I was out thrifting in Warren so I decided to give Cockeye Creamery a try after seeing it…read morerecommended by an online article. Located on the North side of Warren on 422 the Creamery is located in the parking lot of Cockey BBQ. The menu is a bit limited compared to most ice cream places, it has cones, dishes, sundaes (hot fudge only, milkshakes and ice cream sandwiches, plus hand packed pints and quarts. The variety comes from the variety of unique flavors of ice cream; I tried to get a picture of the flavors board, but the video screen was in the sun and was very hard to read. Service was nice, I got a sample of the Cornbread and Sorghum, which was unusual and very sweet. I ordered a dish with 3 scoops, which was a generous portion. All the ice creams were creamy, not too rich with good flavor, also the ice cream was served just at a great temperature, firm, but not solid so that the flavors really hit the palate. The Key Lime Pie was Key Lime ice cream with graham cracker and marshmallow creme, nice and balanced if not as tart as real key lime pie, but still tasty. The Kong, banana ice cream with graham crackers and mini buckeyes was great, the banana flavor was as good as I have had in an ice cream, not artificial at all. My favorite was the Andromeda, chocolate ice cream with brownie pieces and chocolate chips. The chocolate ice cream was the real star here, rich and chocolaty and not too sweet, this is what you want if you are a real chocoholic. Cockeye Creamery is concentrating on making great ice cream in some unique flavors, well worth a visit if you are in Warren and you want some high quality ice cream. Definitely worth a visit when you deserve a treat.

Not sure how I found room for this amazing oat milk ice cream but I did!! Nice outdoor seating…read more Friendly staff. So grateful for the dairy free and gluten free options of vanilla bean and chocolate.

Amazing, creative ice cream flavors, prices a little high but a spacious clean shop with plenty of…read morecustomers, i would rate it above Handels and Pavs in quality and novelty.

Disappointed in the milkshake, my buddy said they have good shakes but it was expensive and small…read morefor a medium, I think Dairy Queen shakes are better and also cheaper. They give a veterans discount if you ask and you are one

Great weekend specials. Burgers are awesome along with the wings and pizza! Try the Katie's Korner…read moreice cream

The fish dinners are unbelievably good. The wings come in at a close second…read more Convenient location with a drive thru.

Excellent! The ice cream is yummy and the hot fudge divine. I let them know that I really like hot…read morefudge and they put extra in without even charging me -- who does that these days? I'm told by locals that this is the place to go. It's a landmark. It really is wonderful. If you're ever in Warren, or at their other locations, you need to drop by--you won't be disappointed. .

There isn't a time I'm close by that I can resist this place! There are tons of unique icecream…read moreflavors, and the most exciting part, they have a drive thru!! I love icecream on the go! My favorite flavors are cotton candy and strawberry cheesecake. There's a punch of flavor in each, and I'm completely satisfied with both. So why not 5 stars? To be honest, I come here for the nostalgia versus the flavor. I've tasted better strawberry cheesecake icecream, but not cotton candy, it's one of a kind!

Udderly Sweet is, delightfully, old fashioned with welcoming staff that are always friendly! They…read morehave a vast menu of delicious ice cream novelties and scrumptious hot foods! Check out their website to view their menu! #SatisfiedCustomer

Came back here again and it seems they are using some other brand for some of their ice cream. It…read morehad a lot of overrun and was airy.. and thus seemly not very cold. Good if your un the area, but not my first choice if there was something else that had a rich, "hard" ice cream. The texture of what we got today was almost like it was also being served too warm.. very soft.

There are few simple pleasures left in the world that consistently deliver joy--and Handel's Ice…read moreCream is one of them. From the moment you arrive, the experience feels intentionally unhurried and charming. Ordering at the window adds to that classic ice cream parlor nostalgia, and the outdoor seating invites you to slow down, sit back, and actually enjoy the moment instead of rushing through it. On a warm day, it's exactly where you want to be. The Service, omg the service was amazing, they care, they listen they even try to help with custom non menu item requests. And then there's the ice cream. Magnificent. Truly. Rich, creamy, perfectly balanced, and unmistakably homemade in both texture and flavor. Each bite feels indulgent without being overwhelming, and it's clear that quality--not shortcuts--is the priority here. This isn't just dessert; it's craftsmanship. Handel's manages to do something rare: it delivers consistency, atmosphere, and exceptional product all at once. Whether you're stopping by with family, friends, or simply treating yourself, it feels like a small celebration every time. If you appreciate great ice cream, thoughtful simplicity, and a place that understands the value of doing one thing extremely well--this is it. Highly recommended.

There's nothing quite like Handel's, and it was the perfect final stop after our big Italian…read moredinner. Even on a chilly night, their ice cream is a must-have. Sometimes, all you need to soothe an overindulged stomach is a perfect scoop of classic vanilla, and Handel's absolutely delivered. I love the old-school, no-fuss vibe here. It's a classic walk-up window setup, with the ice cream hut at the center of a spacious parking lot, making for a super easy in-and-out trip. Service was quick and friendly, exactly what you want. For those who want to linger, there are plenty of picnic tables with umbrellas. Or, you can easily get a lid and take your treats to go. While my friend dove into a delicious Butterscotch Ripple, my simple vanilla was exactly what I needed--creamy, rich, and the perfect palate cleanser. They have a huge menu with tons of flavors for every possible craving. It's the ideal spot for a quick, high-quality after-dinner treat. A true classic.

Drive up window food is great service is fast and friendly inside the store is nice. The ice cream…read morestand is in the country but once you been there you will want to go back they have a apple dumpling you have to get they heat up the dumpling then put vanilla ice cream on it very good.

Not so great, I went by the reviews and it didn't work out this time. Friendly service for sure,…read morebut that's all I can say. Ice cream wasn't that good especially the Flurry. Also it was over priced. Cleanliness didn't look all that great either.

This has always been my favorite ice cream place to go to! They serve the best "hard" ice cream. I…read morealways get their Cookies & Cream! Delicious!

I seen a young lady post about her experience on Facebook and she stated she had a racial…read moreexperience. But me being the woman that I am I wanted to try for myself when I went to get a chocolate ice cream they told me they don't have "that flavor" here... well at least not by that name we call it Toasted vanilla and they were out of it and it's going to be a while before they restocked it again sorry Let's just say it's not a coincidence that I just happened to be a black woman as well‍Cold stone it is

Yum! We were staying in Pymatuning State Park and drove past Yorkie's a few times before deciding…read moreto stop for a treat. We tried both the soft serve and the hard ice cream and both were delicious. They have so, so many flavors. Plenty of options for everyone. They were also extremely generous with toppings which I really appreciated.

It is a little expensive for what is being offered. You're better off going across the bridge to…read morethe ice cream place in Andover. Also, it is now closed for the season.

Being new to town, this was our first visit to Katie's Korner…read more We were thrown for a loop by the "Cash Only" requirement but there's an ATM at 7/17 Credit Union half a mile away. The portions are generous and the ice cream was delish!

Lots of flavors and homemade waffle cones…read more This place was recommended by a local so we went to try it out. So many flavors to choose from and portions are huge. Waffles cones are homemade and fresh. They even have benches in the shade to enjoy your ice cream.