY and hard to access. The atmosphere is cozy, the seating areas are extremely cramped. There is one small bathroom, the entrance is crowded by seated customers. read more

The pizza here is just the best in the Lehigh Valley!! The meat lovers Stromboli is second to none!! Cheesesteaks & mozzarella sticks are great!! We have been loyal customers for nearly 20 years & they don't disappoint!! read more

This is the place for one of the best pizzas in Bethlehem - or even the whole Lehigh Valley. Love the owners and wait staff. On Friday-Saturday nights of high school football season, avoid this place (unless you're in high school, then it's the place to be.) The thin crust Sicilian is perfect. I don't know how to describe it but the crust has a taste and texture that's different from the other pizzerias in the area. If you feel a cold coming on, you must have the chicken and rice soup that is homemade by mama in the kitchen, it's the best. Nothing fancy, just GREAT food. p.s. - eat your pizza in the restaurant if you can. the pizza (especially the thin crust) doesn't always travel well and can get soggy in its box on the way home. read more

There are two points that I feel work very well in this venue's favor. The first, and biggest, is the pizza. This is quite possibly some of the best pizza I have ever had. It's very full of flavor and just the right size. The second point in their favor that I experienced was the atmosphere. While it feels very much like it hasn't been updated since the 1970's, it's very cozy. It definitely feels like a good family spot. The one downside, however, was the service.It felt like it was a bit on the slow side. It wasn't bad enough to really matter, though. Any complaint I can have is completely negated by the fact that their pizza is the cat's pajamas read more

Nice local joint. My husband and I popped in here for our first night in our new neighborhood after our whole block lost power. The waitress was super friendly and made us feel right at home. We both got cheesesteak hoagies. Not the best I've ever had, but definitely tasty. Our fries where nice and fresh - the perfect combo of crunchy and mushy. It is a casual restaurant for eat in or take out only. They take reservations which are highly recommended by the waitstaff on Fridays. A good find! UPDATE: We have ordered Pizza from here several times and it's just awesome. My parents request it any time they come over. They also make their own sodas which have all been yummy. People that work here are lovely. Just a great place. read more

As a 35+ year resident of Bethlehem, I have been eating Martellucci's since I was ten years old. I can say that there is not a pizza in the area that is like those served at Martellucci's. The unique crust is soft and chewy, but crispy on the outside, creating a highly desirable contrast, and the pies are as consistent as you will find in the Valley. They also happen to boast one the best value deals in the area. 2 Large Pies and 25 wings for $32.50. Perfect for that Friday/Saturday takeout for the fam! read more

There is nothing good about this pizza. There isn't a whole that's bad about it, either. It's all around pretty bland and not worth eating twice. Putting the pepperoni under the cheese is neat. That's my one plus. The sauce was boring. The crust was flimsy, a pizza needs a little crunch. The vegetable pizza was terrible. I'm not sure if any of the veggies on my pizza were cooked. The were hard, and once again, flavorless. How do you do that? Veggies have flavor. Tomato sauce has flavor. How can you make such a bland pizza? Look. I grew up in California. I know bad pizza. I grew up on bad pizza, but I will never go back to eat this pizza. Not because it was awful, but because what's the point? read more

Stopped here when we stayed in Bethlehem overnight. Food was great, service was great, and the staff had excellent customer service! Definitely 5 stars, highly recommend!! read more

As part of an out of town trip, I was brought here for Italian food. Man, this place was good! Family owned and it shows in quality. Dinner entrees were great and my small stomboli was a full meal. Service was good and price was more than fair. Make sure you stop by like I did! read more

Delicious pizza!! My husband and I came here for lunch. We ordered a large cheese pizza. The pizza has a great crisp to the bottom and a nice spongy texture. I wouldn't call the crust chewy, it tastes fresh. The sauce isn't too sweet and the cheese has a nice blended flavor. The restaurant is small and busy for lunch. There is one server for the whole restaurant and she works her butt off. Great service! It is BYOB. read more

So, we don't eat takeout pizza at all - don't get me wrong, we love pizza, but our family has lactose issues. So, we decided since we're in the middle of a quarantine and stuck at home, we thought "what the hell." It has been YEARS since we ordered any take-out pizza. So, I posed a question to a local Facebook group: "If you could only eat one pizza a year, where would you get it?" There was some fierce competition between 3 locals places, but Martelucci's won out. IT DID NOT DISAPPOINT. AMAZING. I got the small Sicillian with garlic and green peppers, and he got a large pepperoni and mushroom. Both crusts were chewy and delicious. And I judge pizza by greasiness, and both pies were not greasy at all. We'll definitely order again (but it might be next year...). read more

Been back a few times now and recently tried the thin crust Sicilian pie. We had a simple version, just pepperoni. The darn thing disappeared in 10 minutes. Delicious! Also recently tried some pasta and was disappointed. Will try again but the pizza is so darn good, probably no reason to do anything else. First time in for pizza and was pleasantly surprised. Different than many. Crispy crust that is not thick and not too thin. Tangy sweet sauce, good with both the Hawaiian and pepperoni pizzas we ate. They offered us two liter bottle of soda, nice way to save a little money. read more

I cannot get enough of their pasta soup. It has various types of pasta in a light tomato-basil broth. With crackers and a salad, it makes the perfect lunch. read more

Best pizza ever west of Queens/Brooklyn. I could swear this place had to originate from NY it's so good, and even better than my ole stomping ground on the upper east side. Order the thin Sicilian, amazing!!! read more