Cancel

Open app

Search

Carmine's

4.0 (1 review)

Carmine's Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Carmine's

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

17 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Emmy Squared Pizza - Athens - The Emmy

Emmy Squared Pizza - Athens

4.4(120 reviews)
16.4 mi
Casual dining
Full bar

We had a really disappointing experience here and won't be returning…read more My husband ordered a burger without a bun and made a few simple modifications (no cheese, add bacon and onions). It came out fine, so he ordered a second one--only to have the manager come over after the order was placed to say they were "too busy" to accommodate those same modifications again. Apparently the server "shouldn't have allowed it." That's not just inconsistent, it's poor communication and puts the customer (and server) in an awkward spot for no reason. I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich that was honestly one of the driest things I've ever tried to eat. I could barely get through two bites. The fries that came with it left me with pretty bad indigestion later, which is unusual for me. Our daughters ordered pizza, which was fine--but it arrived about 30 minutes after our food, so we weren't even eating together as a family. We also ordered a bottle of prosecco that was barely chilled. We had to ask for an ice bucket just to make it drinkable. Between the food quality, inconsistent service, and overall experience, this was a miss across the board.

The good: The angel pizza was truly angelic. It looked like the photo online and tasted better than…read moreI predicted. I would definitely order that again. Another huge hit was the shaved brussel sprout salad. If you don't like brussel sprouts, you might change your mind after eating this. The combination of brussel sprouts with the cherries, blue cheese and miso dressing was the perfect combination I would never think to curate. The waffle fries were seasoned and good. The bad: The price is a little much. $18 for a salad without the protein is steep in my opinion. I paid $8 extra for grilled chicken that looked good but was dry, flavorless, and inedible. To be honest, had the chicken not been so terribly bad, and the prices were a little lower, 3/4 items were closer to 5/5.

Photos
Emmy Squared Pizza - Athens - Mushroom, olive basil gluten free crust and vegan cheese

Mushroom, olive basil gluten free crust and vegan cheese

Emmy Squared Pizza - Athens - Le Big Matt

Le Big Matt

Emmy Squared Pizza - Athens - Emily Burger

See all

Emily Burger

Carmine's - pizza - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...