I was hoping for a quick slice and a beer after a long flight and shuttle trip. I was NOT…read moredisappointed! I ordered one Sicilian and one Neapolitan slide and a draft Miller Lite while I watched the World Cup. Fast friendly service and two HUGE delicious slices! Fresh mushroom too. The vibe is true pizza joint and it delivers with good food, friendly service and plenty of space to enjoy.

In terms of value/price + convenience this is 4-5 stars, but in terms of actual flavor of the…read morepizza, a solid "3" ("Good" in my book). Old school booth dining, fast service, pay at the counter before you sit. Friendly crew working, prepping the pizza right in front of you. Buy it by the slice, thin or thick crust--I got a slice of each, very filling (esp that thick crust). $2 draft beer including craft--this is a beer/drinking/college town for sure, it seems. If I were 20 years younger in college I'd be a regular, as a tourist this was cool for a cheap quick dinner before a concert.

Fully Loaded Pizza Kitchen is such a gem in Athens! I tried the tator tots and they were crispy and…read moredelicious, perfect to snack on while waiting for the pizzas. We got the Besto Pesto with that amazing pesto swirl and the Thai One On pizza--both were incredible, packed with flavor and super fresh. And I have to say, their ranch is sooo good, definitely a must for dipping! Service was great and the vibe is fun and laid-back. This is for sure one of my new go-to pizza spots in town.

I have been several times and service and food is always good? Love the pizza. The food is a great…read morevalue for what you get.

Pizza dough ok, meat lovers ok, hot in sitting area. Service easy, Greek salad excellent! Don't…read morelive in area, would not recommend.

Commerce's secret spot apparently lived here for 5 years and this is my first time at Italy's…read morepizza and pasta and oh my it was soo good! We started off with garlic knots that were so delicious! I had probably what was the most amazing tomato basil soup and ended up sharing a big bowl of Alfredo broccoli pasta My sister got delicious Hawaiian calzone and ended up night with tiramisu! If you are in the area, definitely give this place a try! Staff if incredible, chef's and everyone was amazing! 10/10.

Eating here was a walk down memory lane. A wide variety, from spinach Alfredo to stuffed crust…read morepepperoni, each slice told its own story. Very clean establishment with a hardworking staff. We do advise you to come outside of the dinner rush hours in order to avoid a crowded eating experience. Also, don't come if you hate kids. We thank Cicis pizza for the opportunity to experience the buffet of our childhood.

I'm from Savannah, GA and the Cici's Pizza there was world class for a buffet pizza chain. The…read morepizzas were always hot and fresh because all the athletes and sport teams visit and keep the pies rolling out. I've visited a few south of Atlanta chains and the pizzas were terrible because they had no traffic. Even though you can still request hot custom pies I didn't want to be the one asking for all the hot fresh pies when there were so many pizzas untouched out on the buffet table. So anyways this Cici's just seems to be an Athens favorite! I didn't really notice any athletes or sports teams like the one back home. People of all ages just kept coming in and kept the pies coming out of the oven. This is off Atlanta highway and the location is right by an ingles which is convenient to have a cheap pizza dinner and do some grocery shopping afterwards. Another thing I noticed which I was impressed with was the staff's kindness from the manager to the bus boy there were no kind words spared. This location includes some flat screens showing mainly sports. This place is very child friendly. It has a lot of video games for the kids in a separate room connecting with the dining area so you are able to keep watch from a distance.

I will begin by saying that the pizza is delicious. If I had only ordered that, this would be a 5…read morestar review. However, we also ordered the burrata, focaccia, and pasta--all of which were underwhelming. A burrata that comes without bread--how does that work? Thankfully we had decided to order the focaccia already, but bread should come with a $13 burrata. The burrata itself was OK, it needed to be a little creamier but it was a decent flavor. 6/10 Focaccia was disappointing. If I had bought this from Publix, I would have thought it was decent. From an Italian restaurant, I expect better. It was a bit dry and pre-sliced which made me wonder how long it has been out. It also was not a very large quantity. The flavor was pretty good. 6/10 Bread is not their specialty, they may be better served buying from Independent... The pasta was just OK. The cavatelli was a bit doughy, OK flavor. Would be happy with it if I made it myself, but not up to par for a nice Italian place. 5/10 The pizza was a shining star (although I didn't get a plate for the pizza slices). I got the margherita pizza, and the crust was perfectly crisp and the tomato sauce had a wonderful flavor. The mozzarella had a similarly rich flavor and the basil and olive oil were interspersed throughout in a favorable ratio. If Pompeii turned into a pizza only restaurant, I would not be mad about it. Pizza gets a 9/10 Overall, you can tell it is a brand new restaurant and they have some kinks to work out. The food was just OK, but the pizza was excellent. They should lean into that. I would come back just for the pizza.

The new Pompeii housed in the iconic previous downtown DePalmas location exemplifies honoring the…read morespirit of the former stellar and historic restaurant with such friendly and quality service with food that consists of the finest ingredients for an ambiance of style, substance, simplicity and affordability that should contribute to a long life for this new old soul restaurant. The entire staff is exceptional and they all take pride in making their customers feel at home and taken care of with a great meal from lunch, dinner and cocktails at the bar for multiple couples, families and business associates. Wishing them the very best of success!

Good pizza and a friendly staff. The crust is a little thicker than what I typically consider New…read moreYork style, but very good. My only complaints were that drinks are served in bottles and there were no dispensers of cheese and red pepper on the tables. A restaurant this nice should really have a soda fountain. When I asked for Parmesan cheese and pepper, they brought it quickly, but it was in little plastic cups. Those are little details but they distracted from the experience. My guess is that there is probably more takeout and delivery business than dine-in. I'd definitely go back though. The pizza and cheesy bread were both delicious, and the staff was extremely nice and friendly.

If I could give more than five stars I would. The food was delicious but the best part of the…read moreexperience was our waitress, Grace. She was amazing! We had a family get together for my aunts birthday and she went above and beyond to make the evening memorable. Thank you, Grace!!

We had a really nice dining experience visiting their new Normaltown location. They have added a…read morelarge bar area and a rooftop bar. It was too cold and the rooftop was closed but looked nice from the street. We started with some beers served in a cold pint glass. We decided to order a large Greek salad to share along with a 14 inch fully loaded pizza. The salad arrived and it was covered with a lot feta cheese, red onion, olives, peppers, and tomatoes. It was plenty for my wife and I to split. The pizza came out and it was delicious. Thin crust with a lot of great tasting red sauce. It was loaded with meat, veggies, and cheese. Some of the best pizza we have had in Athens. Our server took great care of us throughout the meal.

This place has some really good pizza and a terrific atmosphere! I highly recommend!!read more

Excellent pizza great salads Full bar they take…read morereservations. I recommend a reservation on the weekend.

Some important details…read more The food is really great, and if you're coming for the food, I highly recommend this place. The service, however, isn't great. It seems like a lot of college students working their first service jobs, so they're inexperienced and pretty disorganized. They were also out of so many drinks. Every time we ordered a drink, our waiter would come back and tell us they were out of it. The restaurant is also very loud. Everything echoes off the walls, and we were practically yelling across the table just to understand each other. Overall, if you want good food, definitely try it out! But considering the service, drink availability, and noise level, there's definitely room for improvement.