5 stars because of the food and old pub vibes. Been coming for decades and cant believe I am just…read morewriting about it now. Location: Main Street Newmarket Parking: there's a tonne of parking (free) in the area. The best part is, if you park in the lot behind the pub you can go in through the backdoor. Inside: There are booths and tables. There are two long tables i. The middle with raised seats. You can also sit in the windows and people watch. This is the type of place that looks like it has not been updated in our lifetime. They put their money into keeping the food and drink tasty. Im cool with that. Staff: Everyone I've ever has serve us has been so nice. Food: I think the food is terrific period the last time I went. I had the grilled cheese with chicken. It was delicious and I am so glad that I got it. But everything here is delicious for everything I've ever gotten. And I think i've eaten a lot of things from the menu.it's not a pretty place to hang out. But for foodies, it's a good food place

Decent food for a pub! Pleasantly surprised. Great staff!! Would definitely recommend.read more

I do love cute little pubs with good food and this place fits the bill. I can't find any photos as…read moreit has been a while since we've been but would like to to back soon. Service is fast and everyone is super friendly. Get the Ruben sandwich! Holy sandwich, one of the best I've ever had. Trust me on this one. And for dessert the sticky toffee pudding. Yum x100000000 Can't wait to go back!

Just picked up take out, ordered lamb stew. And I get that inflation is high, but all we got for a…read more$25 price tag was a tiny cup of stew and another tiny cup of mash. We called and asked that it was supposed to come with garlic toast (as per menu) and we were told it doesn't. Horrible value for money

This place.. was not it. Much smaller than it looks on the outside. They have an okay drink…read moreselection and good prices, and the fact it's been around forever makes it a cool stop at least once. Lots of soccer memorabilia, too, if you're into that. But, overall, not a place I'd return to.

Grey Goat Pub & Grill is Newmarket's oldest pub!…read more Though it is the oldest pub the interior sure is amazing new and chic. Bistro like and homey. Though small in size but not too busy even during Super Bowl. Service is excellent and friendly. Great selection of beers and a decent pub menu. $5.50 for a pint of Grenville Island is definitely A-OK!! I am even glad that it is available on tap. Chicken Wings ($12.00) was great for sharing... A great choice to watch a game or just to chill with your friends!

Oh I came on cheese burger day (wed) ha awesome..gravy on fries...woo the bomb.cheap beers…read moretoo.bartendress great

Great spot! Very good! I would definitely order from them again! The portions are just right. You…read moremight even have a little leftover!

The service is friendly. The food tastes great and is affordable. The highlight though is their…read more"perfectionass". When I received my order, I thought to myself what an ass!!!! I then reviewed the menu, and sure enough, it was cooked to "perfectionass". A knight's arms pub and grill specialty.

Came here again since it's walking distance from home. It's…read moreFriday and this time promptly seated and order taken. Ordered chicken and shrimp pad Thai $19 and Santa Fe burger with $17. Knew it was a mistake to order pad Thai at a pub, and I wasn't wrong. It's so sweet and drenched with some sort of ketchup flavor. Wish there's more shrimp too there was only 3. Chose Santa Fe burger because wanted avocado but there's no avocado, the deep fried thing was a pickle. But otherwise the burger was juicy.

Have been a few times and is always good. Went on a…read moreWednesday. We were greeted immediately when we walked in, very friendly, and got a table right away. It was busy for a Wednesday. It's a little loud but in a good way, lively atmosphere. It was wing night, $15 for wings and fries. Very good portion size. Our waitress was great as well. Nice little pub. Would definitely recommend to give a try.

I am not sure why this place doesn't have more stars. The food here is AWESOME. Great beer…read moreselection as well as great cocktails. They did a seasonal cocktail that was delicious. This is a go to place for me. I would highly reccomend the pies as they make them in house and they are fantastic. The mac and cheese and the yorkies with beef was sooo good as well. That beef just melts in your mouth, as beef should. Shout out to our awesome server (I forget her name!) But she has blonde hair and tattoos and is so attentive, friendly, and just overall great! Great pub.

After the show you can shoe your movie receiot for 10% off your meal, very thoughtful service, with…read morea small establishment with Irish vibes! A Killkinney and wood oven ouzza is all yiu need for a goid time have fun! -Zuk

We visited this place for a light dinner and when we arrived around 6pm , I guess it's still early…read moreso not too many ppl. Therefore I didn't need to wait too long for my food as other reviewer mentioned. We ordered the onion soup. The cheese on top is not toasty at all as shown from my pic but despite that, it's a really good tasty onion soup!! It's very hot (temperature hot) which is a must for me for onion soup! And also Very flavourful bowl of soup with real food taste. I am surprised how good it is! Way better than the Keg one! If they toast the cheese on top longer and make it more toasty, it would have been a Perfect bowl of onion soup and would be one of the best one in TO!!! We also ordered the burger with wedges. The patty is nice and thick and not dry! I do like the burger. But the wedges, it's subpar unfortunately, abit too burnt and dry... Brussels sprout is ok, nothing particular standout but not a bad dish either! I need fibre in my diet anyway so this is perfect.. lol... All in all, this experience is a positive one and I will come back for the onion soup again for sure !! I give it a 4 stars mostly because of the yummy onion soup!

I saw a review from 2 years ago saying about Machia. This was very in accurate and wrong. Not sure…read morewhere that review came from, but Marchia, as well as Amber, Chris and Kayla, are extremely professional and very friendly and anytime you go, you'll have a great experience. Thanks

Awesome burger and onion rings. My wife enjoyed her meal too. Service was wonderful. We will going…read moreback.

This wings joint & bar engages in false advertising & gets 1.5 stars. On the menu, a poster on the…read moredoor & website various offers are advertised but when I tried to order the ribs & wings special, I was told it was no longer available - they only offer the Tuesday wings deal now. False advertising is one thing, but the food & service are also questionable. They also have some Indian dishes so since the ribs & wings deal was not available, I ordered lamb rolls but only after I'd paid was I told it was not available & cheaper starters were offered to replace it. A proactive refund of the difference was not offered: I had to ask. And I got the pre-tax difference back, so I was overcharged. Ordered chicken samosas. The inside of the first was still ice cold. I returned & complained about this & the guy refried the other 3 & dumped the half eaten samosa without giving me a new one. This aside they tasted OK & there was little chicken in them - they were mostly potato. Got the yellow chicken with naan. The naan was uninspired - it tasted like it'd just been warmed up in the microwave. The yellow chicken tasted so-so. It was not very yellow & was a rasam (thin) not a curry (thicker). The naan didn't go with it (naan goes more with thicker curries) & there was no rice option.

First time here. Vibe is great. Food is amazing. Burgers are homemade and fresh. Wing sauce…read moreselection is enormous. Plenty of booze and tons of food choices. Can't go wrong here.