Stayed in the Gala suite at the Cider Mill Inn on a recent getaway to Pine Island, NY. Very beautiful victorian B&B decorated with period antiques but has all the modern amenities a traveller would desire including wi-fi, cable, A/C, fireplace, plush terry robes and also a hot tub and pool. A front porch is available to relax and enjoy the country fresh air. And it wouldn't be a B&B w/o the breakfast so for you foodies out there the food is absolutely delicious which included fluffy pancakes, bacon, fruit, oatmeal and the fresh made scones by your host are to die for! If you want to stay in a quiet, quaint B&B with friendly hosts surrounded by nature this is the place. read more

Just back from our stay here and happy to report the place is as good as others say. Great location, VERY friendly inn keeper and lovely, seasoned rooms. The building was erected in 1865. If you like history, this place is your thing. Historical, BUT with all the modern appointments that made our stay comfortable and pleasant. Proprietor Bob is a friendly man with all the right stuff to be a host. The property and rooms are immaculate, everything works and there are some nice amenities including a huge swimming pool, 24/7 coffee and tea, microwave and fridge upstairs and AC in every room, plus ceiling fans and Wifi. Lovely decor too and the little things like scented towels and delightful shower cosmetics. plus hot, hot water, good water pressure in the shower, and thick terry robes in each room make this a cozy sport to hang your hat after a busy day out exploring the environs. Breakfast was fresh, hot and delicious and Bob was flexible with creating offerings based on our preferences. We did not leave for 90 minutes after check out because we spent the time chatting with Bob, he is that personable. We have spent much time at B&Bs here and in Europe. this place gets five stars! Spacious rooms · Thoughtful amenities · Quiet rooms read more

See all

Cozy Bed & Breakfast in a beautiful 1860's Victorian home. Bob is an amazing host. He is very accommodating and extremely knowledgeable about the area. My husband and I have been coming here every October since we had gotten married in 2020. The breakfasts that Bob cooks are always delicious. The best part is that you can select a time with Bob as to when you'd like to have breakfast, in case you were planning on sleeping in. The rooms have a very elegant and comfortable feel. The experience alone makes it our go to getaway when we need a break from the city. Smack in the middle of the Hudson Valley, it's surrounded by farms, trails, restaurants, and shops, so there's always something to do. read more

Nice sized room, thick and soft towels. Quiet location. Owner was flexible on breakfast time my first morning. Appreciated the complimentary water and soda. Was not impressed with the breakfasts, bed and pillows uncomfortable. Shower head gross, cords/outlets seemed unsafe. Outside landscaping needs attention. read more

See all

Amazing B&B, Bob is super cool guy, very welcoming and respectful of his guests propertey while being vwry attentative to their needs. The home is extremely clean, the pool is very nice and convienet to get to. The home is close to shops and major roads. Bob is an incredible chef, we had an amazing breakfast and simply an amazing experience, thanks Bob for being such a great host, wishing you and family the best!! read more

This is now my new favorite bed and breakfast. My husband and I went here to go to Warwick winery (very close by) and celebrate our anniversary. (Which I also highly recommend what a great winery!) The grounds of this home are beautiful! The bed is so comfortable! We woke up in the morning to a beautiful breakfast home made scones (still hot) coffee, poched pear, oatmeal with chai and then hash-browns frittata and sausage ... breakfast was an hour long and so delicious & enjoyable.. we can't wait to return ! They have a fridge with waters and soda (some light refreshments) no extra charge, I thought that was great. We went to Warwick winery (4miles away) we arrived to the bed and breakfast early, they allowed us to drop our things and check in later. There is so much do to in Warwick, I'm looking up upcoming events to go back! Oh! And they have WiFi! Very important service is limited in the area (we needed it to call cabs and look up events)! That was a great plus This place had all the nice little extras and amazing breakfast ... which made this our favorite bed and breakfast ... highly recommend ! Lastly the hosts were so nice and pleasant, great to talk to and appreciated his warm welcome ! read more

See all

Delightful host and wife, Bob and Clara (Bunny), ready to help in any way. Delightful home from 1880's has plenty of character. A/c unit in each bedroom, and teenie private bathroom. Perfect for 3 nights of exploring Warwick and JW world headquarters. read more

See all

Cider Mill Inn lived up to our expectations. Bob hosted us from beginning until the end of our stay. He was extremely pleasant and knowledgeable about the area, and it's events. We stayed in the Braeburn room. It was cozy and we had our own bathroom. The hallway was quite throughout the night. Also, I was impressed with breakfast. Bob provided a delicious breakfast in the dinning room were we briefly met another couple staying at the B&B. Bob served each dish straight from the kitchen. Parking was sufficient for our rental sedan and the area was extremely safe in the evening. Thank you Bob. See you next time. read more

