absolutely amazing we love coming here to paint ceramics, the staff is amazing always welcoming we come twice a month or more. alway a good time and helpful with picking paint and how make coats . Highly recommen coming in , on a date night, with your kids, or with a friend. So many items to choose from . read more

From the minute, we walked in the door we were relaxed. The girl working was terrific. She showed us what to do and we had such a good time. Prices were very reasonable. read more

I have been here 3 times, most recently last month, and have found the experience to be enjoyable and relaxing. I came with 2-3 friends each time and we all sat comfortably at a table. They offer a wide selection of pieces to paint. There are lots of themes such as seashore, animal statues, cookie jars, mugs, candle holders, Halloween and Christmas and much more. There is a wide variety of paint colors and brushes to choose from. The employees are extremely helpful and available for assistance if needed. I have never felt rushed, I would stay for 3-4 hours just painting and chatting with my friends. And best of all, my pieces came out beautiful all 3 times! And that's a big deal to me as I hadn't painted anything in years! Definitely would recommend this experience to anyone looking for a creative outlet and/or fun outing with friends or children! read more

Color Me Mine - This my most recent piece--seashell tea light holder - Paint-Your-Own Pottery Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

went to color me mine yesterday for the first time since i was about 6 or 7 and loved it. not much has changed since i was little from what i remember. it was such a fun night out with my boyfriend. we had so much fun painting. Julianna was working and she was an amazing employee. she kept a great conversation up with us and was so genuine and very nice. definitely will be back soon to paint read more

Color Me Mine - Paint-Your-Own Pottery Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

So this was my second experience at this location I've been to the one up north in Summit numerous times with my children never had a problem. The first time we use this establishment was about a year ago the paint was thin lose watery and the attendant hovered over you like you were wasting their product but I let it go . Last week I'm go with my son we have a really nice time I paid for two pieces $55 took about a week for us to get it back in upon opening up the product the plate that I painted was cracked square in half. I immediately went back inside to speak to a manager explained to her that my son literally just walked out the door with the piece and when I opened it and examined it in the car it was broken in half. She then only wanted to give me back my money for the piece not what I actually paid for it now when you go into an establishment like this half of the price of the piece is utilized for painting glaze so my $16 piece was actually a $24 piece and she had the audacity to try to keep my additional money I will never patronize this dump ever again! Your establishment broke a piece that I sat over an hour painting and then you have the nerve to try to keep an additional eight dollars that I actually paid for you lost your mind and my business . Never again rather drive a hour to a well ran establishment . Waste of money and time . read more

Color Me Mine - Plate - Paint-Your-Own Pottery Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

I was extremely disappointed, I came here with my sisters and we were very uncomfortable because the employees were not wearing masks. We will not be coming back, not only were the employees not maintaining covid safety, they were not requiring customers to wear masks either. very unsafe. read more

Terrible experience , I went there with my 2 very young children. We paid 50 dollars 2 small items . We went in mind July, I got a phone call on Aug 31st to pick up my item this week. I called spoke with a female said I would be in this week , I was told no problem and when I arrived as I said I would same week they already threw away my childrens items. The "owner" was very rude,unprofessional and ubpleasant... she did not try to resolve this issue in any way .. did not give me an explanation. I let her listen to the voice left on my phone .. did not mention my items would be thrown away . I never heard of a business owner not trying to resolve an issue when I was clearly upset. Beware, she does not value her customers. I would never go back and I will be telling all my friends about this terrible experience. read more

Buyer beware. Unprofessional & inexperienced business owner. Advertised free next-day delivery within 10 miles of store during COVID-19 outbreak just to get people to buy. Then doesn't deliver. Emails go unanswered. Messages via FB go unanswered. When you call to check status of the order (and you live within 10 miles of store) - owner hangs up on you - cancels your order - because she only offered free delivery for her friends that "live around the corner" - and "7 miles is too far to deliver" - despite that she advertised free delivery within 10 miles of store. Better Business Bureau needs to look into her business practices. read more

Had a great experience! Give yourself at least 2 hours to create. Irene is extremely friendly and personable; she's all around the best! :)

Met a friend here for an evening of painting and a chance to catch up. It was very relaxing. We did not need a reservation. Staff was kind, encouraging, and professional- gave advice when asked for and made a few suggestions for good results. I'm not at all crafty, and my painting skills need help. I received a phone call a few days later when the piece was ready, and was told they can hold the piece for 30 days or I could have the piece delivered. I was pleasantly surprised to find out I might have an artistic side after all! I plan to return. read more

Visited today. Chastised for not having a reservation. Then was treated very rudely bc items couldn't be fired. Left with a crying four year old. Visited Van Gogh in Downtown Toms River. Wonderful experience! read more

Cute place . Took my kids over spring break on a rainy day . Everything explained exactly . My negative is that it is expensive . $7 just to sit & then u pay for the piece which is the biggest prob because the range is 10 to $25 . And how do u force your kids to paint a cheap dolphin when lightening McQueen is staring at him . read more

Been there a few times already in the past 2 mos. and I LOVE it ! You pick the pottery you want to paint and select the paints you want to use and then relax and have fun being creative for a couple of hours. They offer a lot of specials throughout the month(s) so pick up one of their events of the month flyers near the front of the store to find out when they are. The staff is very friendly and very helpful. Will go back again and again ! It can be a bit expensive, depending on which pieces of pottery you pick, but they have plenty of pieces for under $ 10 and so this is a fun place for any budget ! read more

Just love this place! This is my first time coming here. The service is amazing. I love the selection they have, a lot of unique pieces. I love to paint, and do it all the time, I will continue to come here! read more

Excellent place to come and paint a ceramic keepsake for yourself or as a gift. Makes a great day/night out to do something different with your kids or adult friends. There are many different pieces to choose from too so you are sure to find something to paint. Great for parties not only for kids birthdays but bridal or baby showers where your entire party can personalize a gift piece for the bride or mom to be! Friendly and helpful staff are accommodating. read more

This was an awesome activity to do with the family, and you can't a momento to remember the lovely experience. Everyone was extremely nice there, and are very patient with young children. Overall, it was a great experience as a family. read more

Very nice place for kids parties and adults. Pick your item and choose your paint colors. They kiln fire the pieces and you pick them up a few days later. Very reasonable prices, friendly, attentive, knowledgeable employees. read more

Color Me Mine - The party. - Paint-Your-Own Pottery Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Just left, me my mom and my finacès daughter. And she absolutly loves this place! I took her here last year too. She loves to color and paint. So i called today they said we can come in at 630. Came in, the girl was SO nice! Did our pieces and left. My fiances daugher needed more paints so she asked nicely to the lady and she got it for her. She was very welcoming! I highly recommend this place! read more

I had a Groupon 2 for $30. The person I had coming with me cancelled due to sickness. I paid 16 for the 2 pieces. I stated I thought it was a great bargain. The manager replied "You should not have showed up alone that is a no no. I'm giving you a break, one person alone is not allowed it's a huge don't". What an obnoxious response and unprofessional manner to respond to someone. Asbury Park has pottery places and there are other places to paint and learn the technique of ceramics. I will never return to this place. read more