I've eaten there a couple of times when passing through.. After our last visit we thought that the service could have been a little better. If you just want pizza it is okay, but don't expect a 5 star experience that includes service with a smile. read more

6 dirty tables. Been here for 30 minutes had to find a clean table. Wondering if it was truly cleaned. 4 employees. 2 were just eating now standing behind counter chatting. They apparently have a table they sit at behind counter. I will drive to Ocean Springs to Tom's if I want Pizza next time. Cheese pizza tasted old. read more

This place is the real deal! I've spent a lot of time in Brooklyn, NY as my father's side of our family is from there, and I've had plenty of Brooklyn style pizza. This place is by far the closest I've ever had, and I had to come to Mississippi to find it! The crust was perfect, crunchy and chewy, the sauce a perfect passata and just the right amount, and that cheese, I think that's what makes it just like the Brooklyn pizza shops I remember fondly. Really good job Brooklyn Pizzeria! read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Amazing pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Bay St. Louis, Mississippi

Brooklyn Pizzeria is always good. Large supreme is always good and enough to feed a family of 3 with leftovers. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Bay St. Louis, Mississippi

First off I live in the Pass, but I am from Brooklyn, with Italian background. I ordered a calzone today, when I got it & opened it up it was "puffy" but almost empty, some cheese, not much, didnt seem like much ricotta, & the spinach was sparing. Might need to train the staff on making a decent,real one. Also noticed no hair restraint or "gloves" on the pizza maker. Usually always enjoy going there for a slice. Like in Brooklyn. read more

The best pizza we tried since moving to the area. Everyone was friendly and the pizza was delicious.

The pizza was delicious, but the wait was crazy. We got a half cheese half veggie. The place was clean.

One of the better pizza restaurants I've been to around here. I still prefer Sarducci's over in Gulfport but this isn't bad and is closer to me in Bay St Louis. I will say two things. 1) prices have skyrocketed, and 2) it took 50 minutes of waiting inside to get my order. Luckily I had nowhere else to be. Food is a 4.25 Service/Speed was a 1.5 Prices were a 2.5 3.6 / 5 read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - "All The Way" Small Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bay St. Louis, Mississippi

See all

I just want to say this place is the absolute best. Passing thru and i wanted some good pizza. We had to try them wings and that new fajita pizza with the chicken baby. Everything was good even that guy with tattoos, perfection to say the least. Loved the music and vibes will be back for more. Thank yall for real read more

We love the pizza here. The calzone was tasty as well. Would like to try some other things but it is hard to get beyond the pizza!

Ashley B is the best! Very friendly, able to multitask while working quickly and efficiently. Ashley can easily recommend menu items as she's worked there for quite a while. Love the pizzas and salads! Order in or take-out. She always gets our order right! read more

Best homemade pizza we have found and we've been to Georgia Alabama and Florida mediocre Pizza at best but this place is wonderful. The sauce is good. The size is good. Everything they put on it is fresh. It's very reasonable and very quick. They have three young men working in there and they really hustle. I appreciate their dedicated Making of wonderful Pizza my husband and I have been there several different times since we've been in in Bay St. Louis and we will go back. Don't miss this spot. It's really good pizza. read more

Pizza was good. Loved the crispy crust. Salads are huge and Have banana peppers, olives, tomatoes, lettuce, and mozzarella cheese. This place offers both ranch and French dressing for the pizza. IYKYK. We were greeted upon entrance and the folks behind the counter were very nice. This place is super casual and not exactly huge. All of the tables were 4 tops with the exception of the one large table in the back. There was a cute little picnic table for small kids. Restrooms were clean. I would eat here again if I were in town. read more

Love the pizza and meatball dish's. Just found out I was a diabetic so I wanted the cauliflower crust. Been out for 3 weeks so I am forced to go to a competitor. Such a shame read more

Great little place in a strip mall, food was great! Price not unreasonable, good service!

Great pizza, great service. A favorite place on the coast. Always tasty - pizza, garlic knots, etc.

Foods always great!! Megan and Courtney are always pleasant and super helpful!! Antipasto is amazing so is meatball. I can't forget my personal favorite turkey and cheese.!! read more

Solid pizza. Thin crust. Good value. Looking forward to having it again next time I'm in town.

Brooklyn Pizzeria was accommodating & fast on our pickup pizza. The calzone was truly delicious. We plan to go there again for our Bay St. Louis pizza fix! read more

The staff here is wonderful. I ordered a Large pizza for dine in for my wife and I and it was the most delicious pizza I have since I was a teen in New York. My wife ordered a sandwich to go and without hesitation the lady said loudly "that's going to be 30 mins." She was an older lady so I'm not sure what the problem was but other than that, everything was great!!!!!!! read more

Very good pizza. Been here several times and the pizza is excellent. Ordered several pizzas and all were very good.