YES!!! First Review!!! Frankly I'm surprised - you should see their guest book - jam packed with glowing reviews! First Impressions We arrived Saturday evening after spending the day at Warwick Winery (a MUST experience!) and were greeted by our jolly innkeeper Bob. He used to live in NYC! We easily broke into a conversation about local NYC eateries and the ol' neighborhood. Water and soda could be found in a fridge upstairs. This was limited to a few cans of diet soda by the time we got to it but the thought was nice and it was heavily restocked 2 days later. Bob was always accessible and eager to give you tips on what to do locally. Everything he suggested, we visited - Warwick Village: Great place to spend half the day Pennings: Find some local produce and have a drink at their apple sorter bar. Sugarloaf: Spend the other half of the day at this beautiful artisan village Candy Apple Shoppe: YUM! Had to pick up a famous Candy Apple here! Adirondack Hiking Trail: Gorgeous with all the fresh snow, climbing up to the bridge was quite an adventure as the steps were gone and all that was left was a snow packed slide! So much fun! Just like Home Bob pointed out that there was a Keurig for Coffee/Tea/Hot Cocoa and a table filled with Sea Salted Caramel Brownies (The sign that indicated they were Highly Addictive was right on the money!) and heart shaped Meringues. What a Treat! The Living Room area was, I don't know how else to put it - Comfy! Even more so than our home. You just wanted to curl up with a book for hours on one of these sofas. The Dining room gave you a Dinner with the Family feel and was very inviting indeed. Cider Mill Inn, of course the rooms would be The Gala Suite, Braeburn and Cortland. We were in the Braeburn. The moment I walked it I squealed with delight - this was our room for the weekend! It was so.. light and fluffy, comfortable and bright, luxurious with its 4 post bed... a room fit for a Princess. Our bathroom was on the small side (a little larger than a Cruise Ship), but we were very grateful that we had a private bathroom! AND it had a overhead heater! Exciting! luxury indeed! And no boring hotel soaps here, you get real local soaps. Being as the 2014 Winter Olympics were on, the one thing we could have wished for was an HD Cable Box. The TV was a beautiful mounted LG Flat Screen, unfortunately it only displayed Standard Def (Sorry Bob! Us city folk have been spoiled by HD!) The FOOD! Bob's wife was what we called the Secret Chef. Although we never saw her, we really appreciated all the love and effort she put into preparing our meals. We were fortunate enough to been able to experience two breakfasts at the Cider Mill Inn. Sweet: Strawberry Scones and Orange Muffins, Poached Pear in Chiati (WOW!), Bananas Flambé over Yogurt and Oatmeal Crisp, Crème brûlée French Toast with Smoked Chicken Sausage or Apple Wood Bacon (and fruit) - Bring your Sweet Tooth! Savory: Cranberry Scones and Blueberry Muffins, Fresh Fruit Cup, Chai Oatmeal (My FAV!!!), Ham & Cheese in a Puff Pastry with Scrambled Eggs - You will leave stuffed as if you just ate at a buffet, but you will be so very happy! It was such a pleasure staying here. This was our first B&B and will most likely be our favorite. We can't wait to come back during warmer times. read more

Bob was such an excellent host! He gave us a bunch of restaurant suggestions our first night there and chatted with us about attractions in the area. The next morning, we were served a lovely homemade 3-course breakfast in their dining room. Thanks to his recommendations, we visited Pennings Farm (highly recommend!) and we were able to secure a reservation at the highly sought after The Grange farm to fork restaurant and had a great time. It seems that Bob and his family live in the house in a separate suite on the first floor, and he told us to just knock on their door whenever we had any questions or issues. We felt really well taken care of, which I guess is why people like to stay at intimate local establishments such as this one. The house is on the older side, but we didn't mind because the A/C worked well, the shower water got hot quickly, and the water pressure was great. Our bed in the Cortland Room was also really comfortable and we slept so well. There was also complimentary bottled water and sodas in the mini fridge outside the bedrooms. Thank you to the Cider Mill Inn for a wonderful weekend getaway! read more

We had a wonderful stay at the Cider Mill Inn. Everything was just perfect and we will definitely return for another stay in the near future! Thank you Bob ( wife, daughter and puppy!). Pat & Ken Hayes read more

Cider Mill Inn - Hotels Near Me - Pine Island, New York

Never again... our first bed and breakfast... got there at 3:30.... no one home for at least 20 min.. owner arrived at 3:50, seemed confused why I was there, even though I had a reservation from over a month, called me by the wrong name several times and said the room would be ready in a few minutes.... 1 hour later, we were still waiting (mind you this is our wedding anniversary)... told him we were leaving and never looked back.... thanks for putting a damper on am other wise perfect weekend read more

