I was fortunate enough to grow up with amazing birthday cakes and holiday treats from Classic Cake Co. My mother would often take me to the bakery when I was a little girl and it was still at the Eagle Plaza location. I've since moved away, which might be a good thing ( if I lived nearby I would probably eat their baked goodies all the time - not good ;) ) Now, whenever my mother comes to town for a visit she makes sure to always bring some Classic Cake treats - usually s'mores cookies, chocolate chip cookies, and fresh whole grain bread. My son/her grandson particularly likes the chocolate chip cookies she brings, and it makes me glad to know that now he can experience just how incredible their baked goods are. I'm a Classic Cake fan for life! read more

My husband and I chose Classic Cakes for our wedding day cake and it was the best decision ever. The quality and flavor lived up to their reputation and our expectations and we cannot wait to eat the rest of our cake on our anniversary! The staff was super friendly and we were lucky to have worked with Kristina who made our cake decision process even easier. read more

Classic Cake - wedding cake, 3 tiers, 3 flavors, DELICIOUS! - Bakeries Near Me - Cherry Hill, New Jersey

Great experience! Classic cheesecake is our favorite place to shop for a cake or cupcakes, so when I decided to order a special birthday cake for my son I call Sharon. I emailed her few cake pictures and told her about changes I want to make. My son loves cheesecake but I wasn't sure I want to go with it. Sharon such a sweet lady! She listened to all my ideas, concerns, doubts and offered her valuable suggestions. We finalized cake design and decided to go with the chocolate cake with raspberry buttercream. Sharon gave me few cupcakes, she wanted me to be sure about the cake flavors. Cake was delivered in time to my house. It was a sensation. It was THE perfect cake for my son birthday! Thank you to Sharon and to all her helpers for a great job!!! Should I mention that cake was gone in an hour read more

Love this place. My wife shopped around for a custom cake and when all other places told her it was not possible, Classic Cake had no problems making an incredible and delicious cake .. plus for a much better price. Every single person that works here is very friendly. I highly recommend this place for cakes, cookies, pastries, and any other bakery items. read more

The cake was half the size we were told it would be. it was not very good either. Grossly overpriced.

Very good red velvet cake. The best I tasted since moving to South Jersey. Not to sweet, you can really taste the chocolate cake beneath the red dye. The icing is perfect. Junior's in Brooklyn on Flatbush Avenue now have serious competitor as the best red velvet on the east coast. read more

I don't know what was worse, the cake that we had from there (that had to be thrown out!) or the customer service by the staff at the Cherry Hill bakery. Don't waste your money! A grocery store cake would be better then what they are saying is "top quality". I will be returning to Sweet Eats! read more

Awesome cakes and choices. I love the chocolate mousse cake.

I ordered a cake for my son and fiancées engagement party. Although I think the quality of other baked goods at Classic Cake are superior to other bakery's products in the South Jersey area, the engagement cake was not. It was beautifully decorated as ordered. However, the taste of this cake for the price did not distinguish it from any other cake that I could have ordered from another bakery. It was ordinary and the icing between the layers was far too thick. Less icing and more cake would have been nice. A lot of money for a disappointing product. I expected more from a Robert Bennett product. read more

We bought four tarts for New Year's Eve; two Key Lime and two chocolate cheesecake. I don't know what the "Key Lime" was, and the chocolate cheesecake, although recognizable, was awful. We spent $20 for dessert and threw it in the garbage, read more

The tiramisu was NOT tiramisu. It was cheesecake. No mascarpone. The lady fingers were not soaked. No espresso. The cocoa powder that I expected to be in the middle was chocolate cheesecake. It was a mess. My SO bought a snowball. We thought it'd be a nicer take on the snack cake favorite. It was just crumbly vanilla cake with hardly any icing and some coconut. Very overpriced and disappointing. read more

My sister bought the best Italian rum cake from here. The way Italian rum should taste, but unfortunately, at other bakeries, rarely does.