After 11 years of patronage, never again. Waited 20 min to pickup after arriving due to 1 cashier & a group ordering individual pizzas. Cold when picked up & quality FAR BELOW anything I've EVER had there. Not sure if it's the "new" Mgmt or what, but I fed it to the dogs as it was worse than the local Pizza Pizza store. read more

Their food is fabulous! Hand tossed pizza crust and delicious bread for their sandwiches don't miss this great place. I get food to go

Absolutely delicious pizza. I've had some pizza in NYC and this is definitely a trip down flavor memory lane. We shared pepperoni, cheese and veggie. It was super fresh and they did not skimp on the cheese, which is the most important part of the pizza (in my humble opinion). The best part is that it's really a good value. The large pizza is huge (I think 20") and a cheese pizza is $14. Adding ingredients are priced per ingredient. Because the pizza is so large, the slices are also akin to the typical New York-style pizza. You can also buy pizza by the slice. There are a lot of really tasty looking items on the menu and we will definitely be returning customers when we are in BSL. read more

I went to eat at Brooklyn's for the first time over the weekend and it was such a pleasant experience. The cashier, I believe her name was Jordan, was so friendly and a pleasure to encounter on a day that hadn't been going well for me. The pizza was delicious! read more

Tasted like the pie we got in New York!! Can't get much closer to the real thing without fighting thru traffic or riding a subway.... Will recommend to anyone read more

Pizza by the slice was very good at a good price. The next day we had subs. They were out of meatballs so an Italian sub was tried. We liked the pizza better. read more

Friendly family place. Amazingly delicious pizza, the crust, sauce, cheese & toppings we're spot on. Definitely the best Brooklyn style I've had 8n the South. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - 2021 menu - Pizza Near Me - Bay St. Louis, Mississippi

See all

Best pizza place on the coast! Very Authentic, amazing service, the restaurant is always clean, And the prices are great as well! Will definitely be returning soon. read more

Worst pizza I have ever had.. Crust was like rubber, sauce sucked, cheap meat, cheap tasting cheese.. I thought maybe since the Gulfport location is owned by another family member it might be better but I was soooooo wrong.. And on top of terrible food, they charged a service fee?? Service fee really for what for super sucky food??? read more

Love this pizza!! This is a hole in the wall place in a run down shopping center. I had lived on the Gulf Coast for years and never truly noticed this place before. I saw it on Yelp and decided to give it a try. The crust is thin and has the perfect crunch. My kids love the pizza too...and they are true critics of pizza cuisine . I got the Italian Roll and it was delicious! Lots of cheese, sausage and pepperoni. The rolled crust had the perfect amount of crispness. We will definitely be back! read more

The Covid-19 caught us traveling and we ended up in Bay St.Louis. one night we decided to try this place. Traveling, it can be hit or miss on Pizza. The big chain stores leave much to be desired. Not this place!! As close to a real NJ proper pizza as I have had Ina very long time. Our pepperoni was made quickly and piping hot( although it was ready to eat when we got back to the camper.). The crust was a great thin crust with a delectable blend of chewy crispness!! I am sure we will be back! read more

Old time Pizza Parlor atmosphere. Pizza good, service great Our favorite place for pizza read more

Hole-in-the-wall pizza place in a shopping center in BSL. Delicious pizza! Typical salads, sides, drinks, strip mall type tables and limited space but totally worth it for the top-notch pizza. Made to order, bubbling hot when served, large slices - order a side salad that you can easily split among 3 or so people. read more

The food is fantastic, but I can't continue to support this management. Called 2 nights ago to make a pick up order at 8:35 (they close at 9:00). I was told that it was too slow of a night to stay open. Called tonight at 8:20. No answer. Stop into the shop. They tell me they were too busy and had to close early. I've given it another chance. The food is always fantastic and the service has gotten better. read more

Staying at rental property nearby and we wouldn't have stopped here except for the good Yelp ratings. It's in a small strip mall, has poor signage, and very unassuming. Order at the counter and they bring to your table. About 9 tables inside. We had a medium pepperoni, Canadian bacon, and breakfast bacon pizza and 2 drinks. Priced reasonable. Pizza was very tasty. Thin, slightly crispy but flexible crust made from scratch. Medium was pretty big, about the size of other places large, and so we had 3 pieces left over. We would definitely come back. read more

The best pizza on the coast The staff is very nice and polite When in a rush you can buy pizza by the slice. read more

This is the best pizza I have found in Bay Saint Louis! Highly recommend! I found that the pizzas are larger than normal. They do put a lot of stuff on their pizzas. read more

This serves the best pizzas in the Waveland/Bay area and probably much further than that. Real New York style and just so delicious. The salads are wonderful also, this is just one of my favorite restaurants by far! read more

If you are looking for a slice of Heaven or a whole lot of joy for you to share this is the place to come. We came and ordered a Medium with ham and pepperoni on it. I did ask for light sauce just because that's the way I like it. When it came out it was perfectly cooked. The crispy crust in your mouth and that gooey cheese. Best part was there was no grease running down my arm like other pizzas. So when you are out and need a snack or a whole meal give this place a try. read more