Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    3.5 (2 reviews)
    Open Open 24 hours

    Casey's Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Chris O.
    82
    85
    37

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 978 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Shake Shack - Ice cream and sundaes!

    The Shake Shack

    4.6(48 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $

    Great food and service! I like the banana split it's a meal in itself. Sandwiches are good also!read more

    This is THE Shake Shack, not the Shake Shack restaurant chain…read more Emily and I made plans to visit Analytical Brewing based on a shirt we saw at Evergreen Farm Brewing. While looking for things to do in Lexington, I found that there isn't much due to it being a small town. BUT, there is an ice cream shack right next to the brewery and that was the perfect spot to get some food before putting down a few beers. We pulled up and walked around to the ordering window outside. There was a lady in front of us which gave us time to figure out what we wanted. Emily settled on a philly steak sandwich and I got the buffalo chicken sandwich. We took a seat at one of the tables and waited for our food. There is an indoor seating area and I did go check it out since we had time to kill. I took a glance in and liked what I saw. It had a very diner-esque feel inside. I didn't do more than stick my head in and look around due to the only people inside were some teenage girls. It didn't take too long for the food to come out. Emily and I took our food and headed next door to try and eat it inside the brewery. The bartender said it was a-okay to eat inside. Funny enough, once we sat down, we say a sign on the table that said you can order from your table and it'll either be brought over from The Shake Shack or you can go grab it real quick. We were both starving and we dug in real quick (while sipping our beers, but that post comes next). The buffalo chicken sandwich was delicious! It wasn't too hot or too spicy, which was a bit of a bummer but the flavor and heavy butter flavor in the bun was just what I needed. Emily said her philly steak (minus onions) was possibly the best thing she's ever had... either because she was famished or it was just that good. So, the food is great! At least what we had. How was their ice cream offerings? Funnily, we didn't get any. The idea sounded good after we were done at the brewery but in reality... we were just ready to head home and unwind from everything. The desire was there at least! I have no doubt that if their ice cream is as good as their food, you are in for a treat. If I go back and get their ice cream, I will add a comment in here on how it was. Also, I didn't really get any good photos here so it would be nice to go back and get some better ones.

    Photos
    The Shake Shack
    The Shake Shack - Hand-breaded tenderloin sandwich.  Good, a little dry maybe, some mayo might have been nice. I'm not an expert on them, however.

    Hand-breaded tenderloin sandwich. Good, a little dry maybe, some mayo might have been nice. I'm not an expert on them, however.

    The Shake Shack

    See all

    Filippo's Pizza & Italian Food - Cannelloni with Meatballs

    Filippo's Pizza & Italian Food

    3.8(31 reviews)
    44.6 mi
    $$

    The food is delicious! Unlike a certain pizza chain restaurant nearby, the pizza crust tastes and…read moresmells like fresh baked bread. We also like the house salad and the lasagna is wonderful. I can't wait to go back.

    Make sure and read all of the negative reviews. They are probably the most objective and they hit…read moreall the highlights. Disclaimer: this visit was on Mother's Day so we understood that it would be crowded with longer wait time. First time in restaurant. The tables are packed claustrophobic tight. Or table was smack up against the side of the salad bar. I was afraid my hair would get in the lettuce. Every time someone walked past our table they bumped into the chairs. Payment is No cards, cash/check only and this info is NOT published anywhere but on a notecard taped to the cash register which was blocked from view as we were seated. Not on the door, not on the website. I see it's here in the comments on Yelp, but I had poor signal and didn't do a review search, just looked at the website. Poor treatment by owners - attitude was not "I'm sorry for your poor experience" but "I'm sorry you're complaining, get lost." Carry out orders and friends and locals seemed to receive priority service. Mediocre, overpriced food. "Baked" pasta dish was runny, mozzarella barely melted, meat sauce with barely any meat, way too sweet. Garlic bread with very little garlic. Pizza crust was hard, flavorless, over cooked on edges. Sauce (to me) has a weird chemical-like taste. Toppings were not fresh, mushrooms were canned, pizza was under cooked in the middle. Wait time - it was one hour until someone told us it was ready to come out in a couple of minutes..... then it actually was another 30 minutes or more later, during which the waiter avoided us like the plague until we flagged him down and asked when our food would be out, then another ten minutes after that. After reading reviews, it would seem that the time deception is a sanctioned tactic. Finally, after going to the car, retrieving an old checkbook, and writing a check with a generous tip in spite of the deficiencies, we politely expressed that they should publish their payment policy and how wait time was misrepresented. Received a very curt response. Left an honest comment on the community fb page and was threatened, cursed, and called every name in the book by most of the friendly "locals." But hey, social media, right? The rudeness on a busy day could have been easier to forgive if everything else had been five star, but the food really isn't worth the price and the wait. And jeez, Monticello....I'm afraid to drive through town, much less eat at this restaurant again.

    Photos
    Filippo's Pizza & Italian Food - Filippo's Pizza

    Filippo's Pizza

    Filippo's Pizza & Italian Food
    Filippo's Pizza & Italian Food - A (half eaten XD ) bacon and garlic large pizza.

    See all

    A (half eaten XD ) bacon and garlic large pizza.

    Flingers Pizza Pub - Flingers Profile Pic

    Flingers Pizza Pub

    4.3(288 reviews)
    12.7 mi
    $$

    The service was great and so was the food! They have all kids of specially drinks…read more It's a cozy atmosphere. We would recommend!

    This was our first visit to Flingers. We chose it based on the reviews and pictures. We visited on…read morea Tuesday night. No wait time. We decided to sit outside on the patio, because it was a beautiful evening. We started with drinks and the cheese bread with marinara for the appetizer. We later placed a food order and decided to try a variety of things since it was our first time. We ordered pepperoni rolls, a thin crust create your own pizza with pepperoni, onion, and bell peppers, and a hand tossed Italian beef pizza. After a significant amount of time the waitress returned to check on us and let us know the pizzas would be out soon, so we asked her about the appetizer. She admitted that she forgot to put it in. She asked if we still wanted it, which we did, and so she said it would be 8 minutes in the oven. The food all came out within the next 10 minutes or so (minus the appetizer), and we dove in. It was all very good and we were happy with the options we chose. The waitress returned once we were finished eating and we asked for boxes and the check. The appetizer still hadn't came out. She apologized again and asked if we just wanted it boxed up to go, to which we said yes. Several minutes later a manager showed up and told us again, that there was a miscommunication and the appetizer was never made and yet to be placed in the oven. At this point, we asked it to be canceled and just asked for boxes and the check. Things happen, and the way they responded to the mistake is the reason I am still giving them 4 stars. They reduced our bill significantly and offered us a coupon for a free pizza on the next visit as a way to make things right. The waitress was great and the manager was very professional. We will give them another try next time we are in town.

    Photos
    Flingers Pizza Pub - Flingers Menu as of April 2026. Flingers is located in Bloomington-Normal Illinois and is the top rates Pizza place, Restaurant and Bar.

    Flingers Menu as of April 2026. Flingers is located in Bloomington-Normal Illinois and is the top rates Pizza place, Restaurant and Bar.

    Flingers Pizza Pub - Appetizer Menu for Flingers Pizza Pub in Bloomington-Normal, Illinois.

    Appetizer Menu for Flingers Pizza Pub in Bloomington-Normal, Illinois.

    Flingers Pizza Pub - Salad Menu for Flingers Pizza Pub in Bloomington-Normal, Illinois.

    See all

    Salad Menu for Flingers Pizza Pub in Bloomington-Normal, Illinois.

    Casey's - pizza - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...