My girlfriend and I were looking for a nice bed and breakfast to stay at after spending the day at the Warwick winery. We found this place via Orbitz and it seemed to have decent reviews compared to other hotels in the area but what a mistake. They have a strict policy regarding check in time being between 3pm and 6pm, so we arrived at 3pm only to find the door locked and no one to answer as we knocked on the door several times. We tried calling the phone number provided but got a voicemail mailbox that was full. We called for about an hour as we sat on the front steps hoping someone would answer or open the door for us. Finally we got in touch with the owner Bob who advises his daughter would let us in. Minutes later we heard the door unlock, never were we greeted by anyone just heard the door unlock. Went to open the door and it was magically unlocked. This should of been our second red flag but we decided to continue on. We went up to the room put our bags down and my gf saw a large bug on the floor. No big deal I killed it then went to turn the air conditioner down and there were atleast a dozen more bugs! It was disgusting. We packed our bags and ran out! Tried calling the owner but again was unable to get in contact with him. Finally called orbitz who after several hours were able to get in touch with the owner he refused to give us our money back and said that we used the room and we lied about the bugs. Attached r the pics of some of the bugs. STAY AWAY! Not to mention the pool was green and looked disgusting along with the rest of the property that was dirty and unkept. read more

See all

We stayed at the Cider Mill Inn for a long weekend. All of the breakfasts were cooked on site by our host, Bob Lipinsky. They are four course affairs so pace yourself! He usually started with fresh-baked muffins and scones, followed by fresh fruit, then some kind of hot cereal, oatmeal, or rice pudding dish. The last course would be something savory like bacon or eggs with either french toast, pancakes, or some other kind of pastry. We stayed in the Gala Suite, which is the most spacious of their available rooms, which was more expensive but worth it if you really want to feel that relaxing get-away kind of feeling. It was absolutely lovely, complete with a small sitting room and a bathroom with a jacuzzi tub. There is also a pool available on the premises during the summer, but we were here in the fall. The surrounding area is a bit remote; about a 15 minute drive into town, where there is a bustling downtown area with shops, restaurants, and other attractions. We checked out Trattoria Viviano, Yesterday's Pub, Frank's Pizza, Caffe a la Mode, and others. We also went apple picking at the Pochuck Farm a mile up the road from the Inn, upon Bob's recommendation. It was a lovely experience. All in all, I have never had a nicer or more intimate hotel/inn experience. I would definitely return for another visit, maybe around the 4th of July just to see how it looks in the summer. read more

My husband and I just spent the weekend at The Cider Mill Inn. We were celebrating a family occasion at the Warwick Winery and it is very close in location. The winery is absolutely beautiful so if you are in the area you should make it a point to stop there. We stayed in the Gala Suite which had a small parlor area and a jetted tub for two. The room itself was very clean. However, there seems to be a problem in the room with stink bugs coming from somewhere. We used half a roll of toilet paper catching them from the ceiling and flushing them down the toilet. Thus the name, stink bug, you are never to squash them. We are not grossed out be nature, although some people may have a problem with this. We do not eat breakfast so we cannot comment on the food. The upstairs refrigerator was appropriately stocked with bottled water and diet soda, which was a plus. There was a Keurig on the lower level for coffee and tea if you desired at anytime during the day or night. The bedding was very clean, however, I would recommend a warmer blanket on the bed since it was a bit chilly at night. Also, the pillows were not soft and squishy. The owner seemed nice enough, although our interaction was very limited since my husband and I do not eat breakfast and we're typically quiet guests. If they could get a good bug spray to handle the stink bugs that would be beneficial as we have seen from other reviews that this was a problem for other guests as well. Overall, if you're in the area, I would recommend The Cider Mill Inn due to the close proximity to the winery. read more

Dirty, un kept..stayed with my spouse late Spring...room up stairs family lived downstairs...rooms, carpets and sheets filthy. Like staying at the Munsters home but for real. Breakfast nothing out of the ordinary. yard a unkept mess, pour dirty..just not what you expect form B & B. read more

I came here with my best friend for a girls' weekend and we loved it. The owner was very nice and welcoming, and the house itself was so pretty. We stayed in the gala suite, which was homey and spacious. The jacuzzi tub was excellent too. Everything was impeccably clean and comfortable. The breakfast was delicious! We had baked goods, fruit, and a frittata & it was great. The location was excellent because it's close to the town of Warwick but also close to several wineries. I would definitely recommend this place and stay here again. read more

Had a wonderful stay here. Felt very comfortable and the breakfast was creative and delicious! I would highly recommend this place for a peaceful and restful stay. read more

My boyfriend and I visited the Cider Mill Inn about a week ago and I don't know where these other reviewers are coming from, but we loved it!! The host (Bob) was so kind and catered to our every need. We stayed in the sumptuous Gala Suite on the second floor. Breakfast was insanely delicious - creme brûlée french toast with poached pears, lemon ginger scones with devonshire cream, chicken and apple sausage, and a spiced chai oatmeal. It was my boyfriend's birthday, and Bob definitely brought out two freshly homemade coconut cupcakes (yum!!) at the end of our meal, to celebrate. I didn't ask for anything in particular, he found out offhand as we were chatting, so we both thought that was honestly sweet. And we were so full of our gourmet delights we couldn't eat until dinner! We walked their beautiful nature trail (on property) as the sun set behind us, and the hot tub was the perfect end to a day of winery hopping and frolicking through the bucolic pastures of Warwick. I'd highly recommend this B&B to anyone looking for a place to really soak up the gorgeous countryside of Warwick, NY. read more