We had the everything pizza the first night and veggie the second. Some of the best pizza we've ever had. The sauce is amazing as is the crust. Our new go to when camping. Service was very friendly and the place was clean. read more

Pizza was great, vibes were good. Wings 10/10. Also very friendly service! We will definitely be back read more

Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza - We ordered pepperoni pizza. Was great. - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

Literally the worst pizza I've ever had. Couldn't call to place an order. Ordered in person, waited 30 mins only had half the order ready, waited another 30 mins for this pizza. Holy crap, never seen a pizza like this, a frozen digorno would be better. My god. read more

Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza - Literally worst pizza ever. - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

We were in town for the holidays and stopped by Christmas Eve after a hike. Outside appearance is well kept, and they have wifi information posted at the doorway on your way in! This is a place to place your order to go, but they have seating indoors and on the patio. There are no wait staff, so take care of your own trash! They have utensils and condiments table, and have a couple fridges filled with two liters of soda and cans of alcoholic beverages. FYI. They are card only. NO cash! Staff was very friendly and patient. We only did pizza and drinks in our first order. The pizza was good! Cheese is gooey and good flavors. No complaints and would totally come back again! We went ahead and tried their homemade ice cream. 3.99 for a half pint... and we got most of the flavors and we enjoyed it. Good flavor and texture! read more

Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza - Pep with half mush, large - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

Wanted to try some place new. Walked in, told them we hasn't been there before, ordered at the counter. If you want to sit inside, there are 2 tables, all others outside but nice area to sit outside when it's nice out. Ordered Italian sub and side of fries. Mom ordered wings. "Server" came out and yelled our name. I said "here", and she set our food down and walked off. I asked, "that's it?!" She said. "What?" I asked, "Napkins? Silverware? Plates?" She walked inside, showed me a bakers rack with paper plates, condiments, and plasticware and another brought napkins. I explained again that when there are new customers, these things need to be explained. Other than that, food was good, would try again. read more

Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza - Italian sub. Good amount of meat. - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

Pulling in this feels like a fun friendly gathering place, they did a great job adding the outdoor patio last year. Unfortunately the pizza is on par with most gas stations nowadays and the beer prices aren't something you want to stick around and enjoy. The setting says restaurant but the employees would rather look at their phone around the corner than present themselves as someone in the food industry. They don't explain anything and everyone who stays to eat their pizza asks for plates,napkins etc. get told "oh there is plates and stuff inside you can grab". So much more could be done to capitalize on this location, just need some management skills and effort. read more

This is just darn good pizza. That being said, I got the chicken pizza with the garlic Parmesan wing sauce because I wanted some protein. The pizza came with a single chicken wing planted in the middle of the pizza. The celery was unnecessary (and not really cooked), so I picked it off. It was really tasty though. Service was nice, but allot an hour around dinner time because they get busy! read more

Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

The pizza was excellent, and we enjoyed eating outside with a nice breeze. There were A LOT of people here with dogs. I love dogs, but I don't enjoy random dogs licking my feet and circling my table while we are trying to enjoy a meal. Since that wasn't the restaurant's fault, I am not taking off any stars. (But it would be nice to maybe have a designated area for people who want to bring their dogs.) It also got pretty busy and the tables filled fast, but there was plenty of room for more tables. They should consider adding way more! read more

First of all, the theming?? Insane!! Picture this, you're in the middle of Ohio craving some pizza and you come across a pirate captain named Ron? Our interest was piqued to say the least. 1. Our pizza was half pepperoni half supreme. Be PREPARED for crazy amounts of banana peppers. I used to hate them but maybe my taste buds are changing because it kinda rocked my world. Don't expect the vegetables to be cooked - in Ron's kitchen they like them crunchy I guess. 2. We ordered breadsticks but the employees might have been confused because we left that establishment with breadsticks and a special surprise... 2a. The breadsticks were breadsticks. Cheesy, garlicky, hitting the spot. 2b. HOT DOG BUNS as garlic bread we are guessing?? Clarify with Ron's first mates so you don't end up with hot dog buns, unless that's your thing in which case have at it. read more

Excellent pizza -thin crust, well baked and great cheese and sauce. Highly recommend!

