Pizza Crossing -- what a hidden gem in Logan…read more Seat yourself atmosphere, and it did take our waitress a bit to come around, but multiple large parties walked in at the same time we did. Once she got to us, she was incredibly sweet and attentive despite being busy. Free refills, and she even offered drinks to go -- such a nice touch. We ordered a small pizza (around 10 inches), which was perfect for 2 adults sharing, and loved that you can do half-and-half toppings. We did half veggie and half "all the way" (their supreme). It's easy to see why this place has been voted one of the best pizzas in Ohio. The pizza is unique -- a thinner crust, but not quite NYC-style thin, topped with provolone cheese instead of the usual mozzarella. A lot of people rave about their pepperoni too: smaller, meatier, and clearly higher quality. Even the slices stand out -- cut into small rectangles instead of triangles. Absolutely delicious and we'll definitely be back next time we're in Logan.

The young lady serving us was very nice and a few other employees also treated us well. The staff…read moreis friendly and helpful. Now to the pizza. We sampled the pepperoni pizza hoping it would be excellent. Sorry to disappoint the locals and staff. It was mediocre. The crust was very thin, the sauce wasn't anything to write home about, and there was way too much cheese on the pizza. No crust and I am not a fan of how they slice it. Give me a nice NY slice instead of cutting away the excessive cheese and either use a fork to eat or grease up your fingers. For some, they may enjoy the pound of mozzarella cheese on it and the little square piece, but this is not for me. As for flavor, nowhere a good pizza but not at the bottom, either. I say middle of the row for this pizza. Our party never fought to eat the leftovers, and that says something. If you're in the area and just need pizza, this could do but do go expecting great pizza.

We had the everything pizza the first night and veggie the second…read more Some of the best pizza we've ever had. The sauce is amazing as is the crust. Our new go to when camping. Service was very friendly and the place was clean.

Pizza was great, vibes were good. Wings 10/10. Also very friendly service! We will definitely be…read moreback

This small town pizza parlor is like walking into the past. We came in around lunchtime on a cold…read moreSaturday. The woman working was very friendly and made us feel welcome. The pizzas took about 20 minutes. They came out piping hot. They had a crisp crust and thick sauce. They were pretty good.

We originally were going to the bar across the street until we smelled the fresh pizza wafting from…read morethe door. We're glad we did. The service was excellent, we were greeted our table was wiped down despite it being clean. We changed our minds and decided to eat at the picnic table out front with the idea we would get the pie ourselves. Nope, they brought the pie, and our salad out to us with a roll of paper towels, and we're happy to do it. The salad! 5 stars! Fresh shredded lettuce tossed with groind pepperoni, green peppers, onions, banana pepper, and cheese. It was enough for 4 of us to eat from. The pizza! 4 stars. A thin,crisp crust where you could taste the fermentation. It had a nice balance of sauce and cheese. We ordered pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms. The pepperoni was Ezzo Sausage's Old World pep, the sausage was sliced and flavorful, the mushrooms were fresh, not from a can. All great! The sauce held the pizza back though. It was tangy, spicy, and well balanced. It was made from tomato paste, or maybe Contidina sauce.. I cant really say what the problem is. To summarize: Great service, Great salad, Above average pizza! Stop when you're in town.

Went to Athens with the family for a quick little trip for dinner and to surprise the youngins!…read more We ordered a 1/2 sheet pepperoni and a slice of cheese pizza plus 3 bottles of water, a Dr Pepper and A Lemon Lime Gatorade! The cook/waitress was extremelynice and helpful! They offer a special of 2 slices or pepperoni or cheese pizza and drink for $7! Their pizza is a large rectangle and I cant wait to devour it! I'mon a diet and Tomato restricted due to stomach health but Im with my familyand this is their choice option .. I LOVE LOVE LOVE Pizza and this did not disappoint! It's thick like Detroit Pizza! Very good and highly recommend if you are in the Athens area!! Literally right near Ohio University in Walking distance... Let me know your experience!

Had some bomb ass pizza. Lost my wallet right after, gave them my number and they called me back…read morelike 20 mins later. Bless the girl who was working tonight, she is amazing. Thank you so much. Ambiance was also amazing in goodfellas. Not too busy.

Busy place on Tuesday 5p and after getting a 12" meatlovers and 18" cheese pizzas did we find out…read morewhy - prompt - decent$ -quality - great taste

The pizza at Deputy's is delicious and they have many other items to offer on their menu. Deputy's…read morestaff are very personable and friendly. In my experience they went out of their way to make sure my visit at their restaurant was a good one. Their phone number (698-4911) is easy to remember too. Deputy's currently only accepts credit cards on carry-out orders so you can not pay with a card for delivery. Since they are a "mom and pop" place they are also not open very late at night.

Grabbed some pizzas to go on a Friday night during a Beer Week festival. Downtown Athens was…read morejumping, as was Courtside. Very busy, but our pizzas were ready a little early. Credit to the folks in the back for their efforts. As for the pizzas themselves, they were pretty good, in general. Thoroughly enjoyed the Nashville Hot pizza, and the sausage on our BYO was quite tasty. Only complaint would be that they were a little doughy, and a few slices on the square cut BYO had no toppings on them. Overall, these were quality pies. Courtside wasn't around during my time here, so I'm jealous of the current students who get to enjoy solid pizza options.

Courtside was one of my fav food places in Athens (I graduated 7 years ago). I doordashed a large…read morepepperoni pizza and it was delicious. Deducted a point bc they forgot my ranch. But best pizza in town for sure!

Definitely a good late night snack after a night out at the bars. We did come in closer to when…read morethey were closing so they didn't have much to pick from. The service was quick and we brought it back to our airbnb. We only got pepperoni and cheese pizza, but it was still good pizza. We got our pizza pretty quickly.

The pizza is delicious! Huge slices and great crust! My son loves getting Goodfellas!read more

i love their food its so good and freshly made, The service is quick and polite, and the interior…read moreis so cute in my opinion very vintage!

I absolutely adore this place and their food. It's amazing all around and fresh. The prices are not…read morebad at all either for what you are getting.