Great store! Even more stuff in the basement, really nice people who work there! Tons to look…read morethrough! Maureen was extremely nice and we'll definitely be back!

One of the best thrift stores I've ever been to!! There are tons and tons of great finds and…read moreMaureen is the nicest person you will ever meet in your life!! It's a family owned business and they get new items in almost every day! They have tons of $1 jewelry and $5 jewelry and a HUGE downstairs area!! Make sure to ask to go see the downstairs area because that's where all of the good stuff is!! It's basically a giant Ebay store in the basement but when you go in person she gives a huge percentage off the collectibles! Sometimes even 50% off! They have Barbies, comics, Walking Dead, Star Wars, WWE, Vinyl, $1 CDs, and so so so much more!!

Lots of cool vintage and vintage inspired trinkets, furniture, and decor. Place is super fun and…read morereally well thought out.

Still a great place to stop for that special hard to find nostalgic gift item…read more And also now the attached coffee and pastry shop, Elise's nieces Cafe. With the cozy outdoor patio. Shop, and then enjoy a warm hot cup of coffee and a delicious pastry!!

Great job great prices amazing thrift stores I would go there any time again I drove an hour and a…read morehalf and still worth it

10 plus 10 stars - always magnificent pieces - my first choice -Elle is so talented and it…read moreshows in her designed pieces Love, achel BarrettWhutmore

Awesome consignment shop located on the north shore of Nassau Long Island. The owner from mill pond…read moreis a very nice and reasonable women that is fair with pricing the items for consigning and truthful about what the markets is calling for price wise. Down size very small shop wish this place could be a bit bigger !

I love going in and just looking. The owner Tracy most gracious lady. Did some business with her…read moreand was very satisfied. Charming shop, the staging is awesome and whenever I visit Oyster Bay, I stop in to browse.

Not a bad thrift shop but definitely not an excellent one either. When you walk in it's seems like…read morea lot of clutter but there were sections where things were in order. There wasn't a lot of selection in the mens department when it came to clothes. The prices were decent but nothing like goodwill prices. I don't know if I'd return but I still wishing Second Chance Theift Shop continued success.

Bought a Mr. Clause and Mrs. Clause animatronic.. came home and was going to clean it up .. roaches…read morejumped out the minute I started cleaning it and also the Mrs. Clause hands was stapled on.. she charged me over 100 bucks for both ! I would never recommend this business or go again!!! How dishonest! Never again !!! Thank you god I had it in my car and not my house !

Not the greatest consignment shop around. Many other shops in locust valley that have more variety…read moreof stuff.

Valley Attic is a unique and special store filled with gems!…read more I've been doing business with "the sisters" for over 7 years and recommend them to anyone and everyone. They are dedicated, provide personalized assistance and care about their consigners and buyers. They truly want the best outcome for all. Although it is second hand store, they only accept first quality high end items and unusual finds, which makes shopping and consigning such a positive experience. They have an amazing eye and have curated an inventory filled with items that you will rarely find anywhere else. The Items are often posted on Instagram so you are always up-to-date on what pieces are coming in, another unique feature. Calling all kinds of customers, including Stagers and Decorators. Just visit and you will be addicted, too. Valley Attic transactions are always pleasure!

This thrift is a wild and crazy experience - the amount of long lost items are insaneeeeeee- you…read morecould probably find anything here if you dig long enough. I was super overwhelmed. I was upset to see vintage makeup outside melting in the oppressive heat - the furniture outside LOVELY - a cabinet with marble top was divine. Wicker chest of drawers. Records galore inside. DVDs outside. Piles of clothes if that's your jam. I overheard the more you buy the less you pay ??? I paid 20 bucks for 9 miscellaneous items.

A true vintage shop. As in, you'll actually find items here from the 70's and before, when things…read morewere made to last. This place is cramped to the max with everything you can imagine from decades past: costume jewelry, canvas paintings, sports pennants, it doesn't stop. They do have newer items such VHS tapes and DVD's stashed in the back. The manager will price everything when you go to check out, but his prices are very reasonable, and the more you buy the better deal he'll give you. He must be good at math. I like people who are good at math. Not a long walk from the Valley Stream LIRR station. Totally worth the trip from the City or Brooklyn. And yes, you can Uber back to the train station with your take! There's on one reason not to love this place: you're extremely claustrophobic. Oh no, what did I write?! Stay away, leave everything for me!

Very fun to dig. Comic and vintage toy collectors should check it out. Staff very friendlyread more

An adorable well organized thrift shop with amazing prices. Stop by and give them some business…read more You'll be glad you did.