I wasn't sure what to expect but was happily surprised with the authenticity of the food. The…read moresauce, bread and crust were made from scratch and so delicious! We ordered pizza and a variety of pastas with different sauces. It tasted just like the east coast, and we will definitely be back as regular customers.

I want to start off by saying that i do like some things at this restaurant and have always been…read moresatisfied with the product. Usually we just order fettuccine, but we have tried the pizza as well, but today i decided to be bold and try something different. And since it was a warm day I went for one of the sandwiches instead of a hot dish. Instantly regretted my decision. A rather underwhelming 6in roll sparsely filled with salami and something they are calling prosciutto, both thinly sliced, and tomato, shredded provolone cheese(wierd) and big chunks of iceberg lettuce. The menu says it comes with soup or salad, however I was charged an additional $3.00 for a half a cup of minestrone soup. In all honesty the best part about this meal were the extra rolls I ordered. I paid $62 for my wife and my meal after tax and tip. It's very disappointing to know I could have bought a sub sandwich and a can of minestrone soup from the Safeway and not only gotten the same meal, but i would have saved myself almost $10 as well.

10 out of 10 across the board. The staff was AMAZING!!! The food is the best food out of every…read morerestaurant I have tried in this area let alone the best Italian food in town. I had the lobster ravioli and it was heaven. I cannot wait to try everything!! The meatballs were just like grandma used to make. Now here is the only downside...this place is SMALL!! You HAVE to make reservations. Make sure you actually speak to someone to make the reservations!! I can't wait to go back!!!

This restaurant has exceptional food and service. THIS is the place to go if you want authentic…read moreand delicious "upscale" Italian food without leaving town. I could easily compare this to restaurants I've been to in Italy, and to finer Italian restaurants in Seattle. Don't let the location on the fringe of town deter you. This restaurant is a gem.

This was our second visit to Pellegrino's, and we really enjoyed it both times! It's a tiny little…read moretwo-story restaurant, and we've sat upstairs on both visits. The upstairs is small and intimate, which gives the whole place a cozy, unique feel. Our waiter this time was a young gentleman who was incredibly friendly and did a great job! Three of us ordered Coors Lights in bottles, and he brought them out ice cold with a chilled glass to pour them into. When we ordered a second round, he let us know he had just put some more in the freezer, so it would be a few minutes. That little extra step made a difference...we'd much rather wait a few minutes for an ice-cold beer than have it brought out warm! I ordered the spaghetti with their house-made Bolognese sauce and added a meatball, and WOW. The sauce had the perfect combination of slight sweetness, a little spice from the sausage, and that tangy tomato flavor. So good! And I'm usually not a huge fan of restaurant meatballs because they can be tough or rubbery, but this one was soft, juicy, and packed with flavor. Sean got the lasagna and absolutely loved it! Our friends who invited us out ordered the steak and spaghetti Bolognese, and everyone was happy with their meals. The steak was cooked exactly how it was requested, and the quality of the food for the price was really good. Overall, Pellegrino's is just a great little place. Warm, inviting atmosphere, friendly service, delicious food, and a fun, intimate setting that feels a little different from your typical Italian restaurant. Definitely worth checking out if you're looking for a place to enjoy a good meal with friends. We'll definitely be back!

We came in with a party of 11 for my niece's birthday and unfortunately had a very disappointing…read moreexperience from start to finish. Right away there was confusion at check-in--they called for a party of 9 with no name, and the host was rude when we responded using the first name instead of the last. After being seated, it took about 10 minutes just to get drinks, and then another 30 minutes before our server took our food order. During that time, we weren't asked about appetizers or offered any drink refills. About an hour later, the server came back and told us the kitchen was backed up and they were "just now making our food," which honestly felt like our order may have been forgotten. At that point, all of our drinks were empty and I had to ask for refills. While we were still waiting, another server came to the table asking how one of our steaks was cooked, which added to the confusion. Our food finally arrived after about an hour and a half. Unfortunately, the issues didn't stop there: My spaghetti and meatballs was incorrect, but I kept it since I didn't want to wait again with a toddler. My sister's husband's meal was never even put in--the server admitted this. My sister's fish and chips came out cold. No one checked back to see how the food was. Drinks were left empty again with no refills offered. We were never asked about dessert. Plates were never cleared, even after I stacked empties at the end of the table to help. Every time we needed something, we had to flag someone down. To make matters worse, the checks came out incorrect with items swapped between them. I've worked as a server/bartender for four years, and my niece is also a server, so we completely understand how busy and stressful things can get. But this experience missed the mark on multiple levels. Even when things go wrong, basic service--like keeping drinks filled and checking on guests--should still be happening. This was easily the worst restaurant experience I've had. It was especially disappointing because we're an easy group and typically tip very well. Unfortunately, we will not be returning.

I was going to go eat at the restaurant but had to cancel my reservation…read more I ordered a takeout instead and it was Delicious! I had the meat platter and the burata caprese. Awesome! Perfect meal for two, while watching a movie. I plan on dining in person in the not too distant future.

