Not a bad thrift shop but definitely not an excellent one either. When you walk in it's seems like a lot of clutter but there were sections where things were in order. There wasn't a lot of selection in the mens department when it came to clothes. The prices were decent but nothing like goodwill prices. I don't know if I'd return but I still wishing Second Chance Theift Shop continued success. read more

Bought a Mr. Clause and Mrs. Clause animatronic.. came home and was going to clean it up .. roaches jumped out the minute I started cleaning it and also the Mrs. Clause hands was stapled on.. she charged me over 100 bucks for both ! I would never recommend this business or go again!!! How dishonest! Never again !!! Thank you god I had it in my car and not my house ! read more

It is a very small store that is very very crowded with merchandise. I only go there when I have a few hours to spend since one has to look carefully for various items. For example, I look at dvds, books, and cds, which are plentiful but often in need of straightening up. I bought several cds today ($1.00 each). The dvds were also $1.00 each, which is a very fair price. They have a nice jewelry counter, some glass cases with more expensive items, some clothing (mostly women's), records, some comic books, prints and paintings, some toys (not many), and knicknacks. I go there a few times a year, and I have always found the owner and her employees to be very nice, friendly, and supportive. The only negative thing I can say is that some of the items there are way overpriced. For example, I looked at a paperback of For Better or For Worse comics. The price was $5.00. It should have been no more than $2.00 tops. I didn't buy it since I didn't really need it, and the price was offputting. I also think the clothing is higher priced than it often should be. So, I do recommend this store, but you must have patience and time! read more

Second Chance Thrift Shop - Two were still sealed and brand new. - Thrift Stores Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Many items. Great Prices. Plenty of Parking. Friendly and helpful workers. Hidden Gems. Many Antique items. $2 Clothing Rack with great finds. Even new items with tags. read more

See all

I love love love this shop. Hidden gem. I found several amazing items including a formal dress and work skirts in the $2 rack. I got a huge kitchen garbage size bag full of clothes for $40 and that is because I bought a wool cardigan for $20. Is mostly clothes and also have misc items. I saw lots of jeans. Women and men clothes. Very reasonable prices. Also have shelvea of jewelry and sunglasses which got some. I wish they opened sooner or had longer hours ao I could stop by more often. This place only sells what they receive in donation and place is small. But its worth a stop bc of the prices. Items out were in good condition. read more

So cool!! So many interesting things. The woman that was working there was so nice. It was an eclectic walk down memory lane.

Wish I had read reviews before going .incredibly rude staff and store does have an odor ad someone previously stated . Save . time and money . Shop elsewhere read more

So it's a little of this and that, not bunches of one thing but plenty for the eye to look at an explore. Just when you think you saw everything, your eye catches something else. Today I left with a vintage copper pepper shaker for $1.00. I say that's a win for me. Lots of clothing to look through and some hodgepodge of artishy art work in the back. If your a thrifter you will love the browsing. read more

See all

This thrift shop is A-Ok. There's lots of stuff packed in here for such a small store. Clothing, accessories, shoes, bags, jewelry, housewares, games, dvds, records, toys and some art pieces- among other knick knacks fill this store. The pricing seemed decent and most items were 1970s to current. I didn't fall in love with any particular item- but this shop is definitely worth checking out regularly. read more

Second Chance Thrift Shop - Thrift Stores Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Came here in December and was really overwhelmed when I went in. It's really cramped so it was hard to walk around with a winter coat. So many good things!! I love it here. You really have to look because there's a lot of stuff in a tiny space. I got a lot of good Christmas decorations and some other decor. Can't wait to go back. read more

I have been a customer for the past two and a half years and this shop never disappoints; honestly it's like walking into a museum. There is so much variety, and I love scavenger hunting for pieces. The price is usually always fair, and the shop always has rotating sales for different colored tags. I've always found amazing quality items in this shop, and it has been my go to for a very long time. I've found gorgeous antiques in this store, and I love sifting through the 50 cent bins to find things like stationary, small vases, and gifts. You can clearly tell that the owner has a passion for this shop, and the staff are always so inviting and friendly. It's a hidden gem in the neighborhood, and you never know what you're going to find! read more

Love this store. I always find amazing items here. You really need to look, try things, and take your time to find some gems. Good luck. The lady who works there is very friendly. read more

My daughter and I love 'thrifting' and always find a little something here! Great prices and nice service.

I root for this place but I don't know how they stay in business. They have almost no music selection, no video games, very little if any electronics and essentially no collectibles. Folks inside are always super nice and the store is easy to roam around. I genuinely wish them the best of luck and continued success but I literally have no idea how the doors are still open. read more