Cheapest gas in this area by far. The other stations in this strip also have cheap gas but this is closer to the highway.

The attendants are kind and the store is clean. Which is great! I spend hundreds of $ there every month (gas, cigs, vapes, snacks). Bought an overpriced $25 disposable vape like usual, and it didn't work. When you take a puff, it stays on and keeps burning/stays lit up. I went back to exchange it, and was told that because I had already left the store, it couldn't be exchanged, to come back and see the manager, and that they need to be tested before you leave. Thing is, you're not told that when you buy one, like other stores do. I was going out of town for days so I couldn't come back the next day, and wasn't about to drop another $25 on a vape (so $50 total for a $15 vape, since they're overpriced at that gas station) in the hopes it might be rectified next week. According to New Jersey law: "Shoppers must be informed of refund policies before making a purchase - not just on the receipt. Refund policies that are 20-days or less must be conspicuously displayed by merchants on signs clearly visible to the buyer from the cash register, posted by the store's entrance, attached to the item or affixed to the cash register." This seems to be a trend with these disposable vapes. A handful of grime balls will buy a vape, put an old one in the new box, and claim their new vape didn't work. So honest loyal customers get screwed thanks to the sleezebags, and the shops having crappy policies that aren't made known. Depending on the brand, I've found that about 20% of disposable vapes are defective. Not to mention, there's a chance your vape might work when you puff it once, then you get home, and it's a dud. If they weren't so incredibly overpriced at Citgo, have such a high rate of defectiveness, and the store actually make their policy known, this wouldn't be such a point of contention. The vapes I buy are being sold at Citgo for $25. They're $15 everywhere else. I wouldn't mind getting screwed AS much if they weren't so overpriced. Not the workers' fault of course. They don't set the prices. I did lose my cool at the attendant, and for that I apologize- it's not her fault that the store has bad policies for disposable (and highly defective) vapes. (They all kinda suck in that regard, but Elfbar hadn't given me a problem until today). In this crappy economic climate, I suppose tensions get a little higher when you feel unjustly screwed out of money (which funnily enough, happens more than ever these last 2 years), but again, it wasn't right to take it out on the attendant, who was just doing her job, and probably has to deal with rude people everyday. I'm never that person, but for some reason, today I was. read more

I don't know if this place can follow directions but when a customer asks for only $25 on a GasBuddy card, don't forget to not set the programmer of your full service pumps and let it roll to full at $38 when they finally came back to check on us. When we told them all they could say is 'thats the way our pumps work and that they swore they set it."(i watched out the back window closest to the gas fill-up side.) I know a bunch of years ago we stopped at a BP gas station somewhere nearby and much like that time this time we intentionally wanted to slip into Jersey for gas coming from Port Jervis and heading into PA. However, i made the suggestion to find that BP but the driver said he had activated a special GasBuddy deal. Maybe if he would've listened to me this whole mess wouldn't have happened. He was traveling almost on fumes for most of the time down from Kingston (Ulster Co.). I was surprised just how close you are to the NY-PA-NJ border - a lot closer than the BP supposedly just down the road. The road was in New York state, but once we turned into the parking lot, i was watching on a map on my phone and we had traveled into Jersey- and all that without a sign in sight not on the toad and nothing in their business or sidestreet.) After collecting the receipt, i mentioned to my brother that that's the way Citgo always treats people, but i still dont know if thats the full truth because km comparing two gas businesses near each other in the Tristate corner of NJ. read more

This company refuses to hire disabled people. As soon as they become aware that you were disabled for any period of time and for any reason whatsoever, your job application gets thrown away! Boycott this place! read more

Check your account statements if you have used your credit or debit card at this gas station. Had an unauthorized charge made at this gas station and it wasn't made by me....... read more

Because this is a "convenience" store, I'm willing to be ok with giving it 1 star for convenience alone, but this place is truly a dump. The bathroom is disgusting and the employees (one in particular) had no respect for the fact that there were customers. One employee was loudly complaining about another employee who wasn't present and then started throwing swears around asking "where the hell" another employee was. The bathroom had several holes in the walls with toilet paper stuffed in them and one toilet was filled with pee and poop and completely clogged and toilet paper was all over the floor. I will however say that they always have cheap gas, so there's something. read more

Terrible! All fill ups in one direction, no signs, rude!!! We are pulling a 33' camper and couldn't turn around. He said the company is watching. Citgo, I will remember and never use y'all again. read more

I stopped here while passing through the area, and have been here numerous times in the past while in the area. Gas in NJ is always much cheaper than NY due to the deep pockets of NY politicians with the soaring tax rates. This gas station is conveniently located right at the NY/PA/NJ state line and is a quick stop off of Interstate 84. The prices here are much cheaper than NY, but are still higher than most of NJ. In fairness, the gas prices are generally the same at all of the stations on this whole strip of road, but it appears they are slightly monopolizing due to their proximity to the NY/PA border, knowing it's still cheaper than the other states. Overall, the service here is great and the attendants pumping gas are always courteous and very prompt, wasting no time when you pull in. read more

This place just across the state line from New York from the Port Jervis exit off Route 84 used to have noticeably lower gas prices, but this past week the rates were the same, so the owners have obviously decided to take advantage of travellers on the interstate. Additionally per New Jersey law you are not allowed to pump your own gas, and the attendant will expect you to hand over your card to him. If on this era of data breaches this makes you uneasy, try New York or Pennsylvania. read more