Had been looking forward to trying this restaurant as it seems to get decent reviews…read more Pickup order on a weekday, later PM. Terrible parking - had to circle a couple times for street parking. Place had maybe 8 total people so not busy. Went up to Server/Cashier near front to let her know I was there for pickup and was immediately told "The servers like it when you stand by the table" in a mildly pretentious tone. No "Hi" or "How can I help you?" This is downtown Olympia so typical establishment behavior. Not surprised. Place was clean and very nicely decorated.Took about 5 minutes to get my pizza which was surprisingly quick. The Pizza I generally like my pizzas crisp and this was not even close. Very soggy, and not much flavor (Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, olives). This was thin crust so that potentially had something to do with taste and texture. I would compare this Pizza to what you get at MOD. It's not too bad, but not too good. Average at best and I expected a lot better. Cost was about normal (14" pizza and bread appetizer for $50 plus tax). Marinara sauce for bread was delicious. All in all, it wasn't a terrible experience. It's by no means gourmet or fancy pizza. Perhaps the rest of their menu is better. Server needs to chill out and brush up on her customer service skills. 3 stars at best.

The food is amazing and the atmosphere is wonderful! The jazz band is wonderfully talented!read more

Probably the best RISOTTO that I've ever had. And I've ate that dish all over the world, even the…read moremicrowavable version. Olympia- what are you doing?!! Why aren't you here EVERY night?! Best. Risotto. Ever.

Well, walked by when visiting the Farmers Market a few days ago. Smelled wonderful ! We decided to…read morehave lunch today since my friend who just moved to the area had eaten the Salmon Salad before and stated how much she enjoyed it. Showed me a pic she'd snapped of the salad. Looked yummy! Dang!! I was hopeful...Had to wait a bit for the hostess, no biggy. Seated outdoors since it was a lovely day. Ordered a cocktail, asparagus appetizer and our meal. asked for bread, the salmon was definitely overdone, easy fix...asparagus sounded tasty, need some work with this one folks. Asked for bread when placing our order, had to get up to ask the server mid lunch for the forgotten bread. Service, nice young lady, teachable... sealed the 2 star rating when I had to go inside to the hostess stand to retrieve our check., Need to step up the game here. Has great potential, just not there yet.

Amazing service, consistent food quality, just a good meal for what you need…read more I don't know why more people don't come here, the food is spectacular. The service was great because the servers were attentive. The food came out hot when it was ready and the atmosphere was very mellow, not pushy.

I had the best dinner here last night! The server was so sweet, attentive, and helped us get our…read moreorder in before a large party so we wouldn't have too long of a wait. I got a delicious iced tea, a casa Mia salad with Italian vinaigrette, a meatball sandwich, and bread to start and it was AMAZING. Everything tasted flavorful, fresh, and the portions were perfect to satisfy without overeating. The inside is cute too- we sat in their makeshift patio inside and it was very fun. A lovely Olympia staple I try to visit when I'm here!

Had an all day meeting close by, so it was super convenient. They only had one waitress for lunch…read morebut she was good. Nice interior, very Italian. I had a chicken Caesar salad, it was so good. Lots of chicken so it was filling. The only issue was that the chicken was a little greasy.

Such a great find for the South end. Make reservations. It's a super small place. They have…read moretheir own parking which is nice in that area. Reasonably priced steaks which are cooked well. Also had the burrata but the standout were the potatoes. Those were delicious. Service was also outstanding. Highly recommend

Here's the deal. 40 years ago this restaurant may have been the place to be, but today.... It's a…read moreno for me dog. If you're gonna serve a steak, and charge $60 for it, it better be a damn good steak. Yes, if eaten more expensive steaks in 5 star restaurants, but common man. The seafood fettuccine was yummy, but that might be attributed to the mountain of Parmesan cheese. I made him shred on top of it. Our server brought the wrong drink, the sides were odd and the ambience was dated. On a good note, I'm not from this town so I won't be back.

When in for the first time during a lunch break. Ordered up…read morethe Philly cheesesteak, and a beer. Found out that they don't serve beer . It does say beer and wine on the window but the cashier said she been here for a few years and there is no beer , I also thought I was getting a combo but I don't think she heard me. . The sandwich was good. It needed something tho to give it the zing like other Phillies I enjoy, ...something that makes me talk about it for weeks to come like a couple other places I have eaten in. The sandwich had mozzarella cheese , peppers, onions and the regular stuff that makes it a sandwich. Service was good the brought it out to the table,they had the regular drinks and chips. The place friendly and abit busy for a lunch time rush. I may return. Hmmm I will have the Philly I do declare.

I had the meatball sub. It was amazing. This place has a stellar reputation with all the students…read moreat Saint Martin's for a good reason.

This place is a little gem! The food is so good and authentic and I have been here a few times for…read moremy birthday, which is in the fall, and it has been such a cozy experience that really has a special place in my birthday memories. I have also been in the summer, to their little open patio, that is magical with lights during summer nights. The ambiance is great, no matter the time of year. The staff have worked to accommodate our larger groups for birthdays, and we have sat upstairs, and downstairs, and they have been attentive, even when we were the only ones on the patio, too. If you want a delicious Italian meal, good wine, lovely atmosphere and good service, try Pelligrinos!

I've eaten at Pellegrino's multiple times, with my husband, friends and coworkers. Always delicious…read morefood with great service. Lovely atmosphere too.