Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    2.0 (3 reviews)
    Open Open 24 hours

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Casey G.

    Casey G.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 544 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Rosati's Pizza

    Rosati's Pizza

    2.9(36 reviews)
    3.0 mi
    $

    Visiting Sandwich and stopped in to get a couple of beef sandwiches. I ordered mine with the…read moregardiniera and jalopenos. My wife ordered just with the gardiniera. Sandwiches were very good. The bread was okay but nothing like Portillo's or one of the regular Italian Beef sandwiches in Chicago. I've had their pizzas and salads which are very good.

    TJ Banning (the owner of this location along with others) gave no one a notice that everyone at the…read moreMendota location would be be losing their jobs. People had come into work and started to prep for their shift when they were sent home and told that the business is closed. Instead of having a meeting and informing staff members, he decided to make a Facebook post telling everyone he'd be mailing their checks. Then a post was immediately made to the public and then turned off comments on their post and deleted all negative ones that made them look bad. Since it's strictly a financial decision that affected many people's livelihood, I'm asking that you reconsider giving this average tasting and over priced pizza restaurant your money. He struggled since Covid and couldn't financially recover so instead of communicating that with anyone in the Mendota location he closed without notice. In this economy he left countless families unable to know where their source of income was going to come from to be able to pay their bills. UNPROFESSIONAL. Again, since it's strictly financial, give your money to a pizza/pasta place that appreciates their staff and actually has quality food within the right price range, because this one isn't worth it.

    Photos
    Rosati's Pizza
    Rosati's Pizza
    Rosati's Pizza

    See all

    Bull Moose Bar & Grille - Bison burgers have to be cooked a little rare to keep the meat moist. Delicious.

    Bull Moose Bar & Grille

    3.7(203 reviews)
    2.5 mi
    $$

    Ok, this place is a FOR SURE hidden gem! They hand make their chicken strips.....that should say it…read moreall. The kids menu has fresh handmade strips that taste AMAZING! Rice flour so they are light with a perfect crisp. The salads are AWESOME, their chipotle ranch is next level, and the blackened chicken is outstanding! We went once for the first time and have been back like 3 times in 2 weeks. The prices are great, foods even better and the service matches the taste... If you're traveling through sandwich - this is a great choice! The only negative is the parking. There's not really anywhere to park. We've lucked out and the one spot in front of has been open a few times we went, you might have to park across the street. Just a right corner - but worth the walk.

    Classic place located in Sandwich to get burgers. It has a certain charm about it. Bull Moose Bar &…read moreGrill is known for having a trolley car in front. Gets pretty busy especially at happy hour. The menu is meaty but there's a few plant based things. Best thing about it is the atmosphere. It's actually not even that great. The trolley car is what people like about it. A cool place to eat. Especially if one likes trains. A lot of great specials to get. It's $3.50 wells on Wednesdays. A lot of meaty things to get. It's about $12 for the Build Your Own Burger option. We got it with the Beyond Burger patty. Comes with a choice of side and we got the kettle chips. This was a pretty big ass meal and we got stuffed. For sure it's the most famous restaurant in town but there's not a whole lot great around here. It's located at Main and Church Street. The menu is meaty but the Beyond Burger is the option for vegetarians.

    Photos
    Bull Moose Bar & Grille - The old Pullman Palace

    The old Pullman Palace

    Bull Moose Bar & Grille - Bison burgers from a local farm.

    Bison burgers from a local farm.

    Bull Moose Bar & Grille

    See all

    Casey's General Store - You can custom build your pizza online. Go for the works. Tomato chunks are added after it's cooked.

    Casey's General Store

    1.6(5 reviews)
    3.1 mi

    Who'd of thunk you can find a tasty pizza at a gas station? Their General Store is renowned for…read moretheir taco pizza... I've been told it prevents a hangover. Since it's national pizza with the works except anchovies day, I went with a tasty supreme pizza. I added spicy sausage, bacon, jalapenos and tomato. The "Hungry Haus Works" is only available at Casey's. They make lots of other sandwiches too. Check out their website.

    Actually would give them a zero stars if possible. Will never order delivery from the Casey's in…read moreSandwich again. Placed an order for delivery last night, waited way longer than any pizza should take, and called only to have them tell us it was delivered. We didn't know where it was delivered but it wasn't our house. We told Casey's no it wasn't whereupon they said then it's a Doordash problem call them. Ok when we called CASEY'S and asked for delivery and paid CASEY'S for the pizza AND delivery, there was no mention of Doordash. We assumed as with Rosati's Casey's has their own delivery drivers, but even so since we are in no way involved in who does the delivery it is still a CASEY'S problem. I posted on our community FB page to ask if anyone rec'd a pizza they didn't order and about 30 minutes later our neighbors who only noticed because they were just arriving home found our pizza in the box laying on their porch and delivered it to us. I should also mention due to appointments we had during the day neither of us had eaten anything, making it even worse that the pizza was lost. So just a warning CASEY'S takes no responsibility for their contracted delivery people from door dash.

    Photos
    Casey's General Store - Build your own online.

    Build your own online.

    Casey's General Store - Can't miss it...

    Can't miss it...

    Casey's General Store - Taco Pizza prevents a hangover.

    See all

    Taco Pizza prevents a hangover.

    Route 34 Pub & Grub - Whiskey And The Pretzel Bites

    Route 34 Pub & Grub

    2.8(9 reviews)
    3.4 mi
    $$

    Had an okay time at this bar in Sandwich known for billiards. It certainly gets packed with people…read moreplaying or just hanging out. Route 34 Pub is one of the few places to go around here so there's hardly anywhere to sit or even stand. A lot harder to even get any bartender's attention. There's plenty of TVs for those watching games instead of playing. Coming in here it was going to be hard to find a seat anywhere. It's got a bar in the middle. This is surrounded by tons of pool tables. A few places for sitting around there but these were also crowded. Luckily there were a couple seats at the bar so we got to sit there. A lot of beers in bottles and cans. It's about $5 to get the cheapest cocktails like well whiskey. Food menu is pretty basic. Mostly it's typical fried stuff. It's about $9 to get the Pretzel Bites. These come with a choice of cheese or marinara. Seems as if the sauce is the best part of it. There's also tacos. Got to say if you like pool you should check it out and see the chaos. It's got a kitchen that's open later. This is located next to the Chinese restaurant where the food is even worse.

    We order the wings today on Sunday when the football game was on. We all ate one and just wanted to…read moreget out of there. When we got home we all weren't feeling good. I went to eat some of the left overs then noticed all of them had alot of hair cooked into them. I've never seen something soo gross in my life. It was only on all the bottom ones. So I didn't see it when we were there. It was soo much hair that its hard to believe this was an Accident!! Thinking about calling the health department. GROSS

    Photos
    Route 34 Pub & Grub
    Route 34 Pub & Grub - Grand Opening!!

    Grand Opening!!

    Route 34 Pub & Grub

    See all

    Casey's - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...