My brother and I were in town and starving, seen this Gem Papa Bennys. The pizza is great I really…read moreenjoyed the Italian sub. Bread is amazing! Must try

Great pizza place in a small town. Their pizza dough is the absolute best. So crispy on the…read moreoutside yet soft and fluffy on the inside. I also enjoy their toppings. Not a fan of their ranch, though. It's a thicker ranch very sour tasting. I prefer a runnier, more herby ranch.

Great food great chocolate great icecream a friendly staff and a lovely vibe plus they have themed…read moretreats during the holidays

I love their pizza. They use fresh mushrooms and not nasty canned. Their chocolates and small…read moregift items in the store always suck me in while picking up my pizza. Make sure you try a chocolate dipped strawberry!

Owner hung up on me when calling to place an order. It appears that they are using their personal…read morecell phone as a business phone. Hours on Yelp and Google are incorrect. K & J's Pizza closes at 7pm on a Saturday night. Like seriously, Saturday night is going to be one of your busiest nights and you close at 7pm. Are you even a real business? Just my opinion. Can't post a picture because, I wasn't able to order. Went to another local place instead a gas station. Their pizza and breadsticks were delicious!

Best pizza in Otisville, Columbivilla and Otter Lake area. But not many choices in the area for…read morepizza or food for that matter.

Amazing pizza and great salads! We called to order after a long day at the lake. They had…read moreeverything ready to go and the pizza ready to put in the oven so we could take it home hot & fresh. They suggested the garlic Parmesan crust and it did not disappoint. I highly recommend!

There might be a lot of maybes in Mayville. Maybe the bowling alley/ bar is open? There's no sign…read more Maybe the local Eagles Lodge will let non members in? Rumor has it. Maybe the last store in the High street will close. I hope not. But one sure thing is Maria's Pizza on Main Street. Being the only game in town you might think they could get lazy. Pre made this, pre made that. No way. This off the beaten path gem is the real deal. Freshly made dough. Fresh ingredients and a neat as a pin time warp dining area. And super friendly staff. Our personal salad was huge! And the pizza was fantastic. Support local businesses and support Maria's, you won't be disappointed. Also locally raised beef to order with Frozen pacs of ground beef available to go. Of course I bought some. So take a scenic drive north on M 24 and hang a left in Mayville. No maybes here. Maria's...Go!

We were in town for one night and wanted a quick easy supper. Reading the reviews we decided to…read moregive Lazy Dog Pizza a try. We ordered a thin crust cheese pizza, for pickup. Arriving we found our order was ready on time. The pizza did not disappoint! It was a very tasty pizza and done perfectly. We would not hesitate to return.

Service was horrible. Waited struggled with three drinks(all soda) to start with. Finally arrived…read morewith drinks and took the apps order which he again struggled with. 20 mins later apps arrived. Had to go to counter to ask if we could place our main order. Order was taken and food randomly appeared. One pizza at a time. Atleast the food was hot when recieved but nothing more than generic pizza. 25 mins after we recieved the first pizza order the last one finally arrived. Makes for awkward eating when each person was almost finished before the next arrived.

Very thick crust and very little cheese.. After the first bite, you drag the little bit of cheese…read moreon it, off the rest of the slice. Charmont Lanes close by has way better pizza, get the meat lovers!

I love this place! I don't have to get out of the car just pull right into the drive-thru. I…read moreappreciate having a place in the community that you don't have to walk into saves a lot of time and is very convenient. I love their pizza and their subs, especially their steak sub. Always so good and fresh mmmmmm. Great customer service and it doesn't matter who the server is they always remember to give my dog a treat. He loves it!

Service at the bar was amazing! Staff is very attentive and the drinks had some gusto! I recommend…read morethe Gin blossom! Have to get the cheese curds!

If you are not from here I highly recommend not eating here. The pizza was the strangest…read moreexperience. It was like bread with a strange sauce and cheese. We just picked the onions off it and just ate that. Idk who these people are that are giving this place a 5. If we are talking food... yall be crazy

The BEST pizza in the world! I grew up on this pizza and drive 16 hours home-one of the best…read morethings i look forward to. Always get a side of nacho cheese sauce for dipping.

I drove 20+ minutes each way (+ additional delay due to road work) to get Ernesto's pizza for my…read moremom who loves BLT pizza. So pleasantly surprised when they asked if I wanted the lettuce, tomato & mayo in a separate box? Made all the difference! Mom was super happy with it! Note: as of July 2022, curbside pickup only!

Amazing pizza and subs! Customer service is great too and they are always fast with completing…read moreorders.

Second stay in the area - PostCard cabins…read more... We order at least two times from here during our stay. Pizza Subs Apps Are all great and the staff is friendly! They make several things in house - They sell slices to go as well. Love the area and this is a perfect way to get a quick meal before a hike or to just relax.

This is a cool spot just north of Zhenders. Looks historic. Standing room only bar near entrance…read more Watch your knees on the unusual tables. Seems to be a popular spot for locals. It's a bit loud. It's fun though. The staff here are all super friendly. Our server, Stacey, was amazing. You don't even need to ask and she seems to know what you need. We had pizza and wings. Was very good. We will definitely be back.

Tiffany's has great service (outstanding actually). Servers are so attentive, efficient and…read morefriendly. Ambiance is lively. Restaurant nicely decorated. The food was delicious!! Pasta and sauces are all made in-house. My friend and I shared the spinach and artichoke dip and a baked rigatoni. Highly recommend. If you're in the mood for pizza this is the place to go! It looks fantastic!