This is a great record store. The owners are very friendly and helpful. The atmosphere is pleasant…read more They have a great selection of records at really fair and affordable prices. They have gone as far as to look for album's that I could not find and then call me when they arrived. I don't know much about the book selection but my mother thought it was very good. Their cat Mrs. Peele is very friendly and is known to come up to you just to say hello. :-)

Wow. This place is amazing. Great selection of records, books, comics & odd antiques. The have a…read moregreat selection of occult items and a very awesome vibe. Owners are really helpful & cool.

Comic books are on sale! Wow! Everything is Buy 3 get 3 free! Some as low as $1! Bills Bullpen has…read moreMarvel, DC and a ton of Indy comics.

Bills Bullpen has a wide variety of products including…read more Sports cards, MTG, Pokemon, Pop vinyl figures, home decor, Comic books, graphic novels and collecting supplies. Bills bullpen is locates in the Arnot mall and open everyday.

Listen. I'm gonna assume I caught them on a bad day; this store was a mess. But the guy was nice…read moreand tried to be helpful. I would try them again.

Do you like comics? Do you want to have an adventure? Go here! Now! So great! And Jared is amazing…read more It is organized chaos, but it is comic book heaven.

KEYSTONE CARDS at 515 S. Keystone Avenue in Sayre, PA, is a haven for the experienced or the "just…read morestarting out" gamer. Rich concentrates on making this a fun place to be. Always helpful, he makes sure that from the experienced gamer to the tentative "newbie" everyone has a good, stress free visit. Everyone is welcome. The card game MAGIC, in it's various releases, is to be found here including "Modern". Friday Night Magic is held every Friday starting at 6:30PM. But wait, there's more... Previously viewed DVD'S, personally inspected and cleaned, are for sale at excellent prices. You'll probably find that favorite old movie you've been looking for in Rich's extensive collection. Paints to complete that action figure you've been meaning to do are sold here as well as expert advice from Rich, who is a recognized model maker. Learn from the best. Sports cards and sports collectibles can be found here as well. It is WELL worth spending time browsing in Keystone Cards. The atmosphere is friendly, hassle free and enjoyable, something that you do not find in larger "chain" store.. Plus, it feels good to shop at a local, small store that has been in business to 25 years. Hours of operation are Wednesday-Friday 11am-8pm; Saturday 11am-6pm; Sunday Noon-5pm.

From the owner: Trading Cards Gaming , Sports Cards, Supplies, Tabletop Games and Miniature Wargaming.read more

On August 27, 2026 . I took in this Transformers toy into the store and WWE Bayley's wrestling…read morefigure and Christian Cage wrestling action figure and some Comic book. I was giving $60 in store credit and that Transformers are worth $60 by himself . So I feel like I was ripped off. Beware what you take into the store

This place is absolutely amazing, regardless of your era. They have a vintage collection from just…read moreabout every gaming and toy era you can imagine, and the place is HUGE. Whatever your nerd heart desires, whether it is comic books, movies, cds, game consoles, action figures, clothing, plush toys, etc etc. This place will scratch your itch. Can't recommend enough.

The owner offered to "tickle my pickle" (I'm not sure what he meant but I wasn't comfortable, then…read morewhen I said no he said he "hated f****ts" would not recommend.

I am writing to echo the sentiment of several reviewers here as I too experienced an uncomfortable…read moreinteraction with who I believe is the owner. My wife and I were checking out the Ithaca Commons and leisurely walked into this comic shop. As soon as we walked in, the owner asked if we needed help. I said I was just browsing. He then asked if I collected comics. I said I used to up until 2005 but then sorta lost interest due to the over-saturation of the semi-annual crossover events, but I still have a rough knowledge of the happenings in the current Marvel Universe. The guy then started getting really pushy by suggesting that I get back into comic collecting by picking up a trade paperback. I felt pretty uncomfortable so I just kept browsing around the store. My wife tried making small talks asking if he had any nearby restaurant suggestions. He gave an awkward answer (I'm paraphrasing here), "not really, food is food." And then resumed pestering me to buy a book. If I haven't bought a comic in the last 20 years, what makes him think that I was gonna start in his shop during a trip 3000 miles away from home? I was getting really uncomfortable at this point with the awkward silence so I picked up an issue that I had mild interest in. I imagine if we walked out empty handed he would have scolded us like he did to many other people here. 2 stars instead of 1 because he wasn't awfully rude I guess. ‍

The service was outstanding! I am surprised at the variety of collectables this lil gem has to…read moreoffer. I had fun looking through all the apparel and Hats in stock. I really think that it is worth it for most anyone to stop in. You will definitely find something cool or interesting. If not, at least you can scoop up some free auto or forbes magazines in the back. I love this place! Oh and the shopping music is just another reason to stop. Great . Love it.

This review is strictly for the comic book selection…read more A large selection of books that is pretty well organized and the prices are reasonable. I try to stop in when I'm in the area.

I love going into a comic book shop and having someone be available and responsive to questions but…read morenot hovering. Hubbo found some random thing he was really excited about. I bought this Black Horror Anthology. The place was clean. The books were in good shape. We will definitely be back because we didn't have a lot of time to dig through everything.

Great little store, with great sales throughout the year. We stopped in to their $1 comic sale…read moreover at the Inn on the Lake. My husband was pleased with the finds, and the staff were friendly and helpful. Though we're not regulars, it's nice to head out to Canandaigua and see these guys once in a while.

Great little comic shop with and even better owner. Have been coming to this shop for awhile now…read more The owner is knowledgeable and an exceptionally nice guy. His weekend crew is just as nice. Good selection, great prices on back issues and graphic novels. Definitely a place to stop.

Very nice worker. He was very helpful, very nice and engaging with the customer. Felt supported…read morewhen looking at their wide selection. He immediately knew where certain comics where just by engaging in conversation. Would recommend always.