Good pizza Good service Nice deck. Relaxing atmosphere. Good pizza Good service Nice deck. Relaxing atmosphere. read more

Terrible experience,the place is slow and just diverse in bad ways.the subs are tiny and the pizza just isn't that great.i do not recommend going ever!!! This is our first and will be our last.also who uses meatballs instead of sausage on a meat lovers??? read more

The cheesy name draws you in and the food keeps you there The pizza is good but the real gem is the ice cream. Whether you're driving through or stopping by after a long hike, this place is a must. All the ice cream is hand-made and it's so much better than store-bought tubs or those places that make 42 flavors by putting syrup in plain soft-serve. It's not only creamy af, but the flavors stand out really strong - the honey-vanilla is perfectly balanced and the chocolate tastes like chocolate bars instead of the weird taste that typical chocolate ice cream has. Recommend having a scoop of peanut butter ice cream with it! Plus, it's inexpensive, with a half-pint costing less than $5 W O R T H. read more

Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza - Honey-vanilla ice cream - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

This is take out or sit outside only, no indoor dining. Thin pizza crust that wasn't exciting with an ok red sauce, but generous for toppings and definitely bubbling hot cheese. Lots of grease. We were under the impression there would be something fun and pirate-y coining the name...nope. But the girls working the cash register and back kitchen were nice. This is a late-night-taste pizza place. Wouldn't recommend unless you're craving. read more

Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza - Bacon onion topped Build Your Own Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

Really great food and affordable! They have a great patio area when the weather is nicer. They do not accept cash. We got their hot dogs and pepperoni pizza. Pizza was awesome just a bit greasy. read more

Great wings and pizza! Perfect lunch or dinner after hiking in Hocking Hills. The garlic parm wings were so good. We will definitely be back on our next trip! read more

Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza - Boneless Wings and Build Your Own Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

I was thankful this place was open on Memorial Day to satisfy my craving for pizza. While the place doesn't look big from the road there is actually quite a lot of outdoor seating on the front porch + a covered pavilion area off to the side. Inside had seating for about 8 people. ** This business does not accept cash, cards only ** My friend and I got a medium Supreme and a cauliflower crust "build your own" and both were delicious! Thin crusts, round pies cut into squares and lots of fresh toppings! The staff brings your order out to you whether dining in or carry out. The pizzas could've been cooked a minute longer to allow the cheese to optimally melt and possibly get that nice brown color to it, which I think brings out more flavor. They were still hot and delicious! They have Pepsi fountain products and a cooler for single serve beers, water, iced coffee and more. Many other menu items like: salads, wings, garlic/ cheese bread, subs. The seating at inside and porch tables was comfortable, iron patio chairs that accommodated bottoms of all sizes. Lol and under the pavilion area were picnic tables. The staff were personable, pleasant and professional, handling the early dinner crowd efficiently. So glad we stopped in! I highly recommend you do the same . read more

We were pleased to find a place open later to eat. Pizza was decent, but I wish there was some warning that they cut your round pizza into squares. It's more for carry out, but there are a handful of tables. If the employees were half way nice to customers, it would have gotten 5 stars. read more

We got pizza here the last night of our hocking hills vacay. The pizza was hot & fresh. I didn't have to cook. If I had any recommendation it would be if they could spread the toppings a little closer to the edge. But otherwise it was decent pizza. The staff was super friendly & talked us into going back for the homemade ice cream. Boy am I glad we did! The peanut butter ice cream was so delightfully creamy. The chocolate flake was chocolate ice cream with flakes of real chocolate not waxy chocolate flavored somethings. The pineapple and mango were more like vanilla ice cream with bits of pineapple and mango in it. But the vanilla ice cream was super creamy. Get the pizza if you want decent pizza close to old man's cave but make sure you top it off with their homemade ice cream! read more

Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza - Chocolate flake at 6 o'clock, then clockwise, pineapple, mango & peanut butter - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

We rented a place in Hocking Hills for the weekend and when checking out the map, we saw that the pizza place was next to our leasing office. I ordered online when we were en route and picked up at the same time we grabbed our keys. We got a large cheese pizza, a salad, and 2 smaller pizzas. Everything was really good. The crust was thin which I wasn't expecting but it was delicious! The website said it was takeout only but when we arrived, there was outdoor seating available. I'm not sure how that worked since we were just grabbing and heading to our cabin. read more

This is the greatest pizza place of all time. The quality of the cheese was the greatest I have ever had. The pepperoni appeared to be handcrafted on site. The atmosphere really made me believe that I was in the Caribbean in the 1700s amongst real pirates. Captain Ron is the character of characters his warm, and welcoming , yet very rugged demeanor had me and my family wishing that we lived local to visit this place daily. The talking parrot said aye aye to every customer what a hoot. I would give this place 6 stars if I could. My family and I absolutely raced about it and have been talking about the greatest dining experience in the history of dining experiences read more

A nice carryout place near Hocking Hills. Nothing fancy and the food isn't earth shattering but it's great to be able to skip cooking every now and then when you are in nature. We had: - Large pizza (half pepperoni) - good quality pizza but nothing special. Cheese is the highlight. Reminds me of LaRosas in the Cincinnati area but without the sweet sauce. - Cheesy bread - good quality, large portion for $7 - Chicken chunks - these are pretty pricey for what they are but popular with the kids They are taking coronavirus seriously. Curbside pickup and masking. Great work! read more

