First off, the destination is absolutely beautiful, hands down. What truly made our trip incredibly…read moresmooth and enjoyable was the hospitality and care we received from Emerald Isle Realty during our stay. They made us feel like family. When we arrived, we were greeted by their welcoming staff and promptly gained access to our rental where we had crisp bedding, a super clean home and a nice welcome bag with everything we need to plan out our days. The property was beautiful and had all the space we needed. The views we had we're so nice too! We've rented from a few other companies in the past in other destinations, but we'll definitely keep using Emerald Isle Realty when we come back to Emerald Isle, NC. The value, hospitality and experience was great, and we're so thankful our trip was as good as it was. Thank you, Emerald Isle Realty!

"As long-time vacationers to this beautiful island, we have always been more than satisfied with…read morethe services that Emerald Isle Realty provided to make our stay the best possible beach vacation. One year, we tried other agencies because of time constraints and availability. However, we returned to E.I. Realty due to the consistency and excellent customer service provided by all the staff. This year, we stayed at Annie's Place for the third summer and have scheduled our next visit. We have never had any issues, and the owners make small improvements yearly. Throughout the years, we've noticed that all of their staff go above and beyond when we've had an issue or general inquiry. EIR has a fabulous website, and the staff is fantastic to work with. It's reassuring to know that some things don't change!"

This is the 6th summer we have stayed at Playtime, and have loved every minute of it. This house…read morehas everything you need for a perfect vacation! We will be returning again next September. The owner goes above and beyond to make sure your stay is wonderful. She is always available for any questions or concerns, and her guy Robert is available 24/7 to see to any household needs. I've stayed many places in the past, but this place is the absolute best I've ever experienced. You will feel like part of the family when you stay here! I guarantee it! Favorites for us were the heated pool, hot tub, pool, beach, pinball machine, theatre room, and LARGE kitchen, with another small one down near the pool. Take my word, you're gonna love it!

We have stayed at Playtime many times and every stay is wonderful. Right on the beach with amazing…read moreviews from the upper and middle deck, lower deck goes to the pool and hot tub and the board walk right to the beach itself. This house has everything to have a good time, rain or shine. Kids love to hang out in the home theatre, game room with pool table and ping pong machine, kitchen with everything you need. House is kept well and lovely decor. I cannot imagine a better place on the beach.

The rental company is completely indifferent to any issues that arise and can affect your vacation…read more We specifically rented a house with a heated pool for the kids to enjoy this year since Sept is historically cooler. Only to get there and the heating pump be BROKEN and never fixed while we were there. We were told "well it worked yesterday when we tested it!" The part never arrived, we were there for a total of 7 days. We had to call each time to check on progress, they didn't even have the decency of communication. We paid a premium for this house BECAUSE it has the option of a heated pool (many do not in this neighborhood, we know because we went to each house that does last year specifically to pick this house for this year), they could not have cared less. No attempts to make it right, no attempts to remedy, just shrugged shoulders that "these things happen." For $8,000 for 1 week, these things should NOT happen or at minimum a pro-rated rate should have been honored. Also, belongings went missing from our driveway moments after their team pulled the trash bin up to the street. At first we gave benefit of the doubt maybe they thought it was trash? Nope, we were told we were the first people to "ever" accuse their team of theft.... so if it wasn't them it could have been the numerous other people using our driveway as a public access to the beach. If you want a fully private house, driveway included, DO NOT RENT WISHING WHALE. All the houses from the cul-de-sac used OUR driveway to access the beach the ENTIRE week. Not one day went by that a stranger wasn't strolling down our driveway to cut through to the next door house's beach access. Either way, feels like a rental/community issue as we leave things outside every single year, and never ever had anything stolen from us. This is the first year we've had strangers meandering in our driveway. Seems suspicious. We thought this was a safe community. At other homes we used to leave the doors unlocked during the day for ease of the family, NOT AT THIS HOUSE, NOT WITH A BABY SLEEPING INSIDE AND STRANGERS ACCESSING OUR DRIVEWAY ALL DAY. We will be returning to EI Realty where they actually care about their renters and ensure our vacation and money is very well spent. It's a shame, we had a great 6 summer run with Spinnakers and would have had 30 more. But the bad taste in our mouth has us wanting nothing to do with this entire community. Such a shame because the homes and neighborhood are absolutely beautiful, tucked away in our favorite part of the island. But you are only as good as the company who represents you. Shame on you Mathias and shame on you SR.

