Amazing pies, super service!We got a sampling of the 4" pies and a Buttermilk Pie to take to an event. We loved all the pies, and ate every one in a very short time frame...And I really didn't want to give up my big pie the following night. Super staff too! We arrived late, as we were told the wrong closing time and they were turning off the lights. They were gracious and very kind (let us in anyway) and we'll be going back very soon! This place needs to stick around. read more

I was in Midland visiting family - found this darling little shop (love the name), and bought a chocolate cream pie. Absolutely the best I have ever had - the ladies were very friendly - I will definitely come again! read more

The desserts are AMAZING!,,, I guess I should say the pies are out of this world. Long standing dessert stop of choice for me. The pricing I would say is fair, the customer service is always top shelf, polite,friendly,smiley, and almost as sweet as the pies themselves. Cute little place, you will drive smooth by if you aren't looking, it is kind of small. But oh how it is worth the reward of paying attention. Love it, love it, love it!, read more

Love the pies here! I love the option they have of mini pies and I usually get that. You can get up to 4 mini pies of different flavors or same lol but I do different ones! read more

Bought a pie over the holidays. I had been meaning to try this place for some time. So maybe because it was around the holidays and they do not offer many of their pies.... I was disappointed. Ended up with a pecan and I have had better. It wasn't bad by any means, just didn't knock my socks off. I'm going to leave it at a 3 star. Price and quality. read more

Tries 3 Pies pumpkin key lime and the I-40 for an office party, 12 people contributed their thoughts and critiques. Pumpkin-crust was good filling was good not the typical pumpkin filling. Key Lime-excellent pie good crust. A very good tasting pie. I-40 Pecan with chocolate and coconut. Good tasting pie with a good crust. Overall pies were good to very good with the key lime being a favorite. Prices were "expensive" to "shocking" as I paid $78 for all 3 pies. read more

My boyfriend always delivers me pies from here and they are so tasty and fresh! The lemon pie and thumbprint cookies are my favorite, and the other flavors are so good as well! This is for sure a Midland must have! read more

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - A Dozen of 2" Mini Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Midland, Texas

This place is incredible!!! Best pies I've ever eaten in my life! I've never liked key lime, yet their key lime is to die for!!! We have an AirBnb in town and we give their cute little 4" pies as a welcome gifts to our guests who stay 2 nights or more. Everyone always comments on how delicious the pies are. Wish Buttermilk Sky had other locations across the country, not just in the South. read more

This place deserves more reviews. My friends and I saw this cute little pie shop while driving on the loop and decided to stop by for a sweet tooth craving. These are small little pies, the perfect size for a one person serving without feeling the guilt. There's a large variety and I think that was the hardest decision. Picking which one you want to try. When we got there, they were out of samples so that's a bummer but we ended up getting different flavors so I got to try a little bit of everything. I ended up getting the lemon pie because I love a little tartness. I was deciding between that and the apple. But honestly, you cannot go wrong with any of the flavors. They are good. And if you aren't a pie person, they can easily change your mind, trust me! Only complaint would be there are no seating in the pie shop. You have to grab your pie and go. These are small little pies so I feel like seat turnover rate would be good. Even if there are a couple of chairs and a table. read more

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Lemon pie - Bakeries Near Me - Midland, Texas

If you want The best pie in midland and Odessa then don't go to HEB or Walmart. Come here because these are all homemade and they make it 20 mins prior for your pickup..it's walk ins too but carry out i prefer because they make it fresh 20 mins before you pick it up...and yes they are warm. Buttermilk is my favorite because it's not t too sweet but just right. read more

The mini pies are not just cute looking, but taste great. Not too sweet. Good customer service.

Spectacular! To call this pie shop spectacular is an understatement. A must try for pie lovers.

This place is great, just what Midland needed. Pies are very reasonable. I couldn't resist the 4 pack. They even have ice cream. I'll definitely be back. read more

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - I-40 (deliciousness), chocolate meringue, chocolate chip & chess - Bakeries Near Me - Midland, Texas

See all

Amazing staff !! So friendly and are very knowledgeable about the company! Great place to go and grab a quick treat !

This pie shop is fantastic!!! Served 2 of the I-40 pies for my book club and they were a hit!!! Such nice people working there also!! Will definitely be back!! So yummy!! read more

I bought an apple pie today for my brother. It was his birthday, and apple pie is his favorite. I asked him how he liked the pie, and he said "that was literally the best apple pie I have ever had." And this is a guy who has had a lot of pies in his day! read more

Nice workers. Young chicks that were friendly and timely when ordering and checking out. Prices aren't bad! 2 small pies for $9. The chocolate meringue was good but the s'mores one was an overly sweet brownie, not a pie. I might be back in the future. Not great but not bad at all. Worth it if you're in the area and want a small pie. read more

Absolutely delicious! The aroma that greets you when you walk in the door is so pleasing! Key lime thumbprint cookies were to die for! Coconut cream pie with meringue reminded me of my grandmother's kitchen read more

Cons: expensive . Variety isn't much . Pros : The pecan pie is amazing ,best one I've had . You can see it's a clean place . Nice and friendly . Quality . read more