Picked up subs a couple of nights ago which were delicious. We decided to order subs again for dinner and what a huge disappointment! We received what looked like half a sub. When I inquired about the difference in size from what we received before, the employee in the back said that they ran out of the sub bread and only offered me an extra bag of chips... really?? Good food but I can't recommend this place because of the inconsistency of the food. read more

Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Logan, Ohio

Ordered two take and bake pies. Pizza was decent and enjoyable. Packaging interesting....disposable pans coveted in a piece of foil. Great instructions on prep. read more

We came up yesterday and my hubby ordered the 10" veggie pizza. Nothing to write home about and especially for $15.99. Tourist trap. But the WORSE part is, I got food poisoning. This morning at 4am I woke up having to vomit and I did a LOT and for 3 hrs. It was the food I had there and the worse feeling and throwing up from chills to burning up to three..3 HOURS of throwing up! I had 6 mild wings along with the Captain Ron's salad. (Which for the price, wasn't even worth half the cost). I don't know which item got me so sick but it was from there. My hubby and I both ate the same breakfast that we mamade at our cabin and he had the pizza, he didnt get sick. We come up every year and this was our first try and definitely our last. I wonder when the place was last inspected and what it looks like back in the kitchen. I am still sick and it's Sunday night at 8 o'clock. PS: Customers had left their pop cups out on the picnic tables so noone knew if seats were taken, had a waitress or someone, come clean up, it would've made for some ppl to be able to sit down. Save risking getting sick and save your money by driving 15 min. further away toward 33 and eat in that area instead. read more

Tried the bowls and they were delicious. Wonderful outdoor dining space. Should have tried the pizza. They looked incredible.

pizza actually pretty good....service and wait time is terrible. they were obviously understaffed, but i was told my pizzas would be "about 15 minutes" when I arrived to get my order (that we had called in 3 hours + before). Walked out 40 minutes later with the pizzas. (had they even started making them???). read more

Overall very nice place. They care about their customers and make good pizza. Definitely recommmend.

This is a great eatery and five stars for the delicious pizza but one star for whoever keeps double-booking the live entertainment.

Service was great, prices are fair and you can eat inside or outside. Just ordered a cheese pizza and the pizza had lots of cheese. The crust was a little funky which is the reason I only gave 3 stars. I would come back but probably try something else. read more

On a visit to Hocking Hills the group of us got pizza from Captain Johns and I will say it was some of the best pizza I have ever had! We had gotten 2 pepperoni pizzas one with extra sauce and both were delicious! I wished we lived closer it would honestly be our go to pizza place. Highly recommend if you are in the area camping. read more

The hours posted on Yelp are incorrect. The hours posted outside of the facility are incorrect. They only take credit no money. The staff is all women so they're afraid of getting robbed stated the girl at the front counter. The food took forever to come. My hot dog was delivered in a cold (right out of the fridge) bun. The husband's meatball sub arrived with pepperoni in it too. The girl at the front counter apologized for the small roll and said she should have taken 50% off but forgot. She offered a brownie instead. He said sure. Some time later "a brownie" arrived in a small aluminum pie plate. It was about 1/2 tall and tasted terrible. Just a disaster. Just sad. read more

It's a tourist trap pizza is frozen dough or already prepared then nothing special about the ingredients and drinks are very pricey it's ok but literally just ok hugely expensive and inside seating is hot read more

I would write a review on the food, but unfortunately I didn't get any. I called Mr. Ron at least 6 times but no answer. So we concluded that they were busy, we drove 30 mins to the restaurant and the parking lot was empty and had a small sign on the door "closed." Next time you decide to unexpectedly close your business make a voice mail or update your website hours. read more

Good pizza. nothing mind blowing. tasted great after a 5 hour hike though. outdoor and indoor seating.

Love their pizza. Close to my home. Fun place to go to. Close to the caves and they are busy during that season.

After reading multiple rave reviews while staying in Lazy Lane's Buckeye Bungalow cabin, we had to try Captain Ron's for ourselves. We think of ourselves as connoisseurs of pizza, and the reviews were correct. We had 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 sausage & mushrooms, onions & green pepper on everything. Not only was the pizza excellent; it was served in a timely manner. We'll make Captain Ron's a "must do" on future trips. read more

Good local pizza when staying in a cabin and you don't want too cook That night you arrive

Excellent pizza, it is sliced in 16 pieces, not your traditional pie cut. Worked well with our group of 18. Great taste and perfect amount of toppings. read more

Delicious pizza! Nice atmosphere! Wi-Fi! Accommodating staff! Definitely stop here for pizza or ice cream!