Cute little place, friendly staff. Almond cookies are a must: so light it melts in the mouth and it's perfect with coffee. Once I had a cupcake there and it was dry and tasteless, but maybe they just had a bad cupcake day...The rum cake is excelent: moist, light and not too sweet. read more

Decided to try the rye bread here (didn't feel like waiting at kibitz or short hills where the bread is soft and delicious. ). So disappointed. Tasted strange and felt stale though I was assured it was fresh. Right in the trash it went. read more

Beyond amazing! Everyone is so sweet and so supportive, not to mention the amazing flavors and cakes they offer xoxo

We ordered a "cut-out" cake for our son's birthday from Classic Cake. We were blown away! It was awesome and very generously sized. As a kid, we always ordered our cakes from Classic Cake, and the current bakery does not disappoint. Highly recommended! read more

I got my wedding cake, son's first birthday and the latest- my mother's surprise party Retirement cake from here. All unbelievably delicious. I live in center city and pay extra to have it delivered to me- its worth it. My son's was an adorable tiger cub cake in vanilla pound with van buttercream- it made the party. The retirement cake was choc chip pound with van buttercream, beautifully decorated with peach, pink and yellow flowers and dusted with a very delicate sparkle. Very happy. read more

I ordered a 12 inch round cake for our anniversary party with 30 guests --- pound cake with fudge filling and decorated with some buttercream flowers down the side. It looked pretty. Frankly, I was disappointed. The cake was dry, not moist or buttery like a pound cake should be. The frosting was just so-so. For $80 I would have thought that it would have tasted delicious, given that it was from Classic Cake. We had some left over from the party but I don't plan on eating it which says a lot, because I am a dessert lover. read more

The cakes are beautiful and taste excellent. The smell when you walk in the door is wonderful.

Absolutely amazing! I went in for a cake tasting for a baby shower and the hospitality was beyond this world. Everyone is so friendly and easygoing it's impossible to leave unsatisfied. Not to mention, the flavors are incredible. Will definitely be ordering for here for now on! read more

Best ever!!!!!!!!!!!! Beautiful and delicious! 10 stars to Classic Cake Company Thank you.

I first started to come here to get French Macarons which are very difficult to find in NJ. The first two times I came here, I was able to get the red velvet flavor which was exceptional. However, I have visited a few times afterwards (3 times) and the French Macarons I received were extremely stale, so much so that I simply couldn't eat them when I got home. Mind you, Macarons are pretty expensive, averaging above $1.25 per cookie so I was quite disappointed each time. My husband had the same complaint for cookies he bought from Classic Cake. I have also had cupcakes from here (lemon and blueberry; red velvet; chocolate cupcakes) and unfortunately, I have found their baked goods to be dry and heavy. I cannot comment on their made to order cakes, because I have never had one and never will given my experience with their "ready to eat" treats. Although the staff is very nice, and helpful, I no longer go here for my French Macaroons and sweet treats. read more

I am getting married at Sea Oaks Country Club in Little Egg Harbor, NJ and they go through Classic Cakes for all their weddings. I was annoyed to have to drive all the way out to Cherry Hill to do my tasting and pick the style of cake that I wanted (considering I live about 1 1/2 hours north) but it was well worth the drive! Kristina assisted us and she made it one the most fun and stress free parts of my wedding planning process. I brought my fiancee, mother and mother-in-law to be with me and I'm glad I had all the extra help because it was tough narrowing down all the delicious flavors of cake. I brought a picture of the cake I wanted and a fabric swatch of the color flowers I wanted on the cake. I highly recommend doing that because Kristina said they could replicate the cake exactly and the swatch would help them get the exact color I wanted (plum colored flowers can mean different things to different people). Their cake/icing are amazing - we ended up doing a 4-layer cake and each layer is going to be a different flavor with different icing - we just couldn't decide on one. Don't be afraid to ask if there's something specific you want. We wanted one layer to have cannoli filling and Classic Cakes had no problem accommodating us. They provided different options so we could save a bit of money as well. So happy I had the chance to experience this. I know so many people who get married at a venue and the cake is part of the package deal. Which basically means the standard no frills wedding cake that usually taste stale and only has two options - chocolate or vanilla. read more