Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    3.4 (5 reviews)
    InexpensivePizza
    Open 5:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    8 months ago

    There food and gas is the only thing that is worth getting there. The car Wash is never open ever.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    their taco pizza is amazing to say the least & everyone needs to try it- don't forget the sauce too!! i can't talk this pizza up enough

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mary P.
    55
    32
    9

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 1,444 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Mama T’s Italian Eatery - Italian Beef - lunch portion - $7.49 - outstanding.

    Mama T’s Italian Eatery

    4.6(69 reviews)
    0.2 mi

    Mama T's is an unexpected delight! Located in a strip mall across from the High School, you would…read morethink it wouldn't be worth visiting. But trust me. It's definitely worth it! All their food is delicious but their thick pan pizza is AMAZING! It takes 30 minutes to cook and just melts in your mouth. Their Ho Ho cake is also fantastic! Baked on Monday, it usually sells out by Thursday evening. You need to go!

    Suzanne was our server tonight. Very knowledgeable about…read moremenu and specials. We decided on tonight's special which was Chicken Tetrazzini. There's made with fettuccine topped with a cream sauce made with honey Dijon and wine. It came with either a grilled or breaded chicken, and we both chose the grilled chicken. The grilled chicken was cooked to perfection in season perfectly. Tender chicken breast meat, which was moist. The cream size was made to perfection and very tasty. You could actually taste the honey Dijon and wine in the cream sauce. Nice and thick and tasty. We also decided to try a bowl of their homemade chili. Mama T's does not hold back on the meat! There was plenty of ground beef in their chili with lots of beans and a sauce was thick and not runny like many places make it. It was seasoned spicy, but not over spiced. For me it was perfect. We also had the breaded mushrooms as an appetizer, and I will tell you that their breaded mushrooms are nice size and moist with a nice breaded coating over them deep-fried to perfection. I have these breaded mushrooms every time I eat there. Our waitress Suzanne recommended the specials to us and we are glad that she did. They are very good waitresses at Mama T's. Prices for the meals is comparable to going to places like Olive Garden and other Italian restaurants. Portion size are more than adequate and you'll definitely not leave hungry. The restaurant is very clean and very appealing to the eye.

    Photos
    Mama T’s Italian Eatery - Christmas decorations are up!

    Christmas decorations are up!

    Mama T’s Italian Eatery - Chicago style pizza!

    Chicago style pizza!

    Mama T’s Italian Eatery - Hours are Tues-Sat 4-9.  Not open for lunch...

    See all

    Hours are Tues-Sat 4-9. Not open for lunch...

    Holi Cannoli

    Holi Cannoli

    3.9(217 reviews)
    5.5 mi
    $$

    We visited for the first time yesterday, after driving by many times previously. The parking lot…read morewas packed, so we weren't sure if we would be able to be seated spur of the moment. Thankfully, we were seated right away. We were served water and a wonderful tray of bread and focaccia with marinara -- everything was delicious, especially the sauce. (OMG!) We explained to the waitress that we wanted to also order an entree to go, and asked for the best timing to do so. Our waitress remembered this and returned at the perfect time to take that order -- rigatoni with marinara and meatballs. We had a 30 mile trip home and the dish was still warm when we arrived! It did take a while for our food to arrive. We were a little concerned because we did not want to drive home in the dark. Our food was very good when it arrived -- the Chicken Vesuvio was amazing, and the leftovers are even better today. Our family member liked the Alfredo, but thought it was a little watery. We were too full for dessert, but carried out a tiramisu. This was also delicious. The dining areas are Italian styled supper club. We were seated to the left of the bar. It looked like the dining area to the right of the bar was a little nicer, but again, we did not have reservations. We were appreciative of the table we were given. Some updates are needed, but we were comfortable. The service was amazing. The host/hostess was friendly and welcoming. The waitress was terrific. The bus boys deserve a special mention -- they were back and forth with water multiple times, and one even offered additional bread to soak up the Alfredo sauce. They were humorous and kind and for being so young, they were very professional--said how much fun it was to work there. (They deserve some special kudos!) Overall, this was a wonderful stop. We'll be back and will try other dishes. We hear that the vodka sauce is also amazing.

    Best Italian food in Southeast Wi. Service is also superb!!!!!!!!…read moreKeep going back for more.

    Photos
    Holi Cannoli - Entryway with beautiful planters

    Entryway with beautiful planters

    Holi Cannoli
    Holi Cannoli - Grilled Octopus

    See all

    Grilled Octopus

    Station 20 Pub 'N Grub - Burger with House Chips and French Onion Dip

    Station 20 Pub 'N Grub

    3.6(8 reviews)
    0.5 mi

    Stopped in on a Sunday, right as the Packers started to play. The bar was mostly full but all the…read moretables were still empty. I ordered a beer at the bar with the friendly bartender while I perused the menu at a table. I decided on their traditional bone in wings, 12 for $16.49, split between their applewood dry rub and their honey bbq dry rub. At over $1.37 per wing, I had high hopes these pricey wings would be worth the cost. And then this is where things went quickly downhill. The kitchen in this bar is small and they do orders one at a time, no batches. I had no idea that when I ordered there were multiple large carry out/door dash orders ahead of me, which meant I had to wait over an hour for my order of wings. Thankfully I had time to waste while watching the game, but no order of wings should take that long, especially without being told about the extraordinarily long wait when I ordered. I will say, once my order arrived, they redeemed theirselves. The wings were large, perfectly fried (tender, juicy and not one bit over cooked) and they were tossed evenly in the flavorful and unique dry rubs. Absolutely no complaints, just pure satisfaction. Okay, okay, they are still pricey, but if it wasn't for that long wait I wouldn't have been bothered by the final check. Station 20, please work on those wait times or find a way to handle in-store orders separately from your door dashers. Solve that issue and you would one of my top wing destinations.

    This place is absolutely slept on in the Lake Geneva area! They have great deals on bloody marys,…read morepizza, beer...the list goes on! I had a Ruben and shared a pepperoni pizza. Everything was greasy goodness and made to perfection. Also, I LOVED that the bloodies came with olives stuffed with little pickles. Our server was also the bartender and she was extremely attentive, friendly, and quick. Also, the atmosphere was what you'd expect from a good dive. I'll be back!

    Photos
    Station 20 Pub 'N Grub
    Station 20 Pub 'N Grub - House Made Pizza

    House Made Pizza

    Station 20 Pub 'N Grub - Front of Restaurant

    See all

    Front of Restaurant

    Casey's - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...