I'd like to start off by saying that I don't typically write yelp reviews, but due to all of the…read morenegativity on here, I wanted to give my perspective after living in a Fineberg building for a year. I'm not saying you should expect the best apartment of your life here, but you should know that there are plenty of tenants that have had an enjoyable experience renting with this company.
My boyfriend and I lived on the top (3rd) floor of a unit in Allston near Comm Ave. We had spent about a month searching for an apartment in May for a September lease (for those of you that know Boston, the real estate market is a mess) and specifically, we wanted an apartment that was no fee. A broker fee is paying $2,000 or however ungodly amount for a real estate broker to open a door for you. Since our apartment with Fineberg, we've had to use a broker to get another apartment and it was a nightmare. But that's another story.
Anyways, we met with Dennis and he showed us the unit. It was a one bedroom that was about ~500 square feet. Small and old, but again, that's Boston. The previous tenants had left their apartment pretty messy, and the unit was small, but we liked it. There was also no security deposit which was a huge bonus. When we toured the apartment, we did not poke our heads in, look around, and call it good. I think people do a terrible of job of actually viewing the apartments they're considering, and then get all pissed off when stuff doesn't work after they move in. We turned on the water and tested the pressure, we felt the heat, we asked the current tenants how everything was, we checked that windows opened, we turned the stove on, etc. REALLY LOOK AT THE APARTMENT BEFORE YOU MOVE IN. So many of these reviews are "there were bugs and mice" or "XYZ didn't work". By being thorough with your review of a unit, you can avoid a lot of shit. Just my two cents.
We signed the lease and lived there for a year. A couple of annoyances with building in general (not Fineberg's fault) - the walls are paper thin and a couple down the hall from us had a baby. Not sure why on earth you would want to raise a family in an apartment full of college students but whatever. We heard the baby a lot, which was annoying. The heat got a too hot during the winters, but we just cracked our window and let some cold air in. Not that big of a deal - I'd rather have it a little warm than not working at all.
Our hot water went out twice in the year we were there, but we were promptly notified and it was a problem within a section of Allston entirely, not just Fineberg. We had a couple of issues with our fridge not staying cold and they supplied an entirely new appliance the day after we submitted our request, which was awesome. We also had the toilet shop flushing, and again, they were in the next day to fix things. If you submit a request, they are very prompt about following up and fixing things. It was annoying that they showed up at 8 am on a Saturday to fix it, but hey, I'm not going to complain for being too prompt.
Overall, we had very few issues over our year with Fineberg. When we did have an issue, they were extremely prompt in fixing it. I would highly recommend Dennis as well, because he was very honest about everything. The ONE thing I want to note that really bugged the crap out of us - when we decided not to re-sign our lease, Fineberg gave my cell phone number to (what felt like) every broker in the city. It's required that we got a 24 hour notice before anyone came into our apartment, but for a full month after our unit went on the market, my cell phone was literally flooded with calls/text from brokers. Some of them are so rude, too - not "can we show your place at this specified time" but more like "we're coming at 7 am Saturday morning" which got super old. I work full time and I came out of a meeting to 12 missed calls and 7 texts from brokers wanting to show our place. Even after someone signed the lease, nobody from Fineberg took it off the market and I still got calls and texts for a couple of weeks.
Besides that, though, we had a relatively good year and I would recommend.