BEWARE!!!! We stayed at Isle Getaway for the last 5 years…read more No issues. BUT. This year we arrive and find that the owner had put limits on the AC..and NO ONE had notified us, communicated with us.. NOTHING.! I thought I rented the Entire beach house ! Not just parts of it! ! We were stunned! This is a 4 story Beach house ,with 3 BR on the the 3 Rd floor! After a very hot, distressing night with very little sleep for all ,after the owner had " fixed" the controls . I had to go BACK to office the next morning ,to BEG Spinnaker's Reach and owner to help again. It was awful ! How did this happen that NO ONE spoke to me about this!????? BEFORE WE GOT TO THE HOUSE! We always been good guests. We do not leave the doors open. And I have gotten my deposit back each year! Like I said we have rented the same house for the Last years without AC controls!!!? The SR people did reach out to the owner again. And offered a portable AC unit for the bedroom that was the warmest. It has always been warmer than the rest of BR on the 3 floor! But what good would that have been for the rest of my guests? He did take off the all the controls the next morning ,! BUT I have been informed that next year!!! Temps only going down to 70?!? AT NIGHT!! . Be very AWARE. that this is happening

Very nice cottage near the beach and sound in a very nice community and very nice accommodations…read more If you are a family of 6-8 this is the perfect cottage for you. I would definitely recommend this cottage for you. If you have stay here I hope you will leave a review or any recommendations

Very beautiful home, lots of stairs so make sure you enjoy cardio. It's on the beach with a private…read morewalk way which we LOVED. The only issue is there's a musty smell in the upstairs spare room so we didn't end up using it. The master bath had a bunch of silverfish come out when we turned it on so we decided not to use it. There were ants in the kitchen but after I mopped the first day I tried to keep them at bay. This didn't ruin the vacation I just think the storm did its number and that was a few of them for this home.

This is a Mold House! Due to negligent and deferred…read moremaintenance of this beautiful rental, mold grows abundantly. When we checked in I noticed the musty smell throughout but especially the top floor and lower level. During our stay, the air conditioning malfunctioned that supplied the top floor. Waited on maintenance for a long while to arrive for repair. Repairman arrived, said a line was clogged, said he cleared the line and left. Hours later, we noticed water coming from the ceiling on the top floor bathroom. Draining from the sheetrock, vent and lighting, running down the hallway sheetrock into the middle floor. The same repairman arrived again, said the sump pump malfunctioned, repaired it and left. Without notice, another repairman arrived who was actually an HVAC certified technician, who without his shirt on went into the house to check on the HVAC system. He said he made the necessary repairs and all was well with the system. While he was in the attic space working, I stayed nearby as he was working. So I got a birds eye view of the great amounts of black mold in the attic space. Mold on every surface within the attic space. It made me quite anxious and nervous for my adult children and grandchildren to sleep on the top floor, breathing the mycotoxins mold produces. No offer was made by Bluewater to relocate us, much less any sort of mold abatement done. No dehumidifiers, no fans. NOTHING! Furthermore, the kitchen cabinets are falling apart, the kitchen faucet is broken and leaks, the middle floor queen bath faucet is broken and the cabinet under the sink was very wet inside. The gutters are full, even have vegetation growing from them, a gutter was loose and beat against the house during wind, and raised nails on the decking are a danger for bare feet. Also, the rugs and carpeting are covered in pet urine stains. We paid nearly 15k for our family to vacation here for a week. It was no vacation. I spent many hours of my valuable family time dealing with the terrible maintenance of this house and awaiting maintenance to arrive, countless hours concerned for my families safety and the countless others who would stay in this hose after us. Bluewater Rental made no concessions to our family, Bluewater made no efforts towards mold remediation, nor did they even take note of all the issues I signaled regarding this rental property. I asked would they notify the owners and future quests. I got no response. Bluewater Realty is very poorly managed. Sea No Evil will make your family sick. Sure made my grandchildren sick. Sure caused me to have the worst vacation I've experienced in my 53 years. Oh! Also mold in the garage that's used as a rec/play room. Avoid Sea No Evil at all cost!

We were the first family to stay at this house. Can't complain with a new house. Great location…read moreon the sound side with a long dock for the kids to fish from. Dick is also a good spot to catch a gorgeous sunset.

We have rented the Jolly Fisherman and the Shell Seekers both with great results. Don't get me…read morewrong things happen but I didn't have any problem with the company taking care of it. Our family is coming back for the 2026 season with every expectation of great property.

Very poorly maintained, house was completely filthy, and had not been cleaned upon arriving,…read morehousekeeping, after being called did come and clean, but nothing under any object has been cleaned for years, I am totally shocked at how nasty they keep their property, maintenance in the house was very poorly kept also, would not recommend staying with this rental company

Not worth $3800/week!! The door handles are falling off in the bathroom and master bedroom. Water…read moredamage on walls after Hurricane Florence has not been repaired, as evidenced by paint peeling off in multiple locations through the the house. Sparsely decorated, tiny television screens, mediocre dishes and cooking utensils, and less than average appliances. Outdoor furniture is old and rusty - leaves a lot to be desired. Mattresses and linens are below average quality. Charcoal grill does not have a cover and it is filthy dirty. Not worth spending more than a month's mortgage payment to come here.