Best pizza in Lynchburg, we're obsessed 10/10 recommend!! Our favorite is the pepperoni ricottaread more

Three stars. I ordered a takeout 12-inch sourdough meat lovers pizza and a veggie pizza, and…read morehonestly, I was disappointed given the price. The meat lovers pizza had a very low quantity and quality of pepperoni and sausage, which was a huge letdown for a $20+ pizza. Coming from New Jersey, I have high standards for pizza and this just didn't live up to the hype. While the veggie pizza tasted great, paying extra for banana peppers pushed the bill way too high. Spending nearly $50 for two small 12-inch pizzas is simply not worth the money.

The food choices and flavors are excellent! Pretzel bites are a must! Service was pleasant and…read moreserver was well versed on what to suggest. I would give it a 4.5 rating if it were permitted. My ONLY issue was the Caesar salad was heavily doused with anchovies, making it extremely salty and not palatable. Couldn't eat it. Cut back a little on the sodium on some of the dishes, this establishment would be five stars all the way. Would recommend.

Friday night = pizza for us and we love trying different Mellow Mushroom locations…read more Around 530, it was beginning to get full but we secured a table near the kitchen. Having been to a few... and memorizing our previous pizza orders, we only needed to glance at the apps to try something different. I opted for the meatballs and was not impressed. They were warm, at best, and dry. The wing sauce was good but they also were barely warm when they got to the table. The salad is always better with the Esperanza dressing; it's good. Our pizzas were good and hot when they arrived to the table! I'd order the pizzas again and skip the appetizers. Service was standard.

The pepperoni pizza we got was really yummy and was made fresh right in front of us. The crispy and…read morecrunchy crust had to be the best part I stopped eating the pizza halfway through to get the crust first. The service was just as amazing quick and easy with limited interaction, just like I like it. Brent was a little cute too. The walls and the arcade really add to the aesthetic. It reminds me of community togetherness which is what Lynchburg is supposed to be like. Supposed to.

Had the RUDEST server EVER!! Food has also gone downhill! The waitress clearly did not want to be…read morethere. Go to other establishments

Loved the dinner experience and service. Had the pasta du jour and a pasta with white clam sauce…read more Very happy with each and very happy with the quality and size of the side salads. A few days later we tried their pizza to go and didn't care for how thick it was. Thin in the center as expected, but way too thick on the outside. We may just stick with entrees.

I ordered a calzone with meatball, phillycheese steak and ricotta in it,,,When delivered, by the…read moreway cost over $20.00,,,,,, I cut into it and there was barely any cheese, no meatball and a trace of cheese steak,,,,, I was overcharged for a NOTHING CALZONE,,,, do not patronize this place they are thieves

My goooooodnesssss...absolutely the best pizza I've ever had in my entire existence! Simply…read moreincredible! And the owners are so nice and generous! Also, the chocolate cheesecake is amazing as well. Top tier!

Simply amazing pizza! Wonderful family run spot, you definitely want to eat here, great value, the…read morehomemade ranch is incredible!

Good food, lots of it, cooked the way you like it (just ask), friendly staff, hometown atmosphereread more

This is an accumulative review. Out of the last three visits we have been disappointed each time…read more 1st was Philly cheese steak subs. Now we have ordered them for the last 5 years or more and this last time was not great. It was 75%bread and 25 % everything else. Then the chicken parm. Well the chicken was not Italian. No seasoning no garlic it was plain frozen chicken patties deep-fried. What a disappointment. And the pizza. Well I have eaten pizza all my life. And here we special order light cheese pepperoni. The crust was wrong. It was not the usual crust. It was dry and the cheese was overcooked. Couldn't eat it. I have always enjoyed going there but it's not my fav anymore. I am almost tempted to go to Pappa John's next door. I have always supported small business. Let's hope they fix these things for nest time.

I'm new to the area, and have been making it a point to try local restaurants. While I'm…read moredisappointed immensely in the lack of Italian restaurants in the area, I was very pleased with my order from Vinny's. I had the eggplant parm dinner (which is how I personally gage every Italian restaurant I eat at), with a side salad with homemade ranch dressing. I love that it's not Ken's from a giant jar. Nothing beats house made. The eggplant parm was delicious, and the sauce had a nice flavor. I'm from a massive Italian town up north where you can throw a stone in any direction and hit an Italian restaurant or pizza joint, so I'm very particular. I also have a culinary degree, which makes me even pickier. I will absolutely be returning, and can't wait to try other items from the menu.

We ordered takeout. The pizza was the highlight of the meal. The crust had a nice chewiness with a…read moreslight crunch on the outside, and it tasted like house-made dough rather than a pre-made crust. I would order the pizza again. Unfortunately, the chicken Marsala was disappointing. The sauce was very thin and watery, with a large amount of liquid collecting in the bottom of the container instead of coating the pasta and chicken. The mushrooms had a texture and flavor that reminded me of canned mushrooms. While the dish lacked the consistency I typically expect from chicken Marsala, the sauce was still very rich in flavor and savory. Based on this experience, I'd recommend the pizza, but I would skip the Marsala. They gave an accurate estimate of wait time, prices were reasonable, and from what I saw the restaurant was clean. I would also like to acknowledge it was later in the night and they were going to be closing in the next hour, which might have caused a bit of a rush on the food, I'm not really sure.

We absolutely love Vitos pizza! Everything from the pizza, calzone, Stromboli, vito stix, dessert…read morepizza... legit everything is amazing! Al & the ladies are so sweet and give service with a smile every time! They are always very appreciative as well. You cannot go wrong with Vitos! ​​

Excellent fast service and delicious pizza by the slice (plain or pepperoni)! I can honestly say…read morethis might be the best local pizza in Lynchburg (at least my top 2). It reminds me of the local pizza I had around me growing up. It's super cheesy and has perfect crisp and chewy crust. It was hard for me to find out where their locations and hours are, but I think the best bet is following their Facebook page where they sometimes post more info by the week. They did announce a few months ago that there is a brick & mortar location downtown, but I haven't had a chance to see if they are open for business yet. I will gladly be